Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Joseph2302]

So, gkrieg is bad then (from my perspective)

[gkrieg13]

So, gkrieg is bad then (from my perspective)

Or WW

[Witherweaver]

Can someone correct me if I'm wrong?  No combination of E, C, D's with four letters can give two Doctors, one 1-shot doctor, and one 1-shot Cop, right?

Needs 5 letters.
EDDDD or CDDDD

Well, or EEEEE = Doctor OR Cop x2; 1 -Shot Doctor OR 1-Shot Cop.

[Witherweaver]

Man why wouldn't RR use his shot Night 1

[gkrieg13]

Pretty sure one of Gkrieg or Joseph is lying. (Possibly Schaad but I doubt it)

We have

M
V

and have to fill

1-Shot Cop
1-Shot Doctor
Doctor
Doctor

with four letters.

But from your point of view, schadd can't be lying, unless scum decided not to use strongman, or didn't kill N2

Are you sure? M V D E E E gives 2 Doctors, 1 1-shot Cop

Oh I hadn't looked at the E's.  Didn't realize they scale differently from doctor

[Witherweaver]

I would say the liar is the one that claimed to protect SS, but you're both claiming that.

[gkrieg13]

So one of Joseph, schadd, WW must be lying

I'll reread them all before I vote. 

I guess it would also be good to look at how many of the three must be lying/could be lying, because if it is just one, then we have a good chance of hitting in the VTs instead of going for the PRs.

[Witherweaver]

I mean we can write out all the possibilities with four letters, but uh I don't want to.

EEEE doesn't work.
EEE (D/C) doesn't work
EE(...) doesn't give enough Doctors
E(...) doesn't give enough Doctors either

and D's and C's don't give enough.   

[J Reggie]

wait, one of gkrieg or Joseph has to be lying, right? because they both claimed to protect SS N1.

[Joseph2302]

wait, one of gkrieg or Joseph has to be lying, right? because they both claimed to protect SS N1.

Roleblocker, could have been roleblocked. Although seems likely that one (gkrieg) is lying

[gkrieg13]

So I guess we don't even have to have 2 doctors, because scum could've just forgotten to kill.  So any number of PRs could be lying.  Really it could be a Joseph, WW, schadd team

[gkrieg13]

wait, one of gkrieg or Joseph has to be lying, right? because they both claimed to protect SS N1.

This is true if they didn't have a RB and strongman.

[J Reggie]

Oh, I forgot about RB.  Nevermind.

[gkrieg13]

wait, one of gkrieg or Joseph has to be lying, right? because they both claimed to protect SS N1.

Roleblocker, could have been roleblocked. Although seems likely that one (gkrieg) is lying

Why is me lying more probable than WW lying in your eyes?

[Joseph2302]

wait, one of gkrieg or Joseph has to be lying, right? because they both claimed to protect SS N1.

Roleblocker, could have been roleblocked. Although seems likely that one (gkrieg) is lying

Why is me lying more probable than WW lying in your eyes?

Your claim seems weird, since it's the same as mine.

I'll consider it properly tomorrow, or maybe Saturday.

[Witherweaver]

LaLight claimed IC?

[LaLight]

LaLight claimed IC?

Vt

[schadd]

i think ww lying would require at least two of {me, joseph, gkrieg} to also be lying. all we have been able to come up with (i think) as a rationale for claiming vig is that he did the scum kill and suspected that he was roleblocked (which is unlikely to happen, sorta doesn't make sense, and uh there isn't a town roleblocker but whatever) or that he knew that there were only 2/3 PRs, which had proven to be not vigilantes, and thus no-one would counter-claim. this requires that there are indeed 2/3 PRs. to me, this makes this claim to be the most likely out of anyone that isn't, in fact, me. my claim seems especially likely because of the pm that i got, blah blah et cetera.


i guess that, if i lied, then nothing became of it. it seems as though i didn't gain any credibility, place any outside suspicion, or back up anyone else's claim.


gkrieg and joseph made the exact same claim. lmao. pending further review, i would hypothesize that exactly one of them is lying, and also it seems a tad more likely to be joseph.


ok cool.

[gkrieg13]

My guess is that a probability thing of who is lying would probably not help very much

[schadd]

My guess is that a probability thing of who is lying would probably not help very much

yes there are too many arrangements here, and too much other stuff

[schadd]

or rather, nothing to be really clarified by arrangements

[Witherweaver]

LaLight claimed IC?

Vt

Right that's what I meant.

[LaLight]

well, yesterday i came to claim and didn't read any of this, then I read it before sleep but had no time to answer.

This is all confusing. My gut also tells me that here's exactly one person lying about PR. And if this is true, then scum team is {JReggie, Iguana, [lying PR]}.
I'd just propose lynching those two first. And in the process we can actually look at the PRs and their behavior.

vote: JReggie

[J Reggie]

well, yesterday i came to claim and didn't read any of this, then I read it before sleep but had no time to answer.

This is all confusing. My gut also tells me that here's exactly one person lying about PR. And if this is true, then scum team is {JReggie, Iguana, [lying PR]}.
I'd just propose lynching those two first. And in the process we can actually look at the PRs and their behavior.

vote: JReggie

Woah woah please unvote before scum have a chance to hammer me. Unless of course you're scum and that's not possible, but I think you're pretty towny so DON'T LOSE THE GAME FOR US

[LaLight]

well, yesterday i came to claim and didn't read any of this, then I read it before sleep but had no time to answer.

This is all confusing. My gut also tells me that here's exactly one person lying about PR. And if this is true, then scum team is {JReggie, Iguana, [lying PR]}.
I'd just propose lynching those two first. And in the process we can actually look at the PRs and their behavior.

vote: JReggie

Woah woah please unvote before scum have a chance to hammer me. Unless of course you're scum and that's not possible, but I think you're pretty towny so DON'T LOSE THE GAME FOR US

I'll have the time. I'm pretty every 15-20 minutes come here to look what's happening during the day.
Well, LyLo thing, I've never been here before. Ok, unvote, though I'm sure you're and II are scums. I'll make the case in an hour/two