Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Pages: 1 2 [All]

Author Topic: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Results!)  (Read 5100 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
+1

Results!
View Finalists
View Cards Submitted

This is the sixth contest for this year's set. This week's challenge: Design an Event!

Submission Rules

ē Each participant may submit one card per challenge.
ē Participation in previous or future challenges is not required to participate in this one.
ē Submit your card to me via this forum's messaging system. Submissions made after each week's deadline cannot be accepted.
ē Each card you submit must have a name, a cost, a list of types, and the exact wording that should appear on the card.  Also include a brief description of any special design considerations (e.g., Stash having a unique back), but do NOT include any other information, such as strategic commentary or examples about it would play.
ē The name you give your card will appear on the ballot. If multiple cards with the same name are submitted, I will differentiate them with letters in a randomly chosen order, e.g. [Card Name] A, [Card Name] B, etc. Cards themselves will likewise be listed in a random order on the ballot.
ē I will accept revisions to your contest entries provided they are submitted to me before the deadline.  If you submit a revision to an entry you have previously submitted to me, resubmit your revised card(s) in their entirety.
ē Only submit cards that are your own design.
ē You may submit cards that have been previously posted here in this forum, including those that have been refined by the community as a whole, provided you can still claim that the central conceit of the card -- and the majority of its final version -- is yours.
ē A single card might conceivably qualify for multiple challenges within this series. If your card doesn't win the first challenge you submit it to, you may submit it for any and all future challenges (until it wins), provided the card fits those challenges. This is particularly pertinent for cards that don't win the first of two slots for a large expansion, although depending on which card does win, your card may not qualify for the second challenge.
ē Do not disclose your submissions publicly, either in this thread or elsewhere!

Except where specified, you may not submit cards combine certain mechanics from multiple expansions. The idea is that you could simply slot the cards into their respective sets without needing components or rules specific to another set. Specifically:

ē Duration cards may only be submitted as candidates for a Seaside or Adventures slot.
ē Potion-cost cards may only be submitted as candidates for the Alchemy slot.
ē Cards that use VP tokens or cost $7 or more may only be submitted as candidates for a Prosperity slot.
ē Cards that use Coin tokens and cards that use overpay may only be submitted as candidates for the Guilds slot.
ē Cards that use Ruins (Looters) and cards that use Spoils may only be submitted as candidates for a Dark Ages slot.
ē Traveller cards, Reserve cards, and cards making use of player Tokens may only be submitted as candidates for an Adventures slot.

Many mechanics are fair game for any submission. The following is an incomplete list.

ē Victory/Action and Victory/Treasure hybrid cards.
ē Cards that allow you to choose an ability from a list.
ē Cards with on-buy, would-gain, on-gain, and on-trash abilities.



Challenge #6: Event

Design an Event card that would fit into the Adventures expansion. Such a card could have one or more of the following qualities:

ē Interacts with player Tokens (possibly including new Tokens).
ē May only be bought once per turn.
ē Almost anything else (except mechanics reserved for other expansions).

The winner from the first Event contest:

Quote from: scott_pilgrim
Odyssey

The player to your left moves your +1 Card and +1 Action tokens to an Action Supply pile (when you play a card from that pile, you first get +1 Card, +1 Action).

$4      Event

Keep in mind that voters may want something that fills a different niche this time around.

Submissions are due by the end of Monday, 2016-03-21.
« Last Edit: July 12, 2016, 02:57:54 pm by mith »
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #1 on: March 12, 2016, 04:48:59 pm »
0

The runner-up from the first contest will automatically be included in the preliminary voting. The author of this card is allowed to submit a new card as well. (As is scott_pilgrim, designer of the winning card.)

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)

Other cards from the previous contest may be resubmitted as is, tweaked, or discarded in favor of a new concept.
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #2 on: March 19, 2016, 08:26:38 pm »
0

Reminder: Deadline is Monday!
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #3 on: March 23, 2016, 11:38:42 am »
0

I'll get the voting started tomorrow sometime; I'll take submissions until I do.
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #4 on: March 23, 2016, 10:54:46 pm »
0

I'm excited!
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #5 on: March 24, 2016, 05:32:52 pm »
0

Having some stupid problem with google drive today, might not be posted til tomorrow.
Logged

AdrianHealey

  • Mountebank
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2244
  • Respect: +766
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #6 on: March 24, 2016, 06:57:16 pm »
+1

Ooooh :( Goodluck!
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #7 on: March 25, 2016, 06:55:52 pm »
0

Mith is online and there are two members viewing this topic. I'm hopeful!
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

yuma

  • Minion
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 694
  • Respect: +609
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #8 on: March 25, 2016, 07:00:17 pm »
0

Mith is online and there are two members viewing this topic. I'm hopeful!

You should be very hopeful. He is currently posting in this topic...

http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?action=who

/stalking
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #9 on: March 25, 2016, 07:07:08 pm »
0

Mith is online and there are two members viewing this topic. I'm hopeful!

You should be very hopeful. He is currently posting in this topic...

http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?action=who

/stalking
Saving this link for later!
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #10 on: March 25, 2016, 07:31:31 pm »
+2

Quote
Bonanza
Types: Event
Cost: $30
Gain the remaining victory cards in the supply.

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.

Quote
Cobbler
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Gain a silver to your hand. Each other player may gain a silver.

Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)

Quote
Crop Rotation
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Once per turn: +1 Card, then each player passes a card from his hand to the left at once, then put a card from your hand on top of your deck.

Quote
Disaster
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per turn: Trash the top 3 cards of any non-Victory Supply pile.
Flip your Pest token face up (It starts face down).

