Maybe it is worth it to look at all possible roles to see which ones benefit from claiming.
1. [Mario] - (Novice Vanilla Cop) - Scum cannot block him. Redirection is also dangerous.
2. [Yoshi] - (Roleblocker) - Can effectively block the most anti-town potential role.
3. [Donkey Kong] - (Odd-Night Strong-willed Bodyguard) - Can save the strongest town PRs much more effectively.
4. [Link] - (Jack-Of-All-Trades) - 1-shot Tracker, 1-shot Doctor, 1-shot Ascetic - Doctor gets better, Tracker cannot be blocked.
5. [Samus] - (Encrypting 2-shot Sensoring Detective) - Doesn't matter much here, but scum cannot block.
6. [Fox] - (2-shot Diverter) - Not sure town should use this, but it could help redirect a nightkill, and the odds are improved with claiming.
7. [Pikachu] - (1-shot Lightning Rod) - I guess knowing what roles could be in the game makes it easier to decide when to pull the trigger.
8. [Captain Falcon] - (Modified Flavor Cop) - Mostly rendered useless unless scum decide to fakeclaim.
9. [Ness] - (1-shot Bus Driver) - See Fox. Improved, if town decides to use it.
10. [Peach] - (Self-Watcher) - We can actually use this to confirm some players as "not doing anything else", which is pretty good. Otherwise would be very meh.
11. [Bowser] - (Supersaint) - That is mostly a super anti-town role and we should make extra sure we know who it is.
12. [Zelda] - (1-shot Commuter) - This is weaker if scum knows to avoid killing them.
13. [Sheik] - (Even-Night Ninja Doctor) - Doctoring will be more effective.
14. [Ice Climbers] - (1-shot Deathproof) - I think being lynchproof is worse for town than being bulletproof is good, so we should know this.
15. [Kirby] - (Universal Backup) - Well... depends.
16. [Marth] - (Tracker) - Cannot be blocked.
17. [Jigglypuff] - (1-shot Paranoid Gun Owner) - Town can avoid targeting, so can scum. This is more dangerous in scum's hands, so this is probably good overall.
18. [Falco] - (Ascetic) - We don't have to waste actions on them. Good.
19. [Ganondorf] - (1-shot Limited Vigilante) - Well, they don't really get more information relevant to them.
20. [Luigi] - (Non-Consecutive Night Sidekick) - Same as above; this is a form of doctoring and will be better.
21. [Roy] - (Motion Detector) - We can effectively prevent scum non-targeting roles from preforming the nightkill.
22. [Dr. Mario] - (Pill Vendor) - Whoever receives the pill will know where it came from. Not sure how much of a difference that makes, but it's probably better as you'd want to target townies.
23. [Young Link] - (Jack-Of-All-Trades) - 1-shot Self-Watcher, 1-shot Roleblocker, 1-shot Bodyguard - RB and Bodyguard are more effective.
24. [Pichu] - (Weak Visitor) - Can announce target each day. If redirected, it may out the Redirector.
25. [Mr. Game and Watch] - (Neighborizer) - Can target worthwhile targets (investigative probably).
26. [Mewtwo] - (2-shot Inverting Redirector) - Having meses with scum's answers potentially. This could lead to all sorts of interesting interactions. Not really sure how it would play. It would arguably be bad for us if scum knew that Mewtwo wasn't in the game.
PPE: 3