Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[schadd]

Hmm

i'm not sure i follow

Kill target speculation is good wifom to play.

[Robz888]

Dylan, IDP, TWM: Has to be scum there, unless everybody is off wagon.

[Eevee]

Why and why?

he made a comment that was unhelpful other than making it seem like he wasn't the one planning the nightkill.


i should go ahead and make the case of my thoughts yesterDay at some point

Which comment?

[Eevee]

I can do a post count, one minute.

[schadd]

Which comment?

Very well done ash, drawing the nightkill as the VT is a heroic feat.

mcmc and pps did it as well, yours sounded the most politician-y to me. i am leaning scum on pps rn as well

[Eevee]

schadd: 78
Robz: 26
Eevee: 43
mcmc: 76
IDPTG: 26
PPS: 69
WW: 70
Dylan: 15
TWM: 15
Andrew: 34



Surprised to see WW so high, Dylan so low. Don't remember a lot from Andrew despite the middling post count.

[Eevee]

Which comment?

Very well done ash, drawing the nightkill as the VT is a heroic feat.

mcmc and pps did it as well, yours sounded the most politician-y to me. i am leaning scum on pps rn as well

I think others can attest I try to make a point of being nice to people and giving credit where I think it's due regardless of my alignment. Especially true for ashersky because we've had some bad blood in the past.

[schadd]

Yeah, I guess. But I do think it's likely ash is simply the real UB.

eevee, would you like to comment on this?

[Eevee]

Yeah, I guess. But I do think it's likely ash is simply the real UB.

eevee, would you like to comment on this?

Very glad to have been very wrong! Total misread from my part, you guys were all the voice of reason.

[mcmcsalot]

schadd: 78
Mcmc:76
Ww: 70
Pps: 69
Eevee: 43
Andrew 34
Robz: 26
IDPTG: 26
Dylan: 15
TWM: 15

Yay! So as robz pointed out unless all scum was on wagon one of idp, dylan, and TWM has to be scum. They also have extremely low content.

I think vote: idp is the most likely, he has been around and lurky, I would guess dylan as another scum as well.

[pingpongsam]

Vote: mcmc

[Robz888]

Vote: Dylan

[Eevee]

Vote: Dylan

[LaLight]

21-2, 13+2, 21+1, 13+2, 21-1, 8+1, 13+1, 8-1. 13, 21, 3, 8, 21+2, 13+2, 21+2.

Vote Count 2.1

Eevee (2): Witherweaver, schadd
IDontPlayThisGame (1): mcmcsalot
mcmcsalot (1): pingpongsam
Dylan32 (2): Robz888, Eevee

Not Voting (3+1): IDontPlayThisGame, Dylan32, AndrewisFTTW, The_Wine_Merchant


With 13-3 alive it takes 5+1 to lynch.
Day 2 ends Monday, Mar 21-1 at 1am FT.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

schadd: 78
Mcmc:76
Ww: 70
Pps: 69
Eevee: 43
Andrew 34
Robz: 26
IDPTG: 26
Dylan: 15
TWM: 15

Yay! So as robz pointed out unless all scum was on wagon one of idp, dylan, and TWM has to be scum. They also have extremely low content.

I think vote: idp is the most likely, he has been around and lurky, I would guess dylan as another scum as well.

I've been able to read the thread more than I've been able to post in it.

Yeah, I guess. But I do think it's likely ash is simply the real UB.

eevee, would you like to comment on this?

Very glad to have been very wrong! Total misread from my part, you guys were all the voice of reason.

I don't particularly like this although I'm having trouble putting my finger on why. The "voice of reason" bit seems like a strange choice of words but it doesn't seem inherently anything to me.

[Eevee]

I don't particularly like this although I'm having trouble putting my finger on why. The "voice of reason" bit seems like a strange choice of words but it doesn't seem inherently anything to me.

Had I been right, I'd totally be gloating about it. Only fair I beat myself up a little now that I wasn't.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Yes

Vote: WW

Vote: mcmc

Vote: Dylan

Vote: Dylan

I mean, maybe it's just me but I like to see some substance from votes.

