Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[drsteelhammer]

Hi everyone,

Here you can find your opponent in round 1. Please send a PM to that person immediately to schedule your match. If your opponent doesn't respond to your messages after a few days, please contact one of the mods. The deadline for round 1 is October 9th, round 2 will begin the day after.

After you've finished playing, please post your results here. Remember: Six games, each one is starting player three times. If someone wins 3,5 matches, you can stop playing. Make sure to read the rules carefully before playing your first match.

Please use this thread only to post results and questions directly related to a specific result. Use the rules thread for rules questions, or game reports to discuss matches.

Here is a link to the full bracket: http://challonge.com/fds_Championship16

gl & hf!
       

1	zporiri	vs.	Ravi Vasudevan (ravi)
2	Jean-Michel	vs.	dorakeen
3	Polk5440	vs.	greenloweawesome
4	markusin	vs.	Conor McCarthy (abagofit)
5	DG	vs.	idontplaythisgame
6	Micha1980	vs.	andrewzom
7	2.71828.....	vs.	GregDC
8	Shvegait	vs.	Graeme808
9	mith	vs.	Orange
10	drsteelhammer	vs.	Isra3lite
11	Simon (DK)	vs.	karenttrouble
12	Lalight	vs.	rchandra (arcee)
13	Horist	vs.	dornado
14	Aleimon Thimble	vs.	SirDagen (SirD)
15	Chris is me	vs.	Hertz Doughnut
16	Dunduks	vs.	missouriben
17	Lekkit	vs.	luliin
18	Saaket	vs.	maskins
19	Burning Skull	vs.	Howlard (wittyhowlard)
20	aku chi	vs.	4est
21	tufftaeh	vs.	nuceria
22	gloures	vs.	love
23	jimbo-2- (jimbo)	vs.	heron
24	A Drowned Kernel	vs.	jhust
25	breppert (SettingFraming)	vs.	Feirefiz
26	amoffett11	vs.	tyrcho
27	FirstP (first)	vs.	Zent
28	Calamitas	vs.	MtMagus
29	Limetime	vs.	d.thomas0193
30	michaeljb	vs.	sillle14
31	popsofkf (popsofctown)	vs.	AHoppy
32	Silverfinger	vs.	geal77
33	singletee	vs.	Jeremy Toeman (jtoeman)
34	Jeb	vs.	diedre91
35	Robz888	vs.	Martinello76
36	Beyond Awesome	vs.	Philothea
37	Haddock	vs.	Diggaro
38	ced	vs.	Lord Commander Snow (KMueller)
39	The Do-Operator	vs.	G. Lazalde (bardo)
40	Assemble Meme (assemble_me)	vs.	dominus
41	gkrieg	vs.	Squirezucco (dmazzucco)
42	tracer (traces around)	vs.	Petrovic
43	Qvist	vs.	Hawkeye(JeremiahP)
44	Accatitippi	vs.	Cascadestyler

byes for the first round: Stef, Seprix, Psyduck, gamesou, Derg17, SCSN, Titandrake, schadd, jsh357, faust, MicQsenoch, Mikey the Great (Miked), vsiewnar, smcrtorchs, Rabid, danbrooks (dedicateddan), ceviri (tailred), Awaclus, markus, Dingan

[dmazzucco]

How do I reach out to my opponent so that (s)he can crush me?

[Titandrake]

How do I reach out to my opponent so that (s)he can crush me?

To sign up, you had to be a forum member. You can contact other forum members through the PM function.

To do so, go to that member's profile and click the "Send PM" link, or from the top bar, click "My Messages", then "Messages > New Message" from the inbox.

jsh also made a Discord channel for this tournament, which you can use for real-time coordinating.

[singletee]

Use the member search function to find your opponent's profile. Be sure to check the "Search by Goko username" option.

[assemble_me]

I've added the forum names for those where they differ from the MF names to the bracket and the pairings, so everybody should be able to contact their opponents now

[Lekkit]

So me against the wife in the first round.

[drsteelhammer]

So me against the wife in the first round.

rigged

I hope your KC-Possession engine doesn't cause any marriage trouble!

[luliin]

I will beat you hubbie!