Pest token: When you would gain a Victory card, gain nothing instead. When you buy a non-Victory Action card, flip this face down

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.

Quote
Epic
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Epic token to an Action Supply pile. When you play a card from that pile, instead of resolving its normal effects, you may instead receive +1 Card and +2 Actions.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Once per turn: Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3

Quote
Lodger
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per game: Move your -1 VP token and your +2 cards token to an Action Supply Pile (when you play a card from that pile, you first get +2 cards). At the end of the game cards in your deck from the Action Supply Pile with the -1 VP token are worth 1 VP less than they would be otherwise.

Quote
Reconstruction
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
You lose your remaining actions (actions, not action cards).
Discard a card from your hand with a cost higher than $0. If you do, turn your Journey token up (it starts face up). If it's face up: +1 Action.
Return to your action phase.

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.

Quote
Reserves
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Attack token to an Action Supply pile (when you play a card from that pile first each other player reveals the top 3 cards of his deck, trashes one that costs between $2 and $5 and discards the rest. If a card worth $4 or more is trashed, move your attack token to a different Action Supply pile.)

Quote
Sabotage
Types: Event
Cost: $0
Pay the cost of an action card in the supply to place it under the Sabotage event. When any player plays a card from this card's supply pile they discard a card.

Quote
Salvage Yard
Types: Event
Cost: $1
Discard any number of cards from your hand. Gain a card from the trash costing up to $2 per card you discarded.

Quote
Siege
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Once per game: Put your Contraband token to an Action Supply pile which contains ten cards. When another plays a card from that pile, the player to its left names a card which can not be bought this turn.

Quote
Stronghold
Types: Event
Cost: $12
Set aside an action supply card putting your Province token on it. All copies you own are worth 6 Victory Points. When all copies of that card run out, the game ends at the end of the active players turn.

Clarification: You own the copy of the card you set aside.

Quote
Tollhouse
Types: Event
Cost: $1*
+1 Buy
Move your Pass token to Tollhouse.

In games containing Tollhouse, whenever you shuffle your deck: If your Pass token is on Tollhouse, remove it; otherwise, gain a Curse and a Copper and move your Pass token to Tollhouse.


This costs $1 more per empty Supply pile.

Setup: Add an extra Event costing $0 or $1 to the available Event cards.

Quote
Decree
Types: Event
Cost: $3
+1 Buy.
Move your Decree token to an Action Supply pile. Directly after resolving a copy of that Action, you may remove your Decree token from its Supply pile and play it again.
« Last Edit: March 25, 2016, 09:59:44 pm by mith »
Logged

ThetaSigma12

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1446
  • Shuffle iT Username: ThetaSigma12
  • Respect: +1393
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #11 on: March 25, 2016, 07:41:31 pm »
0

Not a fan of the cards with new tokens, except border crossing. I don't like the expensive events, and Bonanza looks like it came from the RBCI thread. The ones I do like are:
Border Crossing, Cobbler, Coronation, Invent, and Recruit.
A lot of intriguing concepts, but not very many seem like they would be delivered properly.
Logged
If you have a fan card you want to be created, just post about it here! I'd love to take a look at it.

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #12 on: March 25, 2016, 09:19:58 pm »
0

Insightful comment time!

Quote
Bonanza
Types: Event
Cost: $30
Gain the remaining victory cards in the supply.
I think this is a troll event. Sorry if it isn't, but this reads: "pay $30 and win the game."

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)
It feels like I've seen this before! I still like it, but maybe it should cost five. Concept is on point though.
Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.
A 'once per game' event just seems lackluster.
Quote
Cobbler
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Gain a silver to your hand. Each other player may gain a silver.
No, sorry. You can't play that Silver the turn you gain it, so it provides no benefit to you that your opponent doesn't get.
Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)
Hmmmmm, I think this is usually better than Pathfinding. On a Smithy, for example, you end up with a 10 card hand. With Pathfinding on a Smithy, you get up to eight cards in hand. I'd maybe like to see this with a cost changing mechanic, like 'this costs $1 per every non-empty supply pile.'

Quote
Crop Rotation
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Once per turn: +1 Card, then each player passes a card from his hand to the left at once, then put a card from your hand on top of your deck.
I think this is too weak. It's good for topdecking dead-drawn actions, but passing seems unnecessary.

Quote
Disaster
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per turn: Trash the top 3 cards of any non-Victory Supply pile.
Flip your Pest token face up (It starts face down).

Pest token: When you would gain a Victory card, gain nothing instead. When you buy a non-Victory Action card, flip this face down
I'm sorry, but I don't like this. Trashing from the supply doesn't appeal to me, and not being able to buy Victory cards is even less appealing.

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.
This is a better version of Crop Harvest in my opinion. I like it.

Quote
Epic
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Epic token to an Action Supply pile. When you play a card from that pile, instead of resolving its normal effects, you may instead receive +1 Card and +2 Actions.
This seems maybe a bit too powerful. Stick it on Poor House or Poor House or a trasher that you might want not to always trash with. Quite versatile, but maybe too powerful.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3
I'd prefer this with either a 'once per turn' clause or a '+1 buy' and 'once per turn' clause. I do like the investment type of thing though.

Quote
Lodger
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per game: Move your -1 VP token and your +2 cards token to an Action Supply Pile (when you play a card from that pile, you first get +2 cards). At the end of the game cards in your deck from the Action Supply Pile with the -1 VP token are worth 1 VP less than they would be otherwise.
This is really powerful, and adds two tokens. Turn Village into Lost City+ with a tiny drawback! Maybe add a current token like +1 card or +1 coin or something.