Also, I like Robz's idea of there being scum off wagon. There's no way the whole scum team was on the lynch wagon yesterday. I'll do a reread.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Not sure what happened to the first sentence I typed in my last post. I just commented on there being a lot of votes which little to back them up, which I personally don't like.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Also, IDPTG, TWM, and Dylan were pretty much the lurkiest people yesterday. It doesn't give them a pass but they were likely absent at critical times. Ok reread now.

[Robz888]

I mean, maybe it's just me but I like to see some substance from votes.

Me too. I voted WW because of the lack of substance to his vote, actually.

But then I voted for Dylan because we should find the scum off wagon, and I like Dylan more than IDP for... reasons.

Mostly for the reason that mcmc preferred IDP and it made me uncomfortable.

[pingpongsam]

Yes

Vote: WW

Vote: mcmc

Vote: Dylan

Vote: Dylan

I mean, maybe it's just me but I like to see some substance from votes.

Also, I like Robz's idea of there being scum off wagon. There's no way the whole scum team was on the lynch wagon yesterday. I'll do a reread.

Simple, I already had suspicions on mcmc and now I know that his wagon yesterday had 3 confirmed (to me) town on it. Also, mcmc was on wagon for the Jacob mislynch (yeah, so was I but we're talking about from my perspective).

[AndrewisFTTW]

Ok Dylan first. Here are his last posts before the lynch yesterday:

I don't actually think we should lynch you, mcmc. But we need informational wagoning.

I don't understand this statement.

I won't speak for Robz but to me this means we don't need a lynch so much as we need to see where people position on ever growing wagons. I mean the ones that go to lynch are going to be most informative but as people vote on and off wagons we get information, especially in retrospect.

Yeah this is how I took it also.

And lol TWM. Early I try to post little bits of reads so people know where I stand unless I see something I think is really strong evidence. Then I will post a lot more. More often than not, I'm incorrect about whatever conclusion I come to when that happens though, sadly (i.e. schadd circa squid girl, gkrieg circa stranger things). The only thing I think I've actually gotten right recently was protecting gkrieg as the bodyguard in squid girl mafia. Nailed it. not that it helped much...

Mcmc. If the DAMA still stands, are you scum?

(Not sure what DAMA is)

So i'm 99% sure mcmc was online when I asked that question and then left without answering. I'm not going to base a read on that, but it should at least be on the record as a small note.

This makes me think he's town. I know other people (WW and mcmc... as usual) were a little suspicious of this:

So i'm 99% sure Dylan was online when I asked that question and then left without answering. I'm not going to base a read on that, but it should at least be on the record as a small note.

I do not like this post.

He actually meant this:

This one:

So i'm 99% sure mcmc was online when I asked that question and then left without answering. I'm not going to base a read on that, but it should at least be on the record as a small note.

And then:

So i'm 99% sure mcmc was online when I asked that question and then left without answering. I'm not going to base a read on that, but it should at least be on the record as a small note.

Dylan, would you like to explain this?

I would actually like to know how you(dylan) came to think this as well.

Again, I think this is pretty damn towny to me. Though I could see it as new scum grasping at straws to find a case (or bus his partner).

[pingpongsam]

DAMA = Drunk, ask me anything

[AndrewisFTTW]

Ok I just reread IDPTG from the beginning of D1 through twilight and found nothing of note. His posting was so sporadic, there were a couple setup comments about the UB, a couple comments about not lynching ash, a couple "stop joking" posts, and that's pretty much it. Null.

DAMA = Drunk, ask me anything

Right, thanks.

[Eevee]

Why is that towny? I think scum is more likely to throw vague suspicions around (and I also think that regardless of his alignment mcmc probably just didn't see the question, I don't think scummcmc-would try to dodge like that).

I actually reread Dylan before my vote, but just didn't have time to type a longer post. I saw low activity (most of the 15 posts were not game-related) non-towny voting, I particularly disagreed with him suspecting mcmc as the main contribution because I thought mcmc looked towny all day.