Thanks, gkrieg -- I hadn't discovered the code tags before now :-)
Note these are not every single interaction within the pair necessarily, and for longer posts it's just a subsection of the commentary. I'm afraid my diligence for noting stuff flagged as I got more sleepy. Anyway, bed time now!
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mail-mi from Diedre
#338: mail-mi: no idea. Pretty confused about him.
#720: I have no idea that Mail-mi is [town]. (After my query of why mail-mi wasn't in his lynchpool).
Deidre from Mail-mi
#319: vote: diedre pressure vote. get on here and do stuff man!
#413: It's definitely different than irl Mafia. You have to look for different things. (response to diedre's melty post)
#415: "...and my scum read on you just shot waaaay up."
#426: Seems to me like he expressed this [] in the scum Qt and got told to say it in thread because it would be townie, and is now playing it up too much.
#565: vote: SA; I guess I could be convinced on Calamitas, though I'd prefer SA or chairs, maybe diedre
#741: If that's your lynchpool, then I should be in it, because I had intent to hammer.
#763: Diedre is another vt? He could be scum.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RR from Diedre
#304: "You are wrong RR. Could you explain your vote, please?" -- setup for a disagreement?
#338: Long explanation of the fact that RR is town.
#377: Actual response to a thing RR said. Seems natural enough.
#551: Disagreeing with RR about real live vs forum mafia. Not driving the game forward at this point.
#591: Pronoun confirmation feels like a non-partner tell.
#717: RR is in Diedre's lynchpool because of the mislynch wagon on Chairs.
Diedre from RR
#301: Why diedre at #301? Especially after a really good (if it were real!) scumread on Seprix, leading me to think you could have some kind of cop role.
#409: "Roadrunner is quite susceptible to pleas like diedre's, so RR is in a moral dilemma". Too-obvious planned: D2 interaction?
#483: RR townreads diedre. Though when he unvotes there, I think he's just taking off his intervening Silver vote.
#546: By the way where'd diedre go?
#552: more about IRL games.
#587: Diedre- He/she has to be town. Reluctant town? Maybe. But town.
#712: Okay the lynchpool is bigger than I thought. SA, Mail Mi, Calamitas and diedre.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Calamitas from Diedre
#338: Calamitas: Town. Pretty sure about this one.
#717: My lynchpool now is: Gkrieg, RR and Calamitas. (because of the Chairs mislynch)
#720: Could you explain a noob what is IC?
#739: You cannot vote on me because "I delayed my claim". Better not saying a thing... (Odd response to Calamitas pressure-voting)
Diedre from Calamitas
#217: Since his role was colored red on the flip, he was mafia aligned.
#317: slightly scummy read: Pretty much non-existent
#718: Gkrieg is basically an IC. What are your reasons for me and RR beeing on that list?
#721: An IC is an 'innocent child'.
#737: PR = power role, VT = Vanilla Townie.
#738: vote: diedre for delaying his claim.
#782: I just feel like that his behavior seems more like town!newbie than scum!newbie in most posts he has made (which are unfortunately not that many).
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RR from Mail-mi
#95: First RVS vote is on RR.
#126: Pushed by RR to explain the teamlyle vote.
#498: Um, huh? Wouldn't that just create more confirmation bias than anything else? (response to RR's re-read of gkrieg assuming guilt)
#565: RR is the obvious person missing from Mail-mi's list here.
#713: You're in the lynchpool, and I am at least taking Calamitas out for today, because of the tracker result.
Mail-mi from RR
#125: "Pls explain" (Mail-mi's real vote on teamlyle).
#587: Mail-mi- lynchpool
#590: I was going to say 'if someone asks me why my head might explode.' So let's just go with muh gut. (Response to mail-mi asking about his chairs vote)
#625: "No mail-mi. No. Plz stop this" (After Mail-mi's ungrammatical misgendering re-vote on me.)
#712: Okay the lynchpool is bigger than I thought. SA, Mail Mi, Calamitas and diedre.
#714: Forgot about that. I'll take him out. But I'm not in the diddidly dang lynchpool! I've been doing my 'bad town' thing! (Calamitas day-pass)
#758: I don't like it because he happened to target Calamitas, who had been confirmed as having no actions. (on mail-mi's role diversion thing. Also #760)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Calamitas from Mail-mi
#228: Responds to Calamitas' query on what happened to teamlyle.
#250: Seems a bit noncommittal about the Seprix breadcrumbing question.
#320: He made a scummy post, and his reaction to it made him look a lot worse. (Mail-mi defending his teamlyle vote to Calamitas)
#526: Silver, why the sudden Calamitas scum read? I thought his response to iguana was pretty null, only a little bit scummy if anything.
#565: vote: SA; I guess I could be convinced on Calamitas, though I'd prefer SA or chairs, maybe diedre
#579: Will vote for Calamitas if SA doesn't happen.
#706: I'm willing to take Calamitas off the table too.
#747: I'm a 1-shot redirector. I used it last night, and I tried to make Calamitas target SA.
#752: I'm actually inclined to believe everyone. Iguana and you are obvious, and Calamitas seems genuine.
#763: I agree. Calamitas maaaaayy be scum, but he took no action last night, and his weird claim.
Mail-mi from Calamitas
#206: Queries Mail-mi's second vote on teamlyle.
#317: slightly scummy read: Opening the case for teamlyle
#321: Commentary at mail-mi. Says behaviour could be slightly scummy or towny, but leans scummy.
#470: Queries Mail-mi's "whyyyyyy" on my VT-claim.
#618: Where? (Asks Mail-mi where my alledged townslip was)
#764: What in particular do you two find scummy in the case of SA. He actually seemed rather towny on my re-read.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Calamitas from RR
#109, #199, #209: Unimportant banter stuff.
#299: "Yeah I realized that" (Calamitas told him Seprix was dead).
#482: I would! And I keep looking back on it and I'm lessand less sure it's outside information. It might've been small talk. -- this is the most RR says about his special info.
#488: Says he'll quite his stuff. Calamitas seems to be responsible for prodding RR into moving the game along a bit. (Or trying t0)
#531: "He's an IC now because of it. Or he would be if he wouldn't of have a slip" (On gkrieg's vig claim, as a response to Calamitas' query)
#558: vote: Calamitas
#587: Calamitas- lynchpool
#634: Oh, you think chairs is scum now? Good job Sherlock ;)
#642: I'm glad Calamitas is figuring out that 'Roadrunner is Roadrunner' already
#712: Okay the lynchpool is bigger than I thought. SA, Mail Mi, Calamitas and diedre.
RR from Calamitas
#111: I have a quite strange sleep cycle.
#232: If I understand it correctly, hated cannot be the case
#297: Tells RR that Seprix is dead.
#317: Gives RR a total null read.
#436: comment on flavour and SK: It fits to the day1 flavor post "might there be a killer in their midst"
#452: Shade on RR over the potential mod info he claimed.
#481: Would one really say something like that if he feels actually guilt for using outside info? (About RR being gleeful that people were talking about him)
#487: Which specific posts did raise your suspicion? (Asking RR about the read-gkrieg-as-guilty thing)
#494: Slowly I get willing to vote for you :D
#530: But for what motive should gkrieg make such a fake claim without necessity?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Author
Topic: M84: Battlestar Galactica Mafia (Game Over - Cylons Win!) (Read 97315 times)