Quote
Reconstruction
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
You lose your remaining actions (actions, not action cards).
Discard a card from your hand with a cost higher than $0. If you do, turn your Journey token up (it starts face up). If it's face up: +1 Action.
Return to your action phase.
I've never liked returning to your action phase. Sorry event designer.

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.
I like this!

Quote
Reserves
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Attack token to an Action Supply pile (when you play a card from that pile first each other player reveals the top 3 cards of his deck, trashes one that costs between $2 and $5 and discards the rest. If a card worth $4 or more is trashed, move your attack token to a different Action Supply pile.)
Ugh, a trashing attack. I mean, just move this back and forth between your Village variant and Smithy variant. At least it heavily discourages Big Money, because they can avoid Golds and trash your Silvers forever with their cantrip.

Quote
Sabotage
Types: Event
Cost: $0
Pay the cost of an action card in the supply to place it under the Sabotage event. When any player plays a card from this card's supply pile they discard a card.
This shuts down cantrips though!

Quote
Salvage Yard
Types: Event
Cost: $1
Discard any number of cards from your hand. Gain a card from the trash costing up to $2 per card you discarded.
This relies on the trash, which is sort of okay. It's dead without TFB though, so that sort of sucks.

Quote
Siege
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Once per game: Put your Contraband token to an Action Supply pile which contains ten cards. When another plays a card from that pile, the player to its left names a card which can not be bought this turn.
This relies on hitting five early. If you open 5/2 though, slap this on Fish Vil and ruin the engine.

Quote
Stronghold
Types: Event
Cost: $12
Set aside an action supply card putting your Province token on it. All copies you own are worth 6 Victory Points. When all copies of that card run out, the game ends at the end of the active players turn.

Clarification: You own the copy of the card you set aside.
W-what? Pay $12 for $3 Provinces that do stuff?

Quote
Tollhouse
Types: Event
Cost: $1*
+1 Buy
Move your Pass token to Tollhouse.

In games containing Tollhouse, whenever you shuffle your deck: If your Pass token is on Tollhouse, remove it; otherwise, gain a Curse and a Copper and move your Pass token to Tollhouse.


This costs $1 more per empty Supply pile.

Setup: Add an extra Event costing $0 or $1 to the available Event cards.
I just do not understand this card. Sorry.
« Last Edit: March 25, 2016, 10:14:07 pm by Roadrunner7671 »
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #13 on: March 25, 2016, 09:20:12 pm »
0

Augh! Quoting sucks!
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #14 on: March 25, 2016, 09:56:00 pm »
0

Gah, sorry, two issues with the submissions. One, we had enough this time to push one to the second page of my inbox label, and it got left out. I also failed to copy all of another one. Fixing now!
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #15 on: March 25, 2016, 10:00:53 pm »
0

Ok, fixed. Decree is the missing card, and Invent is the one that changed.
Logged

Beyond Awesome

  • Global Moderator
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2901
  • Shuffle iT Username: Beyond Awesome
  • Respect: +2388
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #16 on: March 25, 2016, 11:18:21 pm »
0

I like the idea behind Siege. I just wished it would allow you to put the token on any action-supply pile. I don't see why the pile must have 10 cards on it when you buy Siege.
Logged

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #17 on: March 26, 2016, 12:15:19 am »
+1

I like the idea behind Siege. I just wished it would allow you to put the token on any action-supply pile. I don't see why the pile must have 10 cards on it when you buy Siege.

If you could use it on any pile, it becomes way too easy to punish another player after they've started building.  Even having 2-3 of something turned into contraband like that can be crippling.  Siege then becomes this oppressive event that that really discourages you from pursuing any action-based strategy.  And if nobody risks buying any action cards, nobody will buy the event either.  It's just toxic and removes options.

I don't think the current version works so well either, but I need to think about it some more.
Logged

Beyond Awesome

  • Global Moderator
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2901
  • Shuffle iT Username: Beyond Awesome
  • Respect: +2388
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #18 on: March 26, 2016, 01:20:53 am »
0


I like the idea behind Siege. I just wished it would allow you to put the token on any action-supply pile. I don't see why the pile must have 10 cards on it when you buy Siege.

If you could use it on any pile, it becomes way too easy to punish another player after they've started building.  Even having 2-3 of something turned into contraband like that can be crippling.  Siege then becomes this oppressive event that that really discourages you from pursuing any action-based strategy.  And if nobody risks buying any action cards, nobody will buy the event either.  It's just toxic and removes options.

I don't think the current version works so well either, but I need to think about it some more.

You may have a point. But there is also strategy playing around Siege with my suggestion. Though. It almost reads in its current form "veto this card"
« Last Edit: March 26, 2016, 01:22:27 am by Beyond Awesome »
Logged

LibraryAdventurer

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1029
  • Shuffle iT Username: LibraryAdventurer
  • Respect: +719
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #19 on: March 26, 2016, 02:31:47 am »
0

initial reactions:

Bonanza: ugh

Border Crossing: nice

Campaign: Might be okay, but it shouldn't cost 0.
As for Roadrunner's reaction to it: um, Inheritance? It's my favorite event and should be yours too since it's one of the best Scout synergies.

Cobbler: blah

Coronation: don't like it

Crop Rotation: An event masquerade, coool.

Disaster: no

Drinking Song: Should use a separate mat from reserve cards (which would call for another name), but otherwise might be okay. Maybe could cost $1 except that it's too similar to Save.

Epic: I kinda like it, but it should probably cost more. Also, don't like the name for this.

Invent: kinda cool.

Lodger: nope

Reconstruction: The 'return to the action' phase thing doesn't really appeal to me. I'd be willing to consider it, but I think in order to be worthwhile it'd have to draw cards. Also, think it's more complicated than it needs to be. Remove the journey token part and/or the discard and make it cost more.

