With all of the brackets, it's time to add some more:
Token Bracket: (there are two 1st round byes, since I can only come up with 14 tokens)
1. Estate
16. (Bye)
2. Journey
15. (Bye)
3. Trashing
14. +1 Buy
4. 5 VP
13. +$1
5. Coin Token
12. +1 Action
6. Embargo Token
11. +1 Card
7. -$2
10. 1 VP
8. -1 Card
9. -$1
And the Mat Bracket:
1. Island
8. Base card randomizers from the base set (they're sort of mats because you put the base cards on them)
2. Pirate Ship
7. Trash Card (I'm counting this as a Mat, because Donald X says that it should have been one).
3. Tavern
6. VP Token
4. Native Village
5. Trade Route
EDIT: Made this into actual brackets, in case anyone wants to do this.