Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Axxle]

3 players. One is a Winner, One is a Loser, One is a Banana

Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win.

The Banana wins if the winner picks him.

If the Loser is picked they win, and the winner and banana both lose.

We can probably use this thread for multiple games.

/in to win

-------------------------------------------

Stats

Awalcus: 1 win 0 losses
chairs: 1 win 0 losses
iguanaiguana: 2 wins 1 loss
Roadrunner7671: 1 win 1 loss
liopoil: 0 wins 1 loss
sudgy: 0 wins 1 loss

Winner/Banana: 2 wins
Loser: 1 win

[Awaclus]

So basically this is just 1v2 LyLo with 1 IC?

[Axxle]

So basically this is just 1v2 LyLo with 1 IC?

Pretty much!

[Axxle]

But with tasty banana flavor

[Roadrunner7671]

/in

[iguanaiguana]

/wtf

[iguanaiguana]

/in SORRY VLA

[Roadrunner7671]

/in SORRY VLA

I think the real question is why were you on the Dominion forum during your bachelor party?

[Roadrunner7671]

Is this supposed to be blitz or not?

[iguanaiguana]

/in SORRY VLA

I think the real question is why were you on the Dominion forum during your bachelor party?

There was no bachelor party. There was climbing followed by my brother and I getting like three drinks.

Anyway I am the winner. Choose me banana I'm getting married tomorrow.

[Roadrunner7671]

/in SORRY VLA

I think the real question is why were you on the Dominion forum during your bachelor party?

There was no bachelor party. There was climbing followed by my brother and I getting like three drinks.

Anyway I am the winner. Choose me banana I'm getting married tomorrow.

Gl hf

[ashersky]

3 players. One is a Winner, One is a Loser, One is a Banana

Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win.

The Banana wins if the winner picks him.

If the Loser is picked they win, and the winner and banana both lose.

We can probably use this thread for multiple games.

/in to win

But the winner always loses...makes no sense to me.

Player 1 is Winner
Player 2 is Loser
Player 3 is Banana

Player 1 chooses Player 2: Player 2 wins the game.
Player 1 chooses Player 3: Player 3 wins the game.

How can Player 1 win the game?

[Accatitippi]

3 players. One is a Winner, One is a Loser, One is a Banana

Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win.

The Banana wins if the winner picks him.

If the Loser is picked they win, and the winner and banana both lose.

We can probably use this thread for multiple games.

/in to win

But the winner always loses...makes no sense to me.

Player 1 is Winner
Player 2 is Loser
Player 3 is Banana

Player 1 chooses Player 2: Player 2 wins the game.
Player 1 chooses Player 3: Player 3 wins the game.

How can Player 1 win the game?

Winner wins if he picks banana.

[Roadrunner7671]

3 players. One is a Winner, One is a Loser, One is a Banana

Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win.

The Banana wins if the winner picks him.

If the Loser is picked they win, and the winner and banana both lose.

We can probably use this thread for multiple games.

/in to win

But the winner always loses...makes no sense to me.

Player 1 is Winner
Player 2 is Loser
Player 3 is Banana

Player 1 chooses Player 2: Player 2 wins the game.
Player 1 chooses Player 3: Player 3 wins the game.

How can Player 1 win the game?

Winner wins if he picks banana.

That's what I assumed.

[Accatitippi]

You don't have to make assumptions!
Quoting the OP: "Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win."

[Roadrunner7671]

You don't have to make assumptions!
Quoting the OP: "Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win."

You should play!

[Accatitippi]

You don't have to make assumptions!
Quoting the OP: "Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win."

You should play!

I should study! 
(hadn't been invited to a forum game on f:ds yet and I was starting to wonder what was wrong with me, so thank you! )

[Roadrunner7671]

You don't have to make assumptions!
Quoting the OP: "Winner is publicly revealed. They have to choose the player who is the banana to win."

You should play!

I should study! 
(hadn't been invited to a forum game on f:ds yet and I was starting to wonder what was wrong with me, so thank you! )

Studies have shown that a break from studying is quite beneficial. For example, this one here: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=13332.msg500574#msg500574

And who knows when the next time you'll get to play this game will be?

And you'll just let poor iguanaiguana not get the one gift this forum can offer him, a forum game? It's his birthday tomorrow!

[pacovf]

How do we know if the winner chose correctly?

[Roadrunner7671]

How do we know if the winner chose correctly?

Axxel will announce it.

[iguanaiguana]

Adel's playing?

[Roadrunner7671]

Why is no one joining? It'll be fun!

[Axxle]

How do we know if the winner chose correctly?

I can announce it or the person chosen can.

And yeah it should be a super blitz game but I won't really put a timer on it.

[Axxle]

So far I just have rr and II in, correct me if im wrong.

[Awaclus]

/in

[Axxle]

Sending PMs now

[Axxle]

Awaclus is the the WINNER.

Please post your choice of banana in thread in bold when you're ready. Feel free to ask ii and rr anything that might help you decide.

[Awaclus]

So, which one of you is the banana?

[iguanaiguana]

I claim banana.

Don't have time to argue so just pick me, I'm real.

It's the day before my wedding and I wouldn't lie.

Saw I was the banana and came straight here.

It's real I'm the banana pick me winner so we both win cmon do it

[Awaclus]

Any counterclaims?

[Roadrunner7671]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

[Roadrunner7671]

And everyone's gone.

[iguanaiguana]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

He's lying.

[iguanaiguana]

There's no flavor. It just says I'm the banana. That alone should be enough evidence to condemn Roadrunner.

[Awaclus]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

What's your flavor name?

[iguanaiguana]

This flavor name thing is yet another example of Roadrunner botching a fakeclaim. There's a lot of precedent for this. This should be easy.

