Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[J Reggie]

I don't think a thread like this exists yet. The point of this game is to say a thing that happened in a specific mafia game, and the first person to guess which game that was from wins the round. They then get to start a new round, or they can pass and someone else can start a round.

Obviously there's nothing stopping you from searching through the games, but it's more fun if you don't. Maybe if you get the answer without searching for it, you can say so. The criteria for questions aren't really strict, just something that would point to a specific game. Also, I don't know if this should go in mafia game threads or non-mafia game threads, so let me know what you think.

I'll start with a fairly easy one:
Gkrieg and Ashersky claim masons as scum. Go!

[gkrieg13]

Fan fiction mafia

Edit: I can think of a lot of good ones that are personal, like my first ____.  Does that work?

[J Reggie]

Fan fiction mafia

Edit: I can think of a lot of good ones that are personal, like my first ____.  Does that work?

Sure!

[Roadrunner7671]

Ha ha. Looks like fun!

[gkrieg13]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

[Roadrunner7671]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

X-Shots Mafia? Maybe?

[gkrieg13]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

X-Shots Mafia? Maybe?

Nope!

[LaLight]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

Was there no such a game? :-P

[Roadrunner7671]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

X-Shots Mafia? Maybe?

Nope!

Trick question: You've never had a correct vig shot

[Roadrunner7671]

Nooooo LaLight

[Witherweaver]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

Mistborn.

[gkrieg13]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

Mistborn.

Ding ding ding

[gkrieg13]

I have a question then: where was the first game I shot correctly as a vig?

X-Shots Mafia? Maybe?

Nope!

Trick question: You've never had a correct vig shot

I almost won BSG with taking down the scum team myself thank you very much.

[silverspawn]

A player claims scum in a serious game when it's not yet over.

[Haddock]

A player claims scum in a serious game when it's not yet over.

Not your turn!  Tut tut.

But, like, um, many many games recently, it seems?

[Roadrunner7671]

A player claims scum in a serious game when it's not yet over.

Duel Mafia! It was Joseph!

[Robz888]

A player claims scum in a serious game when it's not yet over.

Yuma did so in Deepspace 9 Mafia. There were three people left, and is only chance was to convince the townie that the third player, me was scum from a different faction. Me and that townie lynched yuma, and I won as scum from the other faction.

[J Reggie]

There's also Sherlock mafia. That may have been what he was going for.

[Haddock]

Seprix also did it recently.  Speed Dating, I think?

[LaLight]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

[ehunt]

A Serial Killer claims Serial Killer

[ehunt]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

voltgloss MIX although this is debatable

[LaLight]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

voltgloss MIX although this is debatable

My one isn't debatable at all

[Robz888]

A Serial Killer claims Serial Killer

Modern Community, that massive game with a million players.

[Roadrunner7671]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

The Walking Dead Mafia?

[LaLight]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

The Walking Dead Mafia?

No
Well, maybe but every townie player remained full townie player in the end

[silverspawn]

A player claims scum in a serious game when it's not yet over.

Yuma did so in Deepspace 9 Mafia. There were three people left, and is only chance was to convince the townie that the third player, me was scum from a different faction. Me and that townie lynched yuma, and I won as scum from the other faction.

I don't actually know what the answer is because I've only heard players talk about it, but this is probably it.

There were other scum claims but no serious ones.

[Witherweaver]

A Serial Killer claims Serial Killer

A Mafia claims Serial Killer~

[Witherweaver]

A Serial Killer claims Serial Killer

A Mafia claims Serial Killer~

Also, TwistedArcher claimed SK as SK in Wheel of Time.  He was slightly caught, though.

[mail-mi]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

LotR 2, rmm10.

First game I didn't get lynched in?

[LaLight]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

LotR 2, rmm10.

First game I didn't get lynched in?

M25 Mean girls?

[mail-mi]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

LotR 2, rmm10.

First game I didn't get lynched in?

M25 Mean girls?

Nope, I was the final mislynch I believe.

[LaLight]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

LotR 2, rmm10.

First game I didn't get lynched in?

M25 Mean girls?

Nope, I was the final mislynch I believe.

Should we go Back to Basics then?

[mail-mi]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

LotR 2, rmm10.

First game I didn't get lynched in?

M25 Mean girls?

Nope, I was the final mislynch I believe.

Should we go Back to Basics then?

Nope.

[sudgy]

I claimed SK as SK right before I got lynched once.

Anyway, here's one that I don't quite remember what exact game it was: the vigilante killed basically all the scum and won the game almost singlehandedly.

[ashersky]

I claimed SK as SK right before I got lynched once.

Anyway, here's one that I don't quite remember what exact game it was: the vigilante killed basically all the scum and won the game almost singlehandedly.

Chairs in Dynasty Warriors.

[iguanaiguana]

Every protective role in the game targets the same player N1 and fails.

#notmyturn

[Haddock]

Every protective role in the game targets the same player N1 and fails.

#notmyturn

That happened in every game ever that contained no protective roles.

[pacovf]

Scum can quickhammer for a flawless win, but instead loses the game.

EDIT: Err sorry didn't see one was going on, sorry.

[Joseph2302]

A Serial Killer claims Serial Killer

I did it the only game I've been SK

[faust]

Scum can quickhammer for a flawless win, but instead loses the game.

EDIT: Err sorry didn't see one was going on, sorry.

Flavorless Mafia -.-

[Witherweaver]

Mafia gets shot by both SK and Vig in the same night.

[chairs]

I claimed SK as SK right before I got lynched once.

Anyway, here's one that I don't quite remember what exact game it was: the vigilante killed basically all the scum and won the game almost singlehandedly.

Chairs in Dynasty Warriors.

I can't help but STILL be smug about that. Vig is basically my favorite role in Mafia and I think the one I do best with by far.

[Jimmmmm]

May i pleeeease?)

A player wins a game though part of his role was Sk and there were townies left (2 or 3 i think.)

Gollum! Gollum!

[Seprix]

My first game.

[silverspawn]

Don't remember how it's called but you were scum and inaccurately townread.

[Witherweaver]

Member of a losing team gets MVP.  This just happened, obviously, in Rewind Mafia, but I believe there have been a couple other cases.

[gkrieg13]

Member of a losing team gets MVP.  This just happened, obviously, in Rewind Mafia, but I believe there have been a couple other cases.

Soap opera

[ashersky]

Member of a losing team gets MVP.  This just happened, obviously, in Rewind Mafia, but I believe there have been a couple other cases.

Soap opera

M15 was the first time ever.

[silverspawn]

Blarnia

[mcmcsalot]

I claimed SK as SK right before I got lynched once.

Anyway, here's one that I don't quite remember what exact game it was: the vigilante killed basically all the scum and won the game almost singlehandedly.

Chairs in Dynasty Warriors.

Oh that was fun!

[Eevee]

Let's revive the game!

What was the first scumslip in f.ds mafia?

[mcmcsalot]

Let's revive the game!

What was the first scumslip in f.ds mafia?

Joth in mafia III

[Eevee]

Correct! (I think.) As a serial killer too!

[mcmcsalot]

Correct! (I think.) As a serial killer too!

Mafia, he much like you in the most recent game mistook his fake claim from the night before and provided a cop result insted of a rolecop result I believe

[cayvie]

What was the first M-series game where town no lynched D1 and went on to win the game?