[diedre91]

match 34
diedre91 4:2 Jeb

[luliin]

Wife vs Husband ends with a (not so) crushing victory for #TeamWife.

luliin 4 - Lekkit 3

[gloures]

gloures 4 - 0 love

[Dunduks]

Dunduks 4 missouriben 3

[Aleimon Thimble]

Aleimon Thimble - SirDagen: 4.5 - 1.5

I know we could stop playing after reaching 3.5, but we both wanted to play that sixth game, so yeah.

By the way, even though SirDagen only won one game, it was the most amazing win ever. He beat me with an engine on a Cultist board without trashing WHILE IGNORING CULTIST. I'm still amazed by it. Will definitely post a log soon.

[assemble_me]

Aleimon Thimble - SirDagen: 4.5 - 1.5

In case you wonder, challonge doesn't allow floating point numbers so it's 45-15 there 

[SirD]

In case you wonder, challonge doesn't allow floating point numbers so it's 45-15 there 

That is very strange to me. So next time you have to double all scores...

[Accatitippi]

In case you wonder, challonge doesn't allow floating point numbers so it's 45-15 there 

That is very strange to me. So next time you have to double all scores...

Might be better to multiply them by ten. 35-15 feels clearer than 7-3.

[aku_chi]

aku chi 3.5 - 0.5 4est

[Horist]

Horist 4 vs Dornado 0

[Chris is me]

So this is complicated.

First game ended on opponent disconnect. I think I was ahead enough to be the clear winner, he does not and wants a replay, so that game is indeterminate. I'll PM the log shortly. I started that game. Then we played the other 5 games, which reached 3-2 his favor. For Game 7, I won.

So: Chris is me 3.? - Hertz Doughnut 3

[Limetime]

So this is complicated.

First game ended on opponent disconnect. I think I was ahead enough to be the clear winner, he does not and wants a replay, so that game is indeterminate. I'll PM the log shortly. I started that game. Then we played the other 5 games, which reached 3-2 his favor. For Game 7, I won.

So: Chris is me 3.? - Hertz Doughnut 3

Another thing the mods can do is watch the stream.

[Deadlock39]

So this is complicated.

First game ended on opponent disconnect. I think I was ahead enough to be the clear winner, he does not and wants a replay, so that game is indeterminate. I'll PM the log shortly. I started that game. Then we played the other 5 games, which reached 3-2 his favor. For Game 7, I won.

So: Chris is me 3.? - Hertz Doughnut 3

5.1 If a game ends due to an unintentional disconnect from the game, discuss the gamestate with your opponent
5.11 If the game was still close, simply replay the game.
5.12 If the lead was almost insurmountable for one player, award a win to the player who was ahead.
5.2 If you have trouble coming to an agreement, put the match "on hold" and message the admins with the situation that occured. Finish the rest of your five remaining matches and if nobody exceeded 3,5 points, await the moderators' decision.

Chris and I had a thrilling, close contest, and this write-up is accurate. One of the nicest people I've ever encountered.  All I wanted to add is my pov that, while I admit Chris was in a better position at the time of the unfortunate disconnect in game 1, I do not think the position was "almost insurmountable" (rule 5.12). (Chris purchased the first Province, and on my next turn, my client bugged, while I had a hand that was likely to score my first Province.)  I suppose it's up to the admins to make that assessment. If it is possible, I would be happy to finish that game from that point on.

Second, neither of us consulted rule 5.2 during the match to notice that we were supposed to put the match on hold before playing game 7. Chris won game 7.

Let us know how to proceed.

Kind regards,
David

We will look this over. I am willing to facilitate playing this game out over Skype if you would both like to take that route (and the other mods approve the idea).

[Micha1980]

So this is complicated.

First game ended on opponent disconnect. I think I was ahead enough to be the clear winner, he does not and wants a replay, so that game is indeterminate. I'll PM the log shortly. I started that game. Then we played the other 5 games, which reached 3-2 his favor. For Game 7, I won.

So: Chris is me 3.? - Hertz Doughnut 3

5.1 If a game ends due to an unintentional disconnect from the game, discuss the gamestate with your opponent
5.11 If the game was still close, simply replay the game.
5.12 If the lead was almost insurmountable for one player, award a win to the player who was ahead.
5.2 If you have trouble coming to an agreement, put the match "on hold" and message the admins with the situation that occured. Finish the rest of your five remaining matches and if nobody exceeded 3,5 points, await the moderators' decision.