[iguanaiguana]

Like if your name is anything more than the winner, go ahead and lynch me. Otherwise it should be him.

[liopoil]

What? I'm the banana. One of RR and II is just messing around.

[Roadrunner7671]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

What's your flavor name?

Banana

[Axxle]

What? I'm the banana. One of RR and II is just messing around.

I'll consider this an /in for next round

[liopoil]

What? I'm the banana. One of RR and II is just messing around.

I'll consider this an /in for next round

Sheesh, I didn't expect you to side with with the loser like that.

Axxle sent me a PM asking if I'd like to play. I said sure, why not, seems like it could be fun and not much of a commitment. Then he tells me I'm the banana. But apparently 4 people are playing, so there's a 4th role floating around mixing things up. I should have known better than to trust mod-Axxle. And now he is blatantly siding against Awaclus and me by pretending that I'm not playing. This is a bastard non-mafia game!

[faust]

The bad in the world is hard to hear when in your ear a banana cheers

[Roadrunner7671]

Charlie, you look quite down
With your big fat eyes
And your big fat frown
The world doesn't have to be so gray
Charlie when your life's a mess
When your feeling blue always in distress
I know what can wash that sad away
All you have to do is

Put a banana in your ear
*A banana in my ear?*
Put a ripe banana
Right into your favorite ear
It's true
*Says who?*
So true
Once it's in your gloom will disapear
The bad in the world is hard to hear
When in your ear a banana cheers
So go and put a banana in your ear

Put a banana in your ear
*I'd rather keep my ear clear*
You'll never be happy if you live your life in fear
It's true
*Says you*
So true
And it's in the skies are right and clear
Oh every day of every year
There's sunshine bright on this big blue sphere
So go and put a banana in your ear
*Oh of course he bursts into flames! '*

[pacovf]

The bad in the world is hard to hear when in your ear a banana cheers

Gonna upvote some of your posts now.

[iguanaiguana]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

What's your flavor name?

Dammit Awaclus, you were supposed to pick me today.

I am the only one who gave any real argument and I actually think it was pretty solid.

Try to time your choosing me over Roadrunner tomorrow to coincide with my saying "I Do" or the kiss or something cool like that.

[iguanaiguana]

What? I'm the banana. One of RR and II is just messing around.

I'll consider this an /in for next round

Sheesh, I didn't expect you to side with with the loser like that.

Axxle sent me a PM asking if I'd like to play. I said sure, why not, seems like it could be fun and not much of a commitment. Then he tells me I'm the banana. But apparently 4 people are playing, so there's a 4th role floating around mixing things up. I should have known better than to trust mod-Axxle. And now he is blatantly siding against Awaclus and me by pretending that I'm not playing. This is a bastard non-mafia game!

This stinks of obvious lying. Liopoil's not playing. Roadrunner's the loser (see the fakeclaim argument -- he only backed off when he got caught.) Awaclus is the winner and I'm the banana. There's really nothing else to say. Please vote, I want us to win.

[liopoil]

This stinks of obvious lying. Liopoil's not playing. Roadrunner's the loser (see the fakeclaim argument -- he only backed off when he got caught.) Awaclus is the winner and I'm the banana. There's really nothing else to say. Please vote, I want us to win.

Easy for a loser/4th role to say.

[Roadrunner7671]

This stinks of obvious lying. Liopoil's not playing. Roadrunner's the loser (see the fakeclaim argument -- he only backed off when he got caught.) Awaclus is the winner and I'm the banana. There's really nothing else to say. Please vote, I want us to win.

Easy for a loser/4th role to say.

[iguanaiguana]

This stinks of obvious lying. Liopoil's not playing. Roadrunner's the loser (see the fakeclaim argument -- he only backed off when he got caught.) Awaclus is the winner and I'm the banana. There's really nothing else to say. Please vote, I want us to win.

Easy for a loser/4th role to say.

The mod said he considered you as signed up for the next game, not this one. You're not playing.

[iguanaiguana]

This stinks of obvious lying. Liopoil's not playing. Roadrunner's the loser (see the fakeclaim argument -- he only backed off when he got caught.) Awaclus is the winner and I'm the banana. There's really nothing else to say. Please vote, I want us to win.

Easy for a loser/4th role to say.

Oh is that why you quoted it?

[Axxle]

Sending liopoil his pm

On a completely unrelated note, this game now has two losers instead of one.

[iguanaiguana]

Sending liopoil his pm

On a completely unrelated note, this game now has two losers instead of one.

I revoke my statement that Liopoil is not playing and instead assert that he is a loser, and i am the banana.

[liopoil]

Sending liopoil his pm

On a completely unrelated note, this game now has two losers instead of one.

liar, I have not received a second PMl; I am still the banana

[iguanaiguana]

Sending liopoil his pm

On a completely unrelated note, this game now has two losers instead of one.

liar, I have not received a second PMl; I am still the banana

You just got your first PM that said you were the loser, I think. I can't be completely sure because I'm not you and this game is weird but Awaclus choose me for God's sake also tomorrow is the wedding going to bed but CMON I shouldn't have to work this hard for a silly game.

[Roadrunner7671]

I just trust that Awaclus will make the right choice.

[liopoil]

If I were the winner I would say that Awaclus is the banana.

[iguanaiguana]

I just trust that Awaclus will make the right choice.

So do I, but only because your awful unnecessary fakeclaim at the start of this gives me a lot of confidence.

[iguanaiguana]

Right... BED

[Roadrunner7671]

Right... BED

Be vanquished!

[Kirian]

Shocking Twist:  All three of you were actually Hitler.

[Roadrunner7671]

/in

Good choice.

[Awaclus]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

What's your flavor name?