Recruit: Why not say "the player to your left chooses an action or treasure costing $5 or $6. Gain the chosen card"?  I think it might be better that way. heavily board-dependant either way.

Reserves: yuk.

Sabotage: I don't think I like it. and it needs some explaination. Does the first card return to the supply if Sabotage is bought a 2nd time?  or does it stack?

Siege: oough

Stronghold: ick

Tollhouse: eww

Decree: I like it. (I'd probably remove the +buy and cost it at $2.)
« Last Edit: March 26, 2016, 07:19:54 pm by LibraryAdventurer »
Logged

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #20 on: March 26, 2016, 03:20:54 am »
0

I skipped the first Event contest, but I managed to come up with something for this one.

Quote
Bonanza
Types: Event
Cost: $30
Gain the remaining victory cards in the supply.

First to $30 probably wins the game.  2p with no alt VP, there are 80 points in the supply.  To lock in 40, you need 7 Provinces, or 6 Provinces + Duchy + Estate, or 5 Provinces + 3 Duchies + Estate... If any alt VP is available, it's even more likely that $30 will buy the win with this event.

I'm not opposed to the general idea, but I'm not sure about this one at all.

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)

Still sounds OK to me.

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.

The clarification is poorly written... I'm guessing it's supposed to say, "but you may buy any cards during the additional turn".

This sounds really interesting.  It's free and even comes with +Buy so you can trigger it whenever you want, but you only get it once.  Do you use it while you're building, or do you save it for a clutch mulligan when greening?

My only concern is that it might be optimal on most boards to use it immediately on your first or second turn to increase your overall tempo.  Theoretically, this just shifts up all your future turns so it makes no difference whether you use it early or late...

Quote
Cobbler
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Gain a silver to your hand. Each other player may gain a silver.

Gaining a Silver to your hand is practically worthless.  If you're already buying stuff, you can no longer play more Treasure.  If you could play the Silver, then this Event has an entirely different problem -- with just $1, you would be able to empty the entire Silver pile.  And as first player, this is probably in your best interest.  You'd probably be hitting Province every single turn from turn 3 onward.

But yeah, Silver in hand does nothing for you outside of some edge cases.

Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)

The effect as intended could be cool, but I don't know if it's worth the complexity.  I'm reminded of the playtesting story about how various tokens used to be able to go on kingdom cards in general, but were changed to only go on actions because people just didn't know what "kingdom cards" refers to.  This seems like it would be even tougher to get right.

Quote
Crop Rotation
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Once per turn: +1 Card, then each player passes a card from his hand to the left at once, then put a card from your hand on top of your deck.

The passing effect is usually neutral, but the trick is that you can choose the timing.  So you can just save it for when you have a Curse in hand or something.  You can also use it to save a card in hand for the next turn, but Save is both cheaper and better for that.  Overall this seems fine, but I'd rather let Masquerade have its unique gimmick.

Quote
Disaster
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per turn: Trash the top 3 cards of any non-Victory Supply pile.
Flip your Pest token face up (It starts face down).

Pest token: When you would gain a Victory card, gain nothing instead. When you buy a non-Victory Action card, flip this face down

So the Victory card blocking is only when it's face up, right?  This should be reworded to match the wording of the -$1 token.

I like it.  Powerful pile control at a significant cost.  Only concern: it should be reworded to move cards to the trash, rather than trashing them.  It makes a huge difference for cards with on-trash effects.  Just consider what this does with Fortress, Squire, Catacombs, Hunting Grounds...

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.

The simplest use of this card would be as an instant Island.  You can hide away Estates early and other VP later.  Not sure if that's too powerful, but it's available to everybody at basically all times so it sounds OK to me.  It will change the pace of the game a little and add interesting decisions of when to do it or when to put it off.  If it's too powerful an effect, it would be easy to add a "non-Victory card" restriction.

It also interacts with Reserve cards.  The notable one is Wine Merchant -- the $2 cost to retrieve Wine Merchant is the same, but with this event you can topdeck them.  If you have Champion or Lost Arts, it can become a sort of Golden Deck (probably still harder to pull off than most others).  With other Reserves, you can get them onto your mat without having to play them first, which may matter sometimes.  You can also put Copper onto the mat to buff Miser faster.

The most interesting use is as a controlled Native Village.  You can decide what to save on your mat and when to retrieve key pieces.  That should have many interesting use cases, but the one that stands out most is putting together combo pieces, whether that's Prince and a specific target or a 5 card game-ender like KC-Bridge.  Others will be able to see it building up too, so it's not just a surprise game-end.

Might be better if it cost $1 but without +1 Buy?  That would encourage slow but consistent use... but maybe then it's too easy to just island VP.  Or maybe it should cost $3?  I'm not sure.  But a more controlled NV is always a concept I enjoy, and I can see this being used in many different ways.

Quote
Epic
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Epic token to an Action Supply pile. When you play a card from that pile, instead of resolving its normal effects, you may instead receive +1 Card and +2 Actions.

The name doesn't work for me, but it is very powerful.  I'm pretty sure it's too powerful for just $5.  But at any cost, it doesn't sound particularly fun to me.  Turning key cards or cheap cards into optional villages seems like it would trivialize engine building.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Once per turn: Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3

I'd suggest making it once per turn and giving it +1 Buy.  As it is, if the board has no +Buy and no other Journey token card, this is entirely useless.

Lo and behold, the correct version of this submission does what I suggested. :P  OK, like this, I think it's a nice, simple event.

The trick with this card is that it'll be a net positive even if you buy it every turn, but sometimes it'll be better for you not to give up the $1 when you could buy something better, and sometimes it'll be better to wait on getting the net +$2 until you really need it.  Deciding when to wait is an interesting decision that will come up multiple times in a game.  I highly approve.