Chris and I had a thrilling, close contest, and this write-up is accurate. One of the nicest people I've ever encountered.  All I wanted to add is my pov that, while I admit Chris was in a better position at the time of the unfortunate disconnect in game 1, I do not think the position was "almost insurmountable" (rule 5.12). (Chris purchased the first Province, and on my next turn, my client bugged, while I had a hand that was likely to score my first Province.)  I suppose it's up to the admins to make that assessment. If it is possible, I would be happy to finish that game from that point on.

Second, neither of us consulted rule 5.2 during the match to notice that we were supposed to put the match on hold before playing game 7. Chris won game 7.

Let us know how to proceed.

Kind regards,
David

What about playing the LAST game for the final win?

[Chris is me]

I'm definitely willing to replay the game from the point of disconnection with Skype and proxy physical cards,, but I do think my lead is almost insurmountable. Mods feel free to PM me if you'd like me to explain how I feel the game would have played out.

[singletee]

How do I reach out to my opponent so that (s)he can crush me?

To sign up, you had to be a forum member. You can contact other forum members through the PM function.

To do so, go to that member's profile and click the "Send PM" link, or from the top bar, click "My Messages", then "Messages > New Message" from the inbox.

jsh also made a Discord channel for this tournament, which you can use for real-time coordinating.

In case a PM doesn't work, you might try clicking the envelope to send an email (if they've listed theirs). My opponent had not realized the tournament had started!

[LaLight]

Lalight-rchandra (Arcee) 4-2

[Deadlock39]

I'm definitely willing to replay the game from the point of disconnection with Skype and proxy physical cards,, but I do think my lead is almost insurmountable. Mods feel free to PM me if you'd like me to explain how I feel the game would have played out.

Here's the game in question.  At disconnect I had [Fishing Village, Fishing Village, Wharf, Wharf] in duration and my hand was [Fishing Village, City, Copper, Wharf, Copper] + [Estate, Estate, Estate, Wharf] (drawn from duration Wharves).

Kind regards,
David

We have reviewed the game log, and feel that the game result is not clear enough to make a call for one player. How well the end game is played could definitely determine the winner. The decks are quite similar, but it appears Chris has some advantage at this point.

I feel the most fair way to proceed is to continue the game from the point of the disconnect, which I would be happy to facilitate if both players are willing. Chris has expressed willingness to participate in this. Is this something you are willing to do David? Feel free to contact me via PM with any questions about the process I am proposing, or to arrange a schedule.

If we can not arrange to play the end of the disconnected match, our only other option is unfortunately a rematch. 

[drsteelhammer]

drsteelhammer 4-0 isra3lite

Thanks for the games!

[markusin]

markusin 4 - 1 Conor McCarthy (abagofit)

Good games.

[mith]

mith 3.5-0.5 Orange

He had connection issues during the 4th game, and offered to call it a draw despite a not insignificant lead.

[Chris is me]

Hertz_Doughnut graciously conceded via PM, so the "official" score is now Chris is me 4 - Hertz Doughnut 3

[Accatitippi]

Accatitippi 4 - cascadestyler 3

Very fun and engaging games, despite a couple of slower boards.

[Hertz_Doughnut]

Hertz_Doughnut graciously conceded via PM, so the "official" score is now Chris is me 4 - Hertz Doughnut 3

Correct.  Best of luck, Chris!

[SettingFraming]

breppert (SettingFraming) 4 : 2 Feirefiz

[Shvegait]

Shvegait 4-1 Graeme808

[The Do-Operator]

The Do-Operator 4 - 2 G. Lazalde

[Haddock]

Diggaro 4 - 0 Haddock.

[Diggaro]

Diggaro 4. Haddock 0.

[Haddock]

Diggaro 4. Haddock 0.

Lol.  I totally wanted to see that score up here twice

[assemble_me]

Lol.  I totally wanted to see that score up here twice

You could have just deleted your post Btw: Now it's here three times

[tufftaeh]

tufftaeh 4 - 0 nuceria

[Micha1980]

Micha1980 - andrewzom 4 : 1

[Beyond Awesome]

Beyond Awesome 4 Philothea 0

[traces Around]

tracer 4 -1 Petrovic

[Seprix]

God luck to everyone.

edit: I meant to write good luck, but God luck seems better anyways, so I'll keep it.

