Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[iguanaiguana]

I was convinced of Calamitas/Space at EoD3. Didn't really consider it could be anything else.

[faust]

Personally, I'd have given the mvp to mail-mi without a second thought. I really don't see night actions being as important as day behavior.

To be fair, I would've lynched mail-mi over Calamitas.  I only shot Calamitas because he was softing bulletproof, and I wanted to test that bulletproof.

Of course, you'd have shot Space-A if you didn't shoot Calamitas, and that would have ended the game right there.

[gkrieg13]

Personally, I'd have given the mvp to mail-mi without a second thought. I really don't see night actions being as important as day behavior.

To be fair, I would've lynched mail-mi over Calamitas.  I only shot Calamitas because he was softing bulletproof, and I wanted to test that bulletproof.

Of course, you'd have shot Space-A if you didn't shoot Calamitas, and that would have ended the game right there.

Very true.  If only we could've no-lynched and then mail-mi didn't shoot.  Then I could've shot mail-mi and be the only player to single-handedly win a game for town

[Calamitas]

Personally, I'd have given the mvp to mail-mi without a second thought. I really don't see night actions being as important as day behavior.

To be fair, I would've lynched mail-mi over Calamitas.  I only shot Calamitas because he was softing bulletproof, and I wanted to test that bulletproof.

Of course, you'd have shot Space-A if you didn't shoot Calamitas, and that would have ended the game right there.

Very true.  If only we could've no-lynched and then mail-mi didn't shoot.  Then I could've shot mail-mi and be the only player to single-handedly win a game for town

But why would you shoot mail-mi and not SA there?

[gkrieg13]

Personally, I'd have given the mvp to mail-mi without a second thought. I really don't see night actions being as important as day behavior.

To be fair, I would've lynched mail-mi over Calamitas.  I only shot Calamitas because he was softing bulletproof, and I wanted to test that bulletproof.

Of course, you'd have shot Space-A if you didn't shoot Calamitas, and that would have ended the game right there.

Very true.  If only we could've no-lynched and then mail-mi didn't shoot.  Then I could've shot mail-mi and be the only player to single-handedly win a game for town

But why would you shoot mail-mi and not SA there?

Maybe I would have realized mail-mi was scum

[Haddock]

Calamitas is MVP.

He was widely townread for the majority of the game, contributed excellently to the Cylon Night-time planning and succeeding in framing SA beautifully.

Shouts to:

-- mail-mi, who played an excellent game.  He narrowly missed out on the MVP mostly because I feel he was lucky to avoid scrutiny on a couple of points.

-- gkrieg, who was single-handedly responsible for every scum death.  He would have been an obvious MVP if it weren't for his incorrect choice right at the end.

[Calamitas]

Thank you very much, really didn't expect that at the start of the game Was great fun and mail-mi played an excellent game as well and deserved the MVP as much as I did

[Haddock]

Thank you very much, really didn't expect that at the start of the game Was great fun and mail-mi played an excellent game as well and deserved the MVP as much as I did

It was a tough call.  I agree mail-mi played excellently.

[Roadrunner7671]

Whyyyyyyy

[mail-mi]

Thank you very much, really didn't expect that at the start of the game Was great fun and mail-mi played an excellent game as well and deserved the MVP as much as I did

It was a tough call.  I agree mail-mi played excellently.

Thanks.

though it was because of Calamitas' interactions with SA that got them lynched on the last day.

[J Reggie]

This was a fun game to read. I was bummed it started while I was away, but it may have prevented me from signing up for other games anyway.

[gkrieg13]

I'll get that MVP some day

[J Reggie]

I'll get that MVP some day

Really you've never gotten MVP? I feel like you're a good mafia player though.

[SpaceAnemone]

Sorry town!!! I tried so hard to argue against the mislynch, but I just didn't have enough evidence to get it through :-(

Calamitas, very well played.. I really did think you were town till you flipped!

Mail-mi/Calamitas/Gkrieg, yeah, the incessant pronouns thing was much more upsetting/distracting than I'd expected. I had some real-life overt sexism stuff to deal with simultaneously over the past few days, so I probably didn't give you as much benefit of the doubt as I could have done at the end there. Sorry I got cross.

I've finally been able to talk through the game with Haddock this evening, so hopefully I've absorbed most of the advice he dispensed! Here's my QT, just in case anyone thought I was making up the bizarre theories I came up with in my defence... I really was just being 100% honest all the time :-P
https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/ktpiZhArgfv

[Haddock]

What did people think of the flavour?

[chairs]

Personally, I'd have given the mvp to mail-mi without a second thought. I really don't see night actions being as important as day behavior.

To be fair, I would've lynched mail-mi over Calamitas.  I only shot Calamitas because he was softing bulletproof, and I wanted to test that bulletproof.

Of course, you'd have shot Space-A if you didn't shoot Calamitas, and that would have ended the game right there.

Very true.  If only we could've no-lynched and then mail-mi didn't shoot.  Then I could've shot mail-mi and be the only player to single-handedly win a game for town

I guess technically I didn't single-handedly win since we did lynch the SK, but I came pretty close in Dynasty Warriors.