Banana

But Iguanaiguana also gave me banana. So either banana is not your flavor name or he could totally give me your flavor name. Therefore, you must be lying.

Banana: iguanaiguana

[Axxle]

iguanaiguana was a banana!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Axxle]

you both win and Roadrunner7671 unfortunately loses.

Next game starts when full

Currently have just liopoil signed up

[iguanaiguana]

Any counterclaims?

Me!

I'm the real banana. I can give you my flavorname, but Iguaniguana can't.

Don't let him guilt you!

What's your flavor name?

Banana

But Iguanaiguana also gave me banana. So either banana is not your flavor name or he could totally give me your flavor name. Therefore, you must be lying.

Banana: iguanaiguana

Good choice sir.

[iguanaiguana]

/in.

Bride to be getting a pedicure, let's knock one out before she's done!

[liopoil]

Wait darn I was actually a second banana for real.

[Awaclus]

I just trust that Awaclus will make the right choice.

Well, a good thing your trust wasn't misplaced then.

[chairs]

/in

[Axxle]

liopoil
iguanaiguana
chairs

liopoil is the Winner

The game starts now!

[liopoil]

From my PM, I win when I choose the banana.

However, I already am the winner.

Do I get to win again?

In that case, which of you is the banana? This doesn't have to be hard, just speak up and we can get this over with quickly.

What are the odds that iguanaiguana is the banana AGAIN??

[Roadrunner7671]

/in

[Axxle]

/in

Adding a new role to the game, here's an example PM:

You are the Screamer

You have no win condition, but you may post in thread as often as you want.

[Roadrunner7671]

Yay

[liopoil]

What happens if I choose the screamer?

[Roadrunner7671]

What happens if I choose the screamer?

You win but I don't

[Roadrunner7671]

Scrollllll

[Roadrunner7671]

Taymgs

[Roadrunner7671]

Taymgs

I need to stop

[Axxle]

What happens if I choose the screamer?

You win if you choose the banana, you lose otherwise.

[Roadrunner7671]

What happens if I choose the screamer?

You win if you choose the banana, you lose otherwise.

He's lying

[Axxle]

Am not!

[Roadrunner7671]

Am not!

Prove it

[Axxle]

You are the Mod

You win when anybody else wins.

You may not lie or you will be modkilled.

Axxle has been modkilled for quoting his role PM

[Roadrunner7671]

You are the Mod

You win when anybody else wins.

You may not lie or you will be modkilled.

Axxle has been modkilled for quoting his role PM

Baby come back

[iguanaiguana]

From my PM, I win when I choose the banana.

However, I already am the winner.

Do I get to win again?

In that case, which of you is the banana? This doesn't have to be hard, just speak up and we can get this over with quickly.

What are the odds that iguanaiguana is the banana AGAIN??

Apparently Axxle thinks it's funny to make me the banana every time I play. I'm the banana again.

[Roadrunner7671]

 





























 






































 

































 



































 













































 













L



















































































 





































































































 



































































 































































 






























































 :

[Roadrunner7671]

I have too much time on my hands. I'm also a SCREAMER

[liopoil]

From my PM, I win when I choose the banana.

However, I already am the winner.

Do I get to win again?

In that case, which of you is the banana? This doesn't have to be hard, just speak up and we can get this over with quickly.

What are the odds that iguanaiguana is the banana AGAIN??

Apparently Axxle thinks it's funny to make me the banana every time I play. I'm the banana again.

A convincing argument. Chairs?

[chairs]

From my PM, I win when I choose the banana.

However, I already am the winner.

Do I get to win again?

In that case, which of you is the banana? This doesn't have to be hard, just speak up and we can get this over with quickly.

What are the odds that iguanaiguana is the banana AGAIN??

Apparently Axxle thinks it's funny to make me the banana every time I play. I'm the banana again.

A convincing argument. Chairs?

[iguanaiguana]

This last post shows how on some level he knows he's just pretending to be a banana.

[chairs]

[liopoil]

Wait chairs I'm confused are you actually the banana or what? These pictures are too confusing.

[chairs]

[liopoil]

Interesting. I think I've made my choice.

I'll give Roadrunner and anyone else who wants to a chance to say something first.

[Accatitippi]

Something.

[Roadrunner7671]

Chair's case is quite convincing.

[liopoil]

Well that settles it.

Choose: Chairs

[liopoil]

Oh, by the way, last game:

Wait darn I was actually a second banana for real.

Since I can tell you guys still don't believe me:

You are the Banana

You win when you are picked by the winner

Check the time-stamp, it matches when he said he sent me a PM.

[Axxle]

That's not what a banana PM looks like. Though I don't expect you it chairs to know that!

Chairs wins alone!

[iguanaiguana]

Damn, we both lose.

[Axxle]

Playerlist for the next game:

Roadrunner7671
sudgy

[liopoil]

Damn, we both lose.

Darn  . Chairs was too good.

I pick Roadrunner to be the winner for the next game (which I'll sit out).

That's not what a banana PM looks like. Though I don't expect you it chairs to know that!

Chairs wins alone!

Mod continues to side against me. After he realized his mistake in making two bananas he even said:

--snip--

Shoot

[sudgy]

Oh, why not, I'll play.

[Roadrunner7671]

/in

[iguanaiguana]

I will mod the next one if Axxle wants to play. Otherwise, I'll play.

[iguanaiguana]

Damn, we both lose.

Darn  . Chairs was too good.

I guess animated gifs are more convincing than arguments.

[liopoil]

Damn, we both lose.

Darn  . Chairs was too good.

I guess animated gifs are more convincing than arguments.

It's true.

[Axxle]

I will mod the next one if Axxle wants to play. Otherwise, I'll play.