[DG]

DG 4 - 1 Idontplaythisgame

[gloures]

Ok, this is a round 2 game since Tufftaeh asked me to play our Round 2 match early since he is going to travel next week. I´ll post it here, is it ok?

gloures 4 - 2 tufftaeh

[tufftaeh]

Ummm, I have a result for round 2 already - hope that is allowed. (I'm travelling next week and gloures graciously agreed to play this week already.)

tufftaeh 2 - 4 gloures

Edit: ninja'd

[heron]

heron 1-4 jimbo

[jimbo]

Jimbo2
jimbo2 (4) - Heron(1)

[Zent]

Hi,

My understanding is that round I goes all the way until Sunday (included) - correct?
I've been trying to contact my opponent with no luck throughout the week (pm + email). I will keep trying, just wanted to check until when did we have time. (I'd really hate to win by walkover as odds are I should likely lose given rankings).

Thanks!

[Titandrake]

Jimbo2
jimbo2 (4) - Heron(1)

heron 1-4 jimbo

Ummm, I have a result for round 2 already - hope that is allowed. (I'm travelling next week and gloures graciously agreed to play this week already.)

tufftaeh 2 - 4 gloures

Edit: ninja'd

Ok, this is a round 2 game since Tufftaeh asked me to play our Round 2 match early since he is going to travel next week. I´ll post it here, is it ok?

gloures 4 - 2 tufftaeh

Diggaro 4. Haddock 0.

Diggaro 4 - 0 Haddock.

I'm going to suggest the convention of having just the winner report results. The winner gets a little victory lap, the loser can run away from the thread in shame, and there's less spam. Everyone wins! (Well, actually, only 50% get to win, but you get the idea.)

[drsteelhammer]

Hi,

My understanding is that round I goes all the way until Sunday (included) - correct?
I've been trying to contact my opponent with no luck throughout the week (pm + email). I will keep trying, just wanted to check until when did we have time. (I'd really hate to win by walkover as odds are I should likely lose given rankings).

Thanks!

Sunday is included, yes. If you already emailed him, there is nothing further you can do so don't worry too much about that. We much rather have an underdog in round 2 than a no-show

[d.thomas0193]

Match 29

Limetime 4-0 d.thomas0193

[Calamitas]

Calamitas 4:2 MtMagus

[Polk5440]

Polk5440 defeats greenloweawesome 3.5 to 1.5. Fun games!

[greenloweawesome]

Polk5440 defeats greenloweawesome 3.5 to 1.5. Fun games!

Truth on both counts. Thanks Polk5440

[dominus]

assemble_me won against dominus (me), 4-0.  Good luck to the rest of you!

[zporiri]

       
4 zporiri - Ravi Vasudevan (ravi) 2

[drsteelhammer]

Since there are only ~30 hours left: Anyone who hasn't heard of their opponent yet may report their match as cancelled in here.

If you feel like waiting a few more hours you can do that aswell, please report it after you're done waiting.

Thanks to anyone who kept us informed about their efforts of contacting their opponents during the week!

[Silverfinger]

Round 1: Unfortunately my opponent geal77 didn't respond on pms and email. I was told by drsteelhammer then i just move on to round 2.

Silverfinger

[Saaket]

I have been trying to contact my opponent Maskins for the last 2-3 days but he hasn't been responding. If he replies soon, then we will be able to play the match, otherwise we won't be able to play.

[2.71828.....]

GregDC did not respond to any of my messages to schedule our match throughout the week

[Zent]

Haven't heard from First either via email or PM. Can still wait until 2.30pm EST but after that can't do today.

[Saaket]

I can't wait any longer, as it is getting late here and I still haven't heard from Maskins. Sad that I couldn't play a match this round, I was looking forward to it :/

[dedicateddan]

Round 2 match:

Dan Brooks 4 - 1 Diedre91

[michaeljb]

Round 1, match 30

 michaeljb 4 - 2 sillle14

[Qvist]

Round 1:

Hawkeye (JeremiahP) - Qvist 0.5 - 3.5

[singletee]

Round 1, match 33: singletee 4-3 jtoeman

[gkrieg13]

gkrieg 4 - 3 Squirezzucco

[Robz888]

Robz888 4-1 Martinello