SkumpyDay 1:
- Usual Skumpy start. Now I am basing that off of all of one other game played with him, but he does the set up break down thing and block posts and etc.
- Literally accuses like... everyone at one point or another. Which to me comes off as towny. But then....
-
Gets on XXR, then on Dylan/Andrew split, and then like 2 hours out does that whole weird unvote thing. Brings the 5-5 split to a 5 Andrew - 4 Dylan. Dunno what to make of this. We know now that Dylan was Town, so I think it looks mildly suspicious that he didn't go for voting Andrew instead of an unvote or just not changing at all. But more than anything it really comes off as towny, because if he were skum buddies with Andrew I think the options were to get on the bus for Andrew or to stay on Dylan... Unvoting all together just reeks of uncertainty, and imo uncertainty a lot of the time can = Town.Day 2:
- Opens with the "10 Questions" bit. Lots of different angles but the one he pursues is the Andrew Town vs Andrew Skum and what does that mean scenario.
- Does a huge re read list - gives lurkers a lot of credit, unsure of pretty much everyone, votes for XXR in the end.
- #696 comes off as skummy to me. I don't really have like a reason for it, it just like reads oddly and overly crafted.
- Claims he would Neighbor Faust, give me a huge town read. This is directly after the post where he ends with defending not giving town cred to anyone.
- More town points given to me, but more importantly, in this middle bit of Day 2, he makes a case for E!. I find this important, because I think that LL switching out to Teproc caused a lot of confusion. Teproc landed on me, but also made a huge case for E!. It speaks town cred to Skumpy imo that he beat Teproc to the punch in regards to making a case vs E! (even though E! was town).
- Spends the end of the day kind of defending the LL/Teproc switch and saying it makes him not want to vote Teproc all that much. This goes on over quite some time to be fair, and then he eventually puts Teproc at L-1.
- Should be noted that 2 days in a row he was the first one to point out the vote count mistakes prior to the "accidental" hammer.
Day 3:
- Usual Skumpy start to day. Looks over the probabilities of roles, talks about the pros and cons of claims, etc.
- #868 stands out for the opening line where he talks about the uncertainty of "one skum being able to carry out multiple actions". while the rules are clearly stated in the set up, I do feel like Skum!Skumpy would of been aware of the situation.
- Starts to show like genuine frustration at the amount his unvote on day 1 was being looked into by everyone (specifically Space and myself).
- Another big re read post. Ends it by going back on the E! train.
- When the E! wagon gets to L-1 he unvotes. States he is still good with it (and of course he was the hammer in the end). Goes to GK in the interim.
- Starts up the whole Skum Team pairing thing while he is on GK and we are at a stall. Comes off as towny, trying to skum hunt when people are being quiet.
- Starts to make a case for Awaclus, then goes with the "more info to be gained from E!", and eventually hammers E!.
Day 4:
- Opens with the relaxed posts about Vig/Not Vig. Andrew is reading as skummy, and I see his point, but I don't want to disregard all the previous town reads I have on him from previous days because of this.
- And lastly, I think that I totally disagree with his recent post regarding the fact that he is still alive today. If anything I would of expected him to wake up alive today. I feel like Skum could use the string of odd vote patterns and responses to set him up quite well. That being said, he could also be skum and that is why he is alive, and the odd vote patterns are in fact actually skummy
All in all for Skumpy - I am just confused. He is like my definition of my middle man at this point. I can find good reasons and bad reasons for like all of his actions. When he talks he seems to genuinely try to be skum hunting the majority of the time, but when he votes, given the info we have now of flips, it seems extremely well calculated.