Quote
Lodger
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per game: Move your -1 VP token and your +2 cards token to an Action Supply Pile (when you play a card from that pile, you first get +2 cards). At the end of the game cards in your deck from the Action Supply Pile with the -1 VP token are worth 1 VP less than they would be otherwise.

I think this is far stronger than Pathfinding despite being half the cost.  -1 VP is not a huge penalty.  In most games, you are happy to give up multiple VP to make your deck stronger -- it's called Estate trashing!  Curses are bad because they are junk, but Lodger-ified cards are very much not junk.  This turns any non-terminal into a Lab, which is just ridiculous. 

Quote
Reconstruction
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
You lose your remaining actions (actions, not action cards).
Discard a card from your hand with a cost higher than $0. If you do, turn your Journey token up (it starts face up). If it's face up: +1 Action.
Return to your action phase.

The effect is just not worth the rules confusion that comes with "return to the Action phase".  Coin of the Realm already delivers a similar effect in a much better way.

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.

I like the general idea.  My first concern is that this is going to be an automatic buy too often.  There are usually at least two key $5s, and there's Gold.  Even if there are only two worthwhile $5+ cards, you can still safely buy this event.  Worst case, you just gain the $4 card you would have bought otherwise.

Maybe that's not so bad?  If there are at least 3 cards you want, it's a constant mini-game for your opponent to guess which 2 are best for you and to block those.  But my second concern is that this will drastically slow down the game as you always buy this and wait for another player to basically make a decision for you.  Overall, I don't know.

Quote
Reserves
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Attack token to an Action Supply pile (when you play a card from that pile first each other player reveals the top 3 cards of his deck, trashes one that costs between $2 and $5 and discards the rest. If a card worth $4 or more is trashed, move your attack token to a different Action Supply pile.)

This should be renamed so as not to cause confusion with the Reserve type.

I'm really not a fan.  I really think that the tokens should be simple effects.  The most complicated one in Adventures is the trashing token, and that's still straightforward.  The others are the -$2 and the 4 vanilla bonuses.  The effect of this Attack token is complicated enough to be an official card of its own... and in fact, it basically does already exist with Rogue and the Knights.

Quote
Sabotage
Types: Event
Cost: $0
Pay the cost of an action card in the supply to place it under the Sabotage event. When any player plays a card from this card's supply pile they discard a card.

I think this needs more of a limit.  As it is, it seems too easy to punish players who build engines.  Again, I think this would remove options (and thus remove fun) rather than opening up new ones.

Quote
Salvage Yard
Types: Event
Cost: $1
Discard any number of cards from your hand. Gain a card from the trash costing up to $2 per card you discarded.

The effect is interesting and uncommon on official cards, but useless if there isn't TfB or a trashing attack in the kingdom.  What are the chances of this Event being chosen along with TfB?  I'm not sure it's worth the card slot...

Quote
Siege
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Once per game: Put your Contraband token to an Action Supply pile which contains ten cards. When another plays a card from that pile, the player to its left names a card which can not be bought this turn.

As with Reserves above, this effect is too complicated to be a token IMO... and also like Reserves, it already exists -- as Contraband.  But I understand the desire to see that effect more often, and in a way that actually impacts the game, since Contraband is rarely bought.  So, here's a way to force it onto other players!

I commented earlier on why I think it's restricted to full piles.  If you can just use it on anything, it will scare people away from ever building, lest a single $5 buy cripple their entire deck.

But I don't think this tempered version works either.  It's a significant opportunity cost to buy this, and then the other players are in a fine place to adjust their strategy and avoid buying the Contraband-ified card.  It's only really interesting if you use it on a card that they clearly want but haven't bought yet (e.g.  they open with a strong trasher, indicating engine, and then you hit Village before they buy any).

Maybe if it was something like, "8+ cards remaining in the pile"?  But even that can be oppressive.  Worse, it can get very political.

Here are my suggested changes:

- Make it cheaper and maybe add +1 Buy to lower opportunity cost.
- Have it actually give other players a copy of the card.  Now it's either a dead card in their deck or they actually try to play around the Contraband effect.
- Clarify what happens if multiple other players have their token on the same card.  As written, if two other players have hit the same card and I play it, the player to my left bans two cards.  That doesn't sound like a good thing to me.  (This is not necessary if it gives out copies while keeping the full pile requirement.)

I think the general idea could work, but it would need many changes.

Quote
Stronghold
Types: Event
Cost: $12
Set aside an action supply card putting your Province token on it. All copies you own are worth 6 Victory Points. When all copies of that card run out, the game ends at the end of the active players turn.

Clarification: You own the copy of the card you set aside.

I don't think this can be balanced at any cost.  If it can be, it's going to to be a lot higher than $12.

Quote
Tollhouse
Types: Event
Cost: $1*
+1 Buy
Move your Pass token to Tollhouse.

In games containing Tollhouse, whenever you shuffle your deck: If your Pass token is on Tollhouse, remove it; otherwise, gain a Curse and a Copper and move your Pass token to Tollhouse.


This costs $1 more per empty Supply pile.

Setup: Add an extra Event costing $0 or $1 to the available Event cards.

The idea is neat.  I like that it (potentially) adds an interesting decision to every shuffle.  Can you find an extra $1 to spare each shuffle to avoid this penalty?  In practice, it's probably pretty easy to do.

I don't think there is physically enough space on an Event to fit all this text.  Events only have space for 3 lines.  This will have +1 Buy on one line, and then there is more text than Pilgrimage (which already takes up all available space without a line for +Buy).  It's just not going to work.