I do not, thanks though

PMs going out after randomization

[Roadrunner7671]

I will mod the next one if Axxle wants to play. Otherwise, I'll play.

I do not, thanks though

PMs going out after randomization

Wait!!!

If I'm a Winner Loser Banana or Screamer bad things will happen

[Axxle]

Let the games begin!

iguanaiguana is the Winner.

Roadrunner and sudgy are the other players this round.

[Roadrunner7671]

So I'm the banana but I'm either going to be modkilled or get a new role. I made this clear to Axxel.

[sudgy]

But seriously, I'm the banana.  I can prove it.

[iguanaiguana]

Prove it.

[Roadrunner7671]

Prove it.

Only fake bananas have ever posted memes/gifs/videos/song lyrics.

[sudgy]

Prove it.

Only fake bananas have ever posted memes/gifs/videos/song lyrics.

Okay, honestly, I just posted that because it was on my mind from the name of the game.

Proof:

You are the Banana.

You win when the Winner correctly chooses you as the Banana.

Anyway, another way to prove whether or not I'm the Banana: if you pick me, it will prove whether or not I'm the Banana.

(Pascal's wager ftw!)

Seriously though, I'm the Banana.  We need to win this.  Roadrunner is obviously the Loser because he is just being weird.  He hasn't been providing any reasons for him being the Banana.

[Roadrunner7671]

Quoting PMs isn't proof, someone (liopoli?) already quoted his.

[Roadrunner7671]

This is making me genuinely upset because this isn't LyLo. I know that everything sudgey is saying is crap, so it's frustrating because I am pretty sure I can't be picked.

[liopoil]

Quoting PMs isn't proof, someone (liopoli?) already quoted his.

And it was proof, in fact

[Roadrunner7671]

Quoting PMs isn't proof, someone (liopoli?) already quoted his.

And it was proof, in fact

Screamer?

[liopoil]

Quoting PMs isn't proof, someone (liopoli?) already quoted his.

And it was proof, in fact

Screamer?

I'm not playing this one

[Roadrunner7671]

Quoting PMs isn't proof, someone (liopoli?) already quoted his.

And it was proof, in fact

Screamer?

I'm not playing this one

But you're posting!

[liopoil]

Quoting PMs isn't proof, someone (liopoli?) already quoted his.

And it was proof, in fact

Screamer?

I'm not playing this one

But you're posting!

Huh, that's weird.

[sudgy]

Axxle said that liopoil's PM wasn't correct, anyway.

iguanaiguana, listen to me.  Look into my eyes.  I am the Banana.

This is making me genuinely upset because this isn't LyLo. I know that everything sudgey is saying is crap, so it's frustrating because I am pretty sure I can't be picked.

AtE?

[Roadrunner7671]

Wait, Sudgey's 'PM' is wrong.

[Roadrunner7671]

You are the Banana.

You win when you convince the Winner that you are the Banana.

[sudgy]

You are the Banana.

You win when you convince the Winner that you are the Banana.

So, you made it up.  In the end, now, neither of our PMs can be trusted, because either of us could have made it up.

[Roadrunner7671]

You are the Banana.

You win when you convince the Winner that you are the Banana.

So, you made it up.  In the end, now, neither of our PMs can be trusted, because either of us could have made it up.

No, because I copy-pasted and you didn't.

[sudgy]

You are the Banana.

You win when you convince the Winner that you are the Banana.

So, you made it up.  In the end, now, neither of our PMs can be trusted, because either of us could have made it up.

No, because I copy-pasted and you didn't.

I can (and am) saying the same thing.  Just because you are saying yours is better doesn't make it better.  And, because you have made up a fake PM as well, it shows that now nobody can trust mine as well.  I'll have to find other ways of showing that I'm the Banana.

[Roadrunner7671]

An apology isn't enough! I demand to be modkilled or get a role change!

Fresh out of modkills, planning on getting a new shipment of them tomorrow.

I can post our entire conversation if you want, but does this sound like something I would say?

[sudgy]

An apology isn't enough! I demand to be modkilled or get a role change!

Fresh out of modkills, planning on getting a new shipment of them tomorrow.

I can post our entire conversation if you want, but does this sound like something I would say?

This doesn't show anything.  I could easily see the Loser posting this.

[liopoil]

Wait, Sudgy is obviously lying.

[Roadrunner7671]

Wait, Sudgy is obviously lying.

[sudgy]

Wait, Sudgy is obviously lying.

...why?

[iguanaiguana]

Banana: Roadrunner

[Roadrunner7671]

Banana: Roadrunner

Ayooooo

[iguanaiguana]

Sudgy's PM had the wrong text when compared to my banana PM from last round, while RR's was the same.

Sudgy also has a history of editing things in quotes for fun.

So he's the loser.

[iguanaiguana]

Am I right?

[Roadrunner7671]

Am I right?

Yep!

[liopoil]

Wait, Sudgy is obviously lying.

...why?

For iguana's reasons, and the timestamps on the PMs. RR made multiple subtle 'banana slips' too, including the post with his PM coming quickly after another post.

[liopoil]

Also quoting real PMs was of questionable legality, so given that sudgy started it he was likely making it up. RR's wording of his PM was a bit weird to be made up so quickly too.

[Axxle]

Rr and II win!

I didn't explicitly say that quoting PMs wasn't allowed, and I think I accidentally let precedent get set when I allowed liopoil to quote his as a joke from the outside so I didn't think a modkill was appropriate (plus I think this is a game where there isn't a bunch of investment in it)

That said I'm going to disallow quoting PMs or pretending to quote PMs from me from now on since it gives me an icky feeling.

[sudgy]

Can I play again?  I'm leaving on Monday.

[Axxle]

Can I play again?  I'm leaving on Monday.

for sure!

