Nobody has responded to my case on mcmc at all, I don't get it. I mean it seems like besides me the only people to suspect him at all were ash and I think Robz and maybe WW.
And while rereading a little bit I found these during twilight:
Andrew consistently having a scum read on me and still looking for scummy things I might be doing throughout our recent discussion and post flip feels super towny to me.
Want to lynch: ash, witherweaver, pps
Could be convinced: Joseph, dylan
Don't want to lynch based on my ability to read later: robz, TWM
Townie: eevee, idp, schadd, Andrew
Evolution of reads
Want to lynch: ash, Joseph, dylan
Could be convinced: pps, idp, witherweaver
Wish I didn't like you people so darn much be more alignment indicative: robz, eevee
Townie: twm, schadd, Andrew
Revolution of reads
Got lynched: Joseph (wagon) mcmcsalot, Witherweaver, Robz888, schadd, Eevee, AndrewisFTTW, pingpongsam
Scummy scum(off wagon): ash, dylan, idp
Keeping an eye on you killers(on wagon): eevee, pps, robz, witherweaver
Do more: TWM
Townie: schadd, Andrew
Consistent town read on me even AFTER the lynch. And now he says:
So I have more of a scum read on andrew then I remembered.
Yes, earlier I said reads change and that's normal and reads shouldn't be suspect just by themselves. But he said he finds me scummy for my vote and yet he had a strong townread on me AFTER my vote. It just looks like he didn't like me suspecting him and so he decided he didn't find me towny at all anymore. a.k.a. OMGUS
Anyway, I guess I'll post some reads for you guys:
schadd - Strong town - I don't know anything about him and even though he's been kinda lurking and joking and whatever, he seems like he is thinking critically and providing solid questions and feedback when he does post. I think he'd be the kind of person to be all-in and trying to lead town if he was scum.
TWM - Slight scum - At the beginning of the day I said I thought out of the three off wagon people he was the scummiest, but there wasn't really much content to analyze. Since then he's been posting pretty good stuff, especially his last three posts. But it feels like he's only starting to get more active now that there's a wagon that would lead to a lynch. I know D1 he was working and that's fine, but early today I don't think he was as active as he is now, and there's been plenty to talk about all day.
IDPTG - Null - Can't remember anything of note from him, I found him towny during my brief reread of the three people off wagon but again, he's just not putting much out there.
Robz - Slight town - Can't really form a read on someone who doesn't post. That said I think scum!Robz would be super active.
pps - Scum - That quickhammer just really rubs me the wrong way. And the way he jumped on my wagon was so sheepy. It seems like he's not really interested in engaging in debates and serious discussion on anything and he's more interested in distancing himself from everyone and doing his own thing, possibly so we can't trace anything back to him the whole game.
Eevee - Null - I guess he's providing good analysis sometimes? But other times it feels like he's just reacting to what other people say instead of coming up with his own opinions and observations. I could be wrong but that's just my recollection. I can't read him.
WW - Null - I would expect WW to be more active and engaged regardless of alignment. I really have no idea what his gameplan is this game and I'm pretty surprised he's as apathetic as he seems. It's pretty disappointing, honestly. I can't even say I'm upset, just disappointed that we don't have WW providing solid content like I remember him doing so often.
mcmc - Strong scum - Everyone knows how I feel about mcmc by now.
Dylan - Slight scum - I found him pretty towny the beginning of the day and since then he's had some good posts but I feel like he's been jumping votes the whole game, at least D2 since he wasn't around much D1. It's worth a reread but I just get the feeling that everything he says is hedgy and he doesn't commit to much, like he's trying to be very careful with everything he posts. Again, I could be wrong but that's just the feeling I get from him at this point.