I mean. Fine. I'm just miffed that everyone keeps assuming I have no idea what I'm talking about.
I'm sorry you felt that your competence was in any doubt! That was definitely not my intention at all, and I respect your problem-solving abilities a great deal. I'm just paranoid that you're too competent, and could possibly be nerd-sniping most of the rest of us with a cleverly-constructed puzzle.
On the believing-you're-town side of things, I'm like 92% there, but I'd really like to see one or more clear proposed solutions that state everyone's roles, say exactly what edits to the colours came from framer/godfather shots each night, and are simultaneously consistent with all four sets of results. I feel like you've satisfied yourself but are skimming over the part where you state a formal solution, and I don't understand your motivation for that, other than possibly being very busy. So I'm going to construct my own solutions, but it will take an hour or more of free time I just don't have till Monday night at this point..
Mmf.
If you'd asked me this yesterday I could have produced one immediately.
But now I'm travelling.
My motivations for not posting one so far are threefold:
1) I've already brought epic rage down onto myself for proposing solutions in the past. (See WW's behaviour)
2) the main result of my experimenting was (as I said) to note that, in the presence of x-shot framing/godfather abilities, there are far too many solutions. Hence writing out one in detail would be potentially misleading, because it gives that solution more attention than other solutions that exist.
3) the only conclusions I am currently drawing from my results right now are:
A) at least one of Dylan/EFHW/jake/chairs is scum. (This is totally immediate from iguanas claim, but also follows immediately from my n4 results.)
B) chairs is town. (Unless there was framing AND x shot godfather used on n1) This follows from my n1+n4 results, but I discovered it only by trying all the possibilities in my excel sheet. I'm more than happy for people to check this themselves, but I can't explain my reasoning because it was literally just a matter of checking every possibility. (He could be permanent godfather, but that guarantees from n4 that dylan/jake/Efhw is scum anyway.)
Neither of those points above are supported by my posting a solution.
I will happily do a solution for you but will be limited access for quite some time; you'll probably beat me to it.
The main thing I remember about the solutions I came up with in my fiddling was that gkrieg/awaclus was 1 shot godfather on n3 in all the ones I came up with.
Really, though, not sure what you gain from seeing ONE solution unless you can prove that it's the only one (which is never going to happen if you allow for x-shot framing/godfather abilities)
Author
Topic: RMM47: Rewind Mafia 2 (Game over!) (Read 228100 times)