Playerlist:
Sudgy

[Roadrunner7671]

I'll play if I can be a whiner, Scout or ghost dragon.

[gkrieg13]

I'll play if I can be a whiner, Scout or ghost dragon.

I get to decide who is ghost dragon, thank you very much

[Roadrunner7671]

I'll play if I can be a whiner, Scout or ghost dragon.

I get to decide who is ghost dragon, thank you very much

You're the mod now? I guess Axxel died so someone has to take over...

[Axxle]

I was born in the year of the dragon, so dying would make me the ghost dragon, sorry.

[gkrieg13]

I was born in the year of the dragon, so dying would make me the ghost dragon, sorry.

But I'm the great necromancer!

[iguanaiguana]

/in Wynaut

[J Reggie]

I played this game IRL and it was super fun! This should be more of a thing.

[gkrieg13]

I played this game IRL and it was super fun! This should be more of a thing.

Haha I feel this would be kinda lame IRL. But I guess it would be fun with the right group when you're bored

[iguanaiguana]

I am modding this game right.... Now!

/in to win!

[Roadrunner7671]

IN

[iguanaiguana]

IN

Reply in 18 seconds. Not bad.

[Roadrunner7671]

We don't even need a mod. The winner can be chosen and the other two people can PM to decide who's who.

[iguanaiguana]

Nah we need two more sign ups.

[Roadrunner7671]

/out

[Dylan32]

/in

[Dylan32]

/out

boo

[Roadrunner7671]

Its bedtime

[Dylan32]

Well, I'm the banana anyway, so just pick me and we can come back tomorrow

[liopoil]

Wow, I remember playing this game! Timestamps say it was just over a year ago. Except I forget what the game is, let me go back and see...

[liopoil]

Oh man, just re-read the thread... good times. I don't remember what PMs Axxle actually sent me the first time, so I'm having a hard time deciding whether to believe myself or not. Anyway, /in

[sudgy]

/in only if the game takes less than an hour or longer than a day.  I'm going to bed at some point.

[iguanaiguana]

Players are Dylan, Sudgy and Liopoil. Game starts in the morning tho I'm going to bed.

[iguanaiguana]

Role descriptions:

Winner:
You are the winner! The mod will confirm you as the winner in the thread at the start of the game. You and the banana both win when you correctly guess which player is the banana by typing in bold text in this format: Banana: playername.

Loser:
You win alone when the winner incorrectly chooses you as the banana by typing your name in the main thread in bold text in this format: Banana: playername.

Banana:
You are the banana! You and the winner both win when the winner correctly chooses you by typing your name in the main thread in bold text in this format: Banana: playername

Role PMS going out now!

[iguanaiguana]

Sudgy is the winner! The game starts now.

[LaLight]

/in for next

[liopoil]

Wow! Hey sudgy, great news: I'm the banana!

Unfortunately you can't really trust me when I say that. One reason for that is because I would say the same thing if I were the loser. The other reason is that I haven't actually opened my PM, so don't actually know whether I'm the banana or not. I hope I am for your sake, so that you can win too when you choose me!

But uh yeah it doesn't really matter much to me whether I'm the banana or not, sorry. I am very confident, however, that Dylan is the loser, so don't choose him!

[gkrieg13]

Wow! Hey sudgy, great news: I'm the banana!

Unfortunately you can't really trust me when I say that. One reason for that is because I would say the same thing if I were the loser. The other reason is that I haven't actually opened my PM, so don't actually know whether I'm the banana or not. I hope I am for your sake, so that you can win too when you choose me!

But uh yeah it doesn't really matter much to me whether I'm the banana or not, sorry. I am very confident, however, that Dylan is the loser, so don't choose him!

Clear loser tell right here.  Bananas would look at their PM.

[liopoil]

Wow! Hey sudgy, great news: I'm the banana!

Unfortunately you can't really trust me when I say that. One reason for that is because I would say the same thing if I were the loser. The other reason is that I haven't actually opened my PM, so don't actually know whether I'm the banana or not. I hope I am for your sake, so that you can win too when you choose me!

But uh yeah it doesn't really matter much to me whether I'm the banana or not, sorry. I am very confident, however, that Dylan is the loser, so don't choose him!

Clear loser tell right here.  Bananas would look at their PM.

Who are you?

[sudgy]

So, I kind of forgot that I'm pretty busy today.  So, how about you two spend all day bickering and I'll pick the banana when I get home tonight.

[sudgy]

...seriously?

[liopoil]

...seriously?

Dylan didn't show up, so he's the loser

[sudgy]

Dylan, you have several more hours.  If you don't say anything, liopoil is the banana.

[liopoil]

Dylan, you have several more hours.  If you don't say anything, liopoil is the banana.

I'm probably the banana even if Dylan does say something, but I admit that I still cannot be sure

[iguanaiguana]

There's no rule that says you have to pick in one day. Neither is there a rule that says you have to let everyone post before you pick. Come to think of it, there aren't really any rules at all!

[Axxle]

Oh man, just re-read the thread... good times. I don't remember what PMs Axxle actually sent me the first time, so I'm having a hard time deciding whether to believe myself or not. Anyway, /in

Iirc, half the time you didn't even get a PM.

[liopoil]

Oh man, just re-read the thread... good times. I don't remember what PMs Axxle actually sent me the first time, so I'm having a hard time deciding whether to believe myself or not. Anyway, /in

Iirc, half the time you didn't even get a PM.

Oh haha. I'm pretty sure I did get a PM this time though, because there's a [1] next to my messages and I don't see why anyone else would be sending me a message right now.

[Dylan32]

Sorry had both a family and a high school reunion today, so this was the first time I've been on my laptop today. Good thing I checked before bed though because you were almost duped into picking a fake banana!