I don't like the increasing cost per empty pile.  I understand the reasoning -- later in the game, shuffles are longer and it's much easier to find $1 to spare, so the change would hopefully keep the pressure on.  But it doesn't matter enough to be worth the text space... which isn't even available.

The setup clause is even less necessary.  I guess the reason is to provide players with something else to do if paying the $1 breaks the bank... but why make an event that increases pressure and then include a clause that alleviates it?  But it's moot because, again, there is literally not enough space on the card for this.

So, I like the idea, but it really needs to be heavily streamlined.

Quote
Decree
Types: Event
Cost: $3
+1 Buy.
Move your Decree token to an Action Supply pile. Directly after resolving a copy of that Action, you may remove your Decree token from its Supply pile and play it again.

Not compelling since Adventures already has Royal Carriage.  This is less flexible and needs to be bought again to be reused.
Logged

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #21 on: March 26, 2016, 04:04:39 am »
0

Tollhouse was especially bad, but I decided to go back and check the others.  Events max out at 3 lines of text.  Vanilla bonuses (always +Buy on the official events) take up one line on their own.

Campaign looks like it will be 4 lines.  It might be possible to phrase it more succinctly.

Disaster is OK, assuming that the Pest token explanation is not on the Event itself.  Otherwise it's 4 lines, maybe more.

Drinking Song looks like it is just barely 4 lines.  If there isn't a way to cut down a couple words (or use a slightly smaller font), losing the +1 Buy and costing it at $1 might be a fine fix.

Lodger, Reconstruction and Reserves are about 5 lines of text each.

Siege is sitting at about 4 lines, but I'm pretty sure it can be pared down to 3.

Stronghold is at 4 as well.

Tollhouse is at a whopping 7 lines, and that's being generous and without counting dividing lines, of which there should probably be THREE.  There's the on-buy effect, the "in games using this" text, the cost-changing text and the setup text.  Drop the +Buy and the setup clause, it could be down to 4 lines of text plus dividing line... still too much.




To be fair, I know some people think that this is a bit nitpicky and that you shouldn't let your creativity be constrained by such pesky stuff as card space, but I firmly believe that it's an important consideration for card design.  If your text won't fit on the card, you're probably either trying to do too much or you need to do some streamlining.  The ones above that are 4 lines long are OK with me, because it shouldn't be too difficult to cut them down a bit.  More than that is too much though.
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #22 on: March 26, 2016, 12:36:00 pm »
0

I found a problem with Drinking Song :(

Just get a hand of 3 Golds a Copper and a Province and you have a golden deck. Every game.
« Last Edit: March 26, 2016, 12:47:13 pm by Roadrunner7671 »
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #23 on: March 26, 2016, 12:43:09 pm »
0

I found a problem with Drinking Song :(

Just get a hand of 3 Golds a Copper and your trasher and you have a golden deck. Every game.

Is that really a problem?  That's basically how Bishop golden deck works too.  Bishop retains fewer points per Province but doesn't need a third Gold, plus gets extra points while you're building to Golden Deck.  Drinking Song seems weaker for that purpose.
« Last Edit: March 26, 2016, 12:44:45 pm by eHalcyon »
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #24 on: March 28, 2016, 12:16:54 am »
0

Discussion is awfully quiet...
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

spiralstaircase

  • Golem
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 181
  • Respect: +330
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #25 on: March 28, 2016, 06:20:04 am »
+2

Discussion is awfully quiet...

OK, some thoughts on ones that jump out at me.

Bonanza: For $30, end the game, and maybe not win. Nope.

Cobbler: Being able to buy silvers I can't use yet for $1 each would definitely change the early game - $10 in turn 3! - but it feels like the drawback completely cancels the effect.

Crop Rotation: Not sure I'd want to masq without the trashing.  Makes me sad that we didn't get convolucid's Crop Rotation, which I'd have given my 10.

Drinking song: I like the idea, but it wants to put the cards somewhere of its own, and it needs "Native" in its name somewhere.

Epic: I'll have 10 Epic Smithies, please.

Lodger: I'll have 10 Village Lodgers, please.

Recruit: I like the idea, but it needs "Contra" or "band" in its name somewhere.

Reserves: With two cantrip piles this could get ugly.  I think it needs something so that once you've moved your Attack token off a pile, it can't go back there.  It also needs to give the card it's on the type "Attack", because as-is, they're un-moat-able.

Sabotage: Can I put a card under this twice?

Siege: I like the idea, but it needs... oh, there it is.

Stronghold: For $12, maybe get 60VP and end the game.  Swingy.

Decree: I like the idea, but I like Royal Carriage better.
Logged

ConMan

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1226
  • Respect: +1417
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #26 on: March 29, 2016, 07:28:06 pm »
+2

Quote
Bonanza
Types: Event
Cost: $30
Gain the remaining victory cards in the supply.
I kind of see the idea behind this, but I don't really like it. On most boards, if you can hit $30 you're probably going to win anyway (unless you've been doing so in the absence of +Buy and your opponent has just grabbed a Province every turn for the last 6 turns). And on Gardens and Fairgrounds boards, this is just silly and it will turn the whole thing into a race to hit $30.

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)
I didn't particularly like the idea of introducing *another* token when this appeared in the first contest, and I still don't. But I don't have any particular objections to the card idea itself (although I think it would be interesting to make the gaining compulsory).

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.
I guess that most of the time this is either "I got a rubbish hand this turn, going to try for a better hand next turn" or "Take two turns at the start of the game". I don't think I'm a massive fan of either possibility.

Quote
Cobbler
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Gain a silver to your hand. Each other player may gain a silver.
As others have pointed out, this is essentially "every player may gain a silver" since in most cases you won't be able to do anything with it (edge cases include Save, Farmlands). Not hugely exciting.

Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)
Again, I don't like having even more tokens, and the rules clarification makes this a bit ugly. Also, this turns too many cards into cwazy powerhouses (for a simple example, compare Pathfinding-Smithy to Coronation-Smithy).

Quote
Crop Rotation
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Once per turn: +1 Card, then each player passes a card from his hand to the left at once, then put a card from your hand on top of your deck.
This could possibly even cost $1, since about 90% of it is like a nerfed Save. The passing is cute, and unlike Masquerade it can't really be used in any kind of pin. It maybe doesn't even need the "Once per turn".

Quote
Disaster
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per turn: Trash the top 3 cards of any non-Victory Supply pile.
Flip your Pest token face up (It starts face down).

Pest token: When you would gain a Victory card, gain nothing instead. When you buy a non-Victory Action card, flip this face down
And again. I, too, don't really think trashing from the Supply does a lot of anything except annoy people. I don't think the Pest token is a bad idea in itself.

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.
I like this one, although I think it would have to be modified a little to prevent it being abused too much. It's nice to have an Event that makes use of the Tavern mat.

Quote
Epic
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Epic token to an Action Supply pile. When you play a card from that pile, instead of resolving its normal effects, you may instead receive +1 Card and +2 Actions.
Argh, more tokens. Is it really that Epic to be able to play a given card as a Village? It's nice for engines I suppose, but a little boring.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Once per turn: Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3
It's ok, I guess? It weakens the impact of having the wrong amount of money at the end of a turn, which I think is actually a bit of a pity.

Quote
Lodger
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per game: Move your -1 VP token and your +2 cards token to an Action Supply Pile (when you play a card from that pile, you first get +2 cards). At the end of the game cards in your deck from the Action Supply Pile with the -1 VP token are worth 1 VP less than they would be otherwise.
*Two* more tokens? And I still reckon it's not as interesting a decision as it might seem. Double-Pathfinding on a card in exchange for it being counted as a Curse? Whack it on the key engine card and you'll be gaining enough Victory cards you can ignore the VP loss.

Quote
Reconstruction
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
You lose your remaining actions (actions, not action cards).
Discard a card from your hand with a cost higher than $0. If you do, turn your Journey token up (it starts face up). If it's face up: +1 Action.
Return to your action phase.
Hmm. Yeah, not a huge fan of the "Return to your action phase" either, even if this version is somewhat nerfed. All you need is to have $2 spare and two cards worth discarding, which can easily just be starting Estates or whatever. I think a variant on "take another turn" would be slightly smoother, although at this point it can be a struggle working out whether such an effect actually lets you have another turn or not.

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.
I like this one. Maybe price it at $5 though?

Quote
Reserves
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Attack token to an Action Supply pile (when you play a card from that pile first each other player reveals the top 3 cards of his deck, trashes one that costs between $2 and $5 and discards the rest. If a card worth $4 or more is trashed, move your attack token to a different Action Supply pile.)
Another token, and even more complications. And a trashing attack that is different enough from Saboteur and Knights to cause confusion. Nope.

Quote
Sabotage
Types: Event
Cost: $0
Pay the cost of an action card in the supply to place it under the Sabotage event. When any player plays a card from this card's supply pile they discard a card.
Ouch. This makes it far too easy to hobble an opponent's strategy in uninteresting ways.

Quote
Salvage Yard
Types: Event
Cost: $1
Discard any number of cards from your hand. Gain a card from the trash costing up to $2 per card you discarded.
Still fairly innocuous. As an Event, it's not terrible that it may sometimes be useless.

Quote
Siege
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Once per game: Put your Contraband token to an Action Supply pile which contains ten cards. When another plays a card from that pile, the player to its left names a card which can not be bought this turn.
Arglflargl. Also, arglflargl.

Quote
Stronghold
Types: Event
Cost: $12
Set aside an action supply card putting your Province token on it. All copies you own are worth 6 Victory Points. When all copies of that card run out, the game ends at the end of the active players turn.

Clarification: You own the copy of the card you set aside.
Arglflarglbargl. Stronghold a cheap card and piledrive them? Even moreso if the card is something like Hamlet that incentivises its own piledriving?

Quote
Tollhouse
Types: Event
Cost: $1*
+1 Buy
Move your Pass token to Tollhouse.

In games containing Tollhouse, whenever you shuffle your deck: If your Pass token is on Tollhouse, remove it; otherwise, gain a Curse and a Copper and move your Pass token to Tollhouse.


This costs $1 more per empty Supply pile.

Setup: Add an extra Event costing $0 or $1 to the available Event cards.
Hneflbafl. Also, seriously having to pay a toll to avoid junking your deck every time you shuffle? Also, why do you also need another Event?

Quote
Decree
Types: Event
Cost: $3
+1 Buy.
Move your Decree token to an Action Supply pile. Directly after resolving a copy of that Action, you may remove your Decree token from its Supply pile and play it again.
[/quote]
Whrrrgbl. Although I think it's a neater implementation than Coronation. Actually, despite adding another token, I quite like this one.
Logged

scott_pilgrim

  • Jester
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 978
  • Respect: +1924
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #27 on: March 30, 2016, 04:15:07 pm »
0

I wrote up comments Monday but didn't post them (I was on a plane).

Quote
Bonanza
Types: Event
Cost: $30
Gain the remaining victory cards in the supply.

I don't think it's necessarily the worst idea ever, though I think similar ideas have been suggested and it could be implemented better.  One thing I don't like about this implementation is I think it's too cheap, and also it's way too automatic in Colony games, to the point it just shuts down most interesting Colony games.

