Joseph re-read, since I forgot him last night!
Early on seems just the usual game-opening stuff.
Claims SK at #156, but I know he claims that sort of thing every game as his meta so that's null.
Yay the forum is back.
Vote: fds for trying to hold up this game and inhibit discussion. Obvious scum tell.
I liked this, and felt like it was townie, but I guess by rights it should be a null.
Okay, so a lot happened today (typical).
Mail-mi seems kind of towny to me, but I'm not convinced LaLight is scum either.
New players do silly things (experienced players do too), but at least they didn't actually hammer the wagon.
He had town on Mail-mi at this point, so that's townie I guess.
His 4-person lynch pool at #425 contains both Silver and faust. And contains a longer defence of Mail-mi (who was still alive and kicking at that point) than any other text on anyone. I guess scum!Joseph could have thought that the wagon would go, and wanted town points for it. It seems relatively unlikely, though.
Oh, but then he finally joined the Mail-mi wagon at #596 after all.
#657: first re-post of his D1 reads, and admission that they didn't look great.
#658: Some misguided setup analysis.
Around the 70* posts, he seems interestingly helpful to Schadd while I'm busy casting suspicion for the scumslip/townslip thing. The two of them seem to be cooperating in a way that lots of other people aren't. Maybe it's nothing, but I did manage to pick up on the scum pairing in BSG from a similar sort of interaction, so I'm noting it here.
#733: second re-post of his D1 reads. Still admits they look bad.
#782: Another comment in defence of schadd, asserting a townslip.
Yeah, okay, I could vote for Joseph if it came down to it, especially if faust were to assert that he's a good target. If he flips scum, I'd also want to look more closely at schadd.