[Dylan32]

So now that I'm here and I'm the banana, you don't have to worry about picking the Loser by default. But for the sake of fun, Sudgy, let's have a lively debate. Have you still not read your PM?

[liopoil]

So now that I'm here and I'm the banana, you don't have to worry about picking the Loser by default. But for the sake of fun, Sudgy, let's have a lively debate. Have you still not read your PM?

Hmm, sudgy has no reason to read his PM either, so I'm not sure he has! In fact, there's no reason for anyone to read their PM this game, that's interesting...

[Dylan32]

So now that I'm here and I'm the banana, you don't have to worry about picking the Loser by default. But for the sake of fun, Sudgy, let's have a lively debate. Have you still not read your PM?

Hmm, sudgy has no reason to read his PM either, so I'm not sure he has! In fact, there's no reason for anyone to read their PM this game, that's interesting...

Well, that's actually true. What a weird game.

[gkrieg13]

Except the winner wants the other two to read their PMs, so he could just vote for the person who actually read their PM instead of voting for someone who claims to have not read it.

[sudgy]

Banana: liopoil

[iguanaiguana]

Noice.

Liopoil is the banana and he wins with Sudgy!

[iguanaiguana]

The next game will be a slight variant. Time commitment is roughly ten seconds more.

LaLight is in. Who else?

[iguanaiguana]

Except the winner wants the other two to read their PMs, so he could just vote for the person who actually read their PM instead of voting for someone who claims to have not read it.

I agree with this btw. Someone who says they have not read their PM is either lying or has a 50% chance of being banana. So that's a reason not to pick them over the other person.

[sudgy]

Except the winner wants the other two to read their PMs, so he could just vote for the person who actually read their PM instead of voting for someone who claims to have not read it.

I agree with this btw. Someone who says they have not read their PM is either lying or has a 50% chance of being banana. So that's a reason not to pick them over the other person.

I just didn't consider liopoil.  I made my decision because I thought Dylan was the loser.

[iguanaiguana]

Except the winner wants the other two to read their PMs, so he could just vote for the person who actually read their PM instead of voting for someone who claims to have not read it.

I agree with this btw. Someone who says they have not read their PM is either lying or has a 50% chance of being banana. So that's a reason not to pick them over the other person.

I just didn't consider liopoil.  I made my decision because I thought Dylan was the loser.

Turns out that was a good call!

[liopoil]

hahaha awesome. I really didn't read my PM (I'm about to now after I finish this post) but if I had to guess, I was slightly leaning towards believing that I was the banana after seeing what a loser dylan was. See, this way I got to play as the winner too!

EDIT: I'll play again unless people who didn't play last time need more space. I promise to read my PM this time, especially because of this slight variant.

[iguanaiguana]

People should sign up, the new twist is dope.

[Dylan32]

Fine, /in, but sort of LA tomorrow so I'll be on when I can , but not constantly. (Memorial Day in the US)

[Roadrunner7671]

/in

[iguanaiguana]

 Players are LaLight, Dylan, Roadrunner. I am sending you a question to answer!

[iguanaiguana]

Waiting for RR

[iguanaiguana]

Your preferences were honored whenever possible,  but at least one person did not get their first choice.

LaLight is the winner!

Game starts now!

[Roadrunner7671]

Oops I thought the banana was the winner and the winner was the banana. I wanted to be the banana, but I thought banana was the chooser

[Roadrunner7671]

That being said, I am the banana, so...

[LaLight]

well prepared speech, my man!

Let's hear to Dylan

[LaLight]

and here's the question to everyone: what would be the first post you'd make if you are a loser?

[Roadrunner7671]

and here's the question to everyone: what would be the first post you'd make if you are a loser?

Probably something about how I'm the banana and you should totally pick me. Super basic but hopefully convincing.

[liopoil]

and here's the question to everyone: what would be the first post you'd make if you are a loser?

this.

[ashersky]

/in  next game

[Galzria]

Banana

[iguanaiguana]

and here's the question to everyone: what would be the first post you'd make if you are a loser?

I would probably say this:

As the mod, I declare that this game now has two losers and one banana, which is me by the way 

[Dylan32]

So there would have initially  been a banana prior to

and here's the question to everyone: what would be the first post you'd make if you are a loser?

I would probably say this:

As the mod, I declare that this game now has two losers and one banana, which is me by the way 

And so iguana must be the additional loser.

My choices were in order banana, winner, loser, so if RR said winner wanting to be the banana, and you, the winner, picked winner first and got it, then we got our first 2 picks and RR is the loser.

[Dylan32]

lol. I misread iguana's post. That's funny.

[Galzria]

Banana

[Galzria]

So. I haven't played before, but following

Banana

I got a pm telling me I was doing right and I could be a banana as long as I was a yellow one in every post I made. So here I am. The banana. Or A banana. I'm probably not the only one. Although I might be. I'm not sure.

[Dylan32]

So. I haven't played before, but following

Banana

I got a pm telling me I was doing right and I could be a banana as long as I was a yellow one in every post I made. So here I am. The banana. Or A banana. I'm probably not the only one. Although I might be. I'm not sure.

I think post #205 ruined that for you didn't it?

[Galzria]

So. I haven't played before, but following

Banana

I got a pm telling me I was doing right and I could be a banana as long as I was a yellow one in every post I made. So here I am. The banana. Or A banana. I'm probably not the only one. Although I might be. I'm not sure.

I think post #205 ruined that for you didn't it?

That would be correct, except I wasn't playing then. I mean, I posted banana because it seemed the thing to do - but I didn't get the pm until after that. How would I have? But I'm definitely a banana now.