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)

Same opinion as last time, this is a nice card that I'll probably vote for.

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.

This might work, though I feel like the territory is already covered by Mission.  Actually, I might have liked this better than Mission, but we already have Mission.  I'm not sure, I don't like the once per game restriction so much.  Don't you pretty much always want to do it as early as possible (like turn 1)?

Quote
Cobbler
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Gain a silver to your hand. Each other player may gain a silver.

Could be okay.

Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)

I think I posted this or something similar in the RBCI thread when Adventures came out.  It sounds really fun on the surface...but $8 is just not nearly enough.  Like, Pathfinding is $8 and just gives you +1 card, and every card is better than +1 card (well, it's sort of different for playing a card twice, but still).  For example, Throne Room just becomes a super King's Court, for cheaper.  Even a cantrip becomes a Lost City.  Throne Room works as a card because it takes up a card and an action, which makes playing the card twice less efficient.  An auto-throne on play is just insanity.

That being said, I actually thought about submitting an event like this for the contest, that trashed the card after playing it twice.  I can't decide whether that would be something you actually want.  But as it is, I think Coronation needs to cost like an absurd amount, which I'm not sure makes the game fun anymore.

Quote
Crop Rotation
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Once per turn: +1 Card, then each player passes a card from his hand to the left at once, then put a card from your hand on top of your deck.

I like the idea of a Masquerade event, and I think this is a good implementation.  $2 might be too expensive.

Quote
Disaster
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per turn: Trash the top 3 cards of any non-Victory Supply pile.
Flip your Pest token face up (It starts face down).

Pest token: When you would gain a Victory card, gain nothing instead. When you buy a non-Victory Action card, flip this face down

Sorry, I don't like it.  I'm not a fan of explicit pile control cards in general.  I assume the Pest token only does that thing when it's face-up?  I don't really see how the two effects are related anyway...I guess the idea is that you have to buy something else so you don't get to run piles and buy victory cards all at once.  But you can still do that in one turn, you just have to buy an action first.  Also, $4 is like insanely expensive for this effect.  I think you only do it if it wins you the game.

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.

Hmm itís sort of like a Native Village event.  You can be more intentional about the pseudo-trashing than Native Village.  The cards go on top of your deck instead of into your hand, but you can choose any number of them.  My gut says it should cost $1, but then it looks a lot better than Bonfire.  Either way, I think I like it.

Quote
Epic
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Epic token to an Action Supply pile. When you play a card from that pile, instead of resolving its normal effects, you may instead receive +1 Card and +2 Actions.

Probably fine balance-wise, doesnít seem exciting to me.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Once per turn: Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3

Thatís actually a pretty cool and very simple idea.  I think you buy it every turn, except when you really have the exact amount you want already.  Itís kind of like Borrow, or coin tokens, or something, but also different enough to be interesting.

Quote
Lodger
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per game: Move your -1 VP token and your +2 cards token to an Action Supply Pile (when you play a card from that pile, you first get +2 cards). At the end of the game cards in your deck from the Action Supply Pile with the -1 VP token are worth 1 VP less than they would be otherwise.

I donít think this is worth it for the extra complexity.  Itís like an ultra Pathfinding with extra drawback.  It just seems like it will be too crazy for something thatís not really new.

Quote
Reconstruction
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
You lose your remaining actions (actions, not action cards).
Discard a card from your hand with a cost higher than $0. If you do, turn your Journey token up (it starts face up). If it's face up: +1 Action.
Return to your action phase.

Thatís so many conditions itís hard to keep track of.  I donít think it needs to suck up all your actions; most of the time I would think youíre in the buy phase because either you ran out of actions (in which case sucking up actions doesnít do anything), or because you have no action cards in hand, in which case you wonít be buying it anyway.  So it could use some cleaning up (I donít think thereís even that much room for text on an event), but I think this is the best implementation of this kind of idea weíve seen yet.  I also think itís too cheap, even with all the other penalties.

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.

I like the idea of this one.  I think maybe the cost of the event and the cost of the gained card and the number of cards named should maybe be changed.  Thereís also an issue that it might slow down play.  On the other hand, it just means the player to your left makes some of your decisions for you, and you can think simultaneously.  It might be automatic, though I guess they can name cards costing $4 or less if they think those are better so itís not strictly better than buying other $4ís.

Quote
Reserves
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Move your Attack token to an Action Supply pile (when you play a card from that pile first each other player reveals the top 3 cards of his deck, trashes one that costs between $2 and $5 and discards the rest. If a card worth $4 or more is trashed, move your attack token to a different Action Supply pile.)

I donít understand the $2 to $5 range; $3 to $6 is much more natural and consistent with official cards, and makes a lot more sense, is less swingy, and makes it more of an attack.  The forcing you to move your token when you hit a more expensive card is clever.  I donít think I like the idea enough to be worth how much text it takes.

Quote
Sabotage
Types: Event
Cost: $0
Pay the cost of an action card in the supply to place it under the Sabotage event. When any player plays a card from this card's supply pile they discard a card.

Huh, itís like a weird Embargo variant I guess.  Seems okay.  If thereís multiple copies, do you discard twice?  I guess nothing in there indicates that you wouldnít.

Quote
Salvage Yard
Types: Event
Cost: $1
Discard any number of cards from your hand. Gain a card from the trash costing up to $2 per card you discarded.

Same as last time, I donít think I like it enough to vote for it.

Quote
Siege
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Once per game: Put your Contraband token to an Action Supply pile which contains ten cards. When another plays a card from that pile, the player to its left names a card which can not be bought this turn.

Cool ideaÖI think thereís