[LaLight]

banana: Roadrunner i guess

[liopoil]

Loser

[Galzria]

banana: Roadrunner i guess

Wrong. I'm the Banana. Now I'm a sad banana.

[Roadrunner7671]

Yay! I'm not really sure what the mod's verdict will be given all the rule changes, but I think at least I win.

[iguanaiguana]

Roadrunner, the loser, wins!

[liopoil]

/in

[LaLight]

/in

[ashersky]

/sendmemypmcat

[iguanaiguana]

Let's do it!

Last game, I asked players to rank their preferred roles from first to worst. Then, I ran the setup that gave as many people as close to their top pick as possible. This game, we will start with the same ranking question, and then I will give you your roles in some other mysterious fashion that I will not explain.

The purpose, of course, is just to give you all something to discuss.

[gkrieg13]

Let's do it!

Last game, I asked players to rank their preferred roles from first to worst. Then, I ran the setup that gave as many people as close to their top pick as possible. This game, we will start with the same ranking question, and then I will give you your roles in some other mysterious fashion that I will not explain.

The purpose, of course, is just to give you all something to discuss.

But they get to discuss bananas anyway...

[iguanaiguana]

LaLight answered: Winner > Loser > Banana.
Ashersky answered: Winner > Loser > Banana.
Liopoil answered: Loser > Banana > Winner.

Liopoil is the winner!

[LaLight]

obviously from the answers you can't say what was the logic. I am the banana though so ashersky won in terms of favourite roles

[LaLight]

whatever ash will say, don't believe him, because banana is me (ii told so)

[ashersky]

The deciding logic is pretty clear -- give everyone their lowest ranked.

Since two of us had the same answers, he used seniority as a tie-breaker.  Hence why I got the banana.

(Or he flipped a coin and I won.)

Either way, LaLight saying he can't see the logic is a misdirect and scummy.

[LaLight]

The deciding logic is pretty clear -- give everyone their lowest ranked.

Since two of us had the same answers, he used seniority as a tie-breaker.  Hence why I got the banana.

(Or he flipped a coin and I won.)

Either way, LaLight saying he can't see the logic is a misdirect and scummy.

That's such an amazing feeling to know for sure someone's scum. I have never been in 3-person LyLo.

To be clear, I know there are many ways to solve the tie, I just don't know what exactly was used and anyway it doesn't really matter.

Seniority? Really?

[liopoil]

Wow, seriously you guys couldn't have chosen something's different? Not making my job easy.

At first I was wondering if the fact that I ranked loser above banana could affect which of you is th banana, but there really is no way to distinguish between you two. Hmm. Maybe the order in which we're listed matters?

I think I might just have to play this like normal win-lose-banana

[LaLight]

Wow, seriously you guys couldn't have chosen something's different? Not making my job easy.

At first I was wondering if the fact that I ranked loser above banana could affect which of you is th banana, but there really is no way to distinguish between you two. Hmm. Maybe the order in which we're listed matters?

I think I might just have to play this like normal win-lose-banana

Yeah, that would be best of course.

Also, reminder: pick me to win

[ashersky]

Wow, seriously you guys couldn't have chosen something's different? Not making my job easy.

At first I was wondering if the fact that I ranked loser above banana could affect which of you is th banana, but there really is no way to distinguish between you two. Hmm. Maybe the order in which we're listed matters?

I think I might just have to play this like normal win-lose-banana

Yeah, that would be best of course.

Also, reminder: pick me to win

Both incorrect.

f.ds rules says to always bet on ash.  If a setup has hidden mechanics, they will always favor ashersky.  It's just physics.

Also fruit. 

I don't even understand what's happening here.  Why exactly am I a banana?  But I am.

[liopoil]

Wow, seriously you guys couldn't have chosen something's different? Not making my job easy.

At first I was wondering if the fact that I ranked loser above banana could affect which of you is th banana, but there really is no way to distinguish between you two. Hmm. Maybe the order in which we're listed matters?

I think I might just have to play this like normal win-lose-banana

Yeah, that would be best of course.

Also, reminder: pick me to win

Both incorrect.

f.ds rules says to always bet on ash.  If a setup has hidden mechanics, they will always favor ashersky.  It's just physics.

Also fruit. 

I don't even understand what's happening here.  Why exactly am I a banana?  But I am.

You said you would rather be the loser than the banana. If the mechanics favor you, then wouldn't you be the loser?

[LaLight]

Wow, seriously you guys couldn't have chosen something's different? Not making my job easy.

At first I was wondering if the fact that I ranked loser above banana could affect which of you is th banana, but there really is no way to distinguish between you two. Hmm. Maybe the order in which we're listed matters?

I think I might just have to play this like normal win-lose-banana

Yeah, that would be best of course.

Also, reminder: pick me to win

Both incorrect.

f.ds rules says to always bet on ash.  If a setup has hidden mechanics, they will always favor ashersky.  It's just physics.

Also fruit. 

I don't even understand what's happening here.  Why exactly am I a banana?  But I am.

You said you would rather be the loser than the banana. If the mechanics favor you, then wouldn't you be the loser?

He in fact is. Looks like he confused the fakeclaim!

[liopoil]

LaLight, why did YOU say that you would prefer to be the loser over the banana?

I am aware that I also did this same thing, but I see no reason for me to talk about that.

[LaLight]

LaLight, why did YOU say that you would prefer to be the loser over the banana?

I am aware that I also did this same thing, but I see no reason for me to talk about that.

Actually, i think that winning as a loser is more exciting than winning as the banana

[LaLight]

And losing as loser is better than if i lose now

[ashersky]

LaLight, why did YOU say that you would prefer to be the loser over the banana?

I am aware that I also did this same thing, but I see no reason for me to talk about that.

Actually, i think that winning as a loser is more exciting than winning as the banana

Which is why you are trying harder.

[ashersky]

Wow, seriously you guys couldn't have chosen something's different? Not making my job easy.

At first I was wondering if the fact that I ranked loser above banana could affect which of you is th banana, but there really is no way to distinguish between you two. Hmm. Maybe the order in which we're listed matters?

I think I might just have to play this like normal win-lose-banana

Yeah, that would be best of course.

Also, reminder: pick me to win

Both incorrect.

f.ds rules says to always bet on ash.  If a setup has hidden mechanics, they will always favor ashersky.  It's just physics.

Also fruit. 

I don't even understand what's happening here.  Why exactly am I a banana?  But I am.

You said you would rather be the loser than the banana. If the mechanics favor you, then wouldn't you be the loser?

The odds of winning favor me.  If I had been the Winner, for example, liopoil would have been the Banana, as the mafia gods know I'd choose you.

[LaLight]

but liopoil will choose not according to mafia gods, but according to the common sense. Which is obviously me

[ashersky]

but liopoil will choose not according to mafia gods, but according to the common sense. Which is obviously me

Pretty sure no.

[LaLight]

but liopoil will choose not according to mafia gods, but according to the common sense. Which is obviously me

Pretty sure no.

You're pretty sure he will act according to Mafia gods? Then he'll lose.

[liopoil]

Ashersky, you win if I choose you no matter what you are. So the odds of winning favoring you has nothing to do with who you are. That you're pretending otherwise is suspicious

[liopoil]

LaLight, why did YOU say that you would prefer to be the loser over the banana?

I am aware that I also did this same thing, but I see no reason for me to talk about that.

Actually, i think that winning as a loser is more exciting than winning as the banana

Which is why you are trying harder.

Seriously, this is why he's the loser?

[LaLight]

LaLight, why did YOU say that you would prefer to be the loser over the banana?

I am aware that I also did this same thing, but I see no reason for me to talk about that.

Actually, i think that winning as a loser is more exciting than winning as the banana

Which is why you are trying harder.

Seriously, this is why he's the loser?

Just pick me here. Ash confuses his own words

[ashersky]

I never confuse my words.

He's the loser because I'm the banana.  He's scrambling because I'm the banana.  Banana doesn't worry.

[LaLight]

Banana does worry the same as loser does. We all are playing for our wincon here. turned out my wincon is the same with liopoil's one

[liopoil]

Hmmmmm.

[ashersky]

Banana does worry the same as loser does. We all are playing for our wincon here. turned out my wincon is the same with liopoil's one

I don't agree.  To me, loser is scum at Lylo, winner is IC.  The least pressured player is banana.  I'm in the easiest role -- if town loses, it's more liopoil's fault than mine.  (I know it's other town job to be towny enough, etc. but the guilt always resides with the wrong voter.)

[LaLight]

I personally struggle to give me and liopoil the win, that's why I am not so relaxed

[liopoil]

Banana does worry the same as loser does. We all are playing for our wincon here. turned out my wincon is the same with liopoil's one

I don't agree.  To me, loser is scum at Lylo, winner is IC.  The least pressured player is banana.  I'm in the easiest role -- if town loses, it's more liopoil's fault than mine.  (I know it's other town job to be towny enough, etc. but the guilt always resides with the wrong voter.)

You and lalight have exactly the same wincon, and so will play exactly the same way. I'm not sure how you're making this distinction, and fault has little to do with anything

[liopoil]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

[LaLight]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

[liopoil]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

[LaLight]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

[liopoil]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

[LaLight]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

[liopoil]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

Not sure what to think of this

[LaLight]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

Not sure what to think of this

I am on your side here, you just need to trust. Ask me anything, i have nothing to hide

[liopoil]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

Not sure what to think of this

I am on your side here, you just need to trust. Ask me anything, i have nothing to hide

Are you the loser?
Are you the banana?
Are you the winner?
Is the answer to exactly one of these four questions "yes"?

[LaLight]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

Not sure what to think of this

I am on your side here, you just need to trust. Ask me anything, i have nothing to hide

Are you the loser?
Are you the banana?
Are you the winner?
Is the answer to exactly one of these four questions "yes"?

Probably.

[LaLight]

Actually it depends on whether we win or lose. Than two of those statements contain "yes" as an answer

[ashersky]

Interesting.

[liopoil]

Wait, both of you should answer each of those four questions

[iguanaiguana]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

Not sure what to think of this

I am on your side here, you just need to trust. Ask me anything, i have nothing to hide

Are you the loser?
Are you the banana?
Are you the winner?
Is the answer to exactly one of these four questions "yes"?

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

[liopoil]

I would like to guess who the banana is but I would also like anyone who claims to be the banana to answer my questions

[LaLight]

Also that post seemed directly designed to make me feel guilty for "costing town the game" if I choose lalight. i'm choosing one of you to win the game and that's pretty much it.

Do you have a stance?

vote: ashersky

Damn, we've lost then

nice try?

No, i merely mean it

Not sure what to think of this

I am on your side here, you just need to trust. Ask me anything, i have nothing to hide

Are you the loser?
Are you the banana?
Are you the winner?
Is the answer to exactly one of these four questions "yes"?

Yes, if you pick ash
Yes
Yes, if you pick me
No

[liopoil]

Banana: LaLight

[LaLight]

aaaand you're right!

[iguanaiguana]

Liopoil and Lalight win together!

[liopoil]

Liopoil and Lalight win together!

cool! how did you assign roles?

[iguanaiguana]

Well making you the winner was the only fair way to assign roles and also share the answers.  So I did that. Then, coin flip for the two with the identical answers.

I wanted to do 'players get the choice of their signup order' but that either didn't work or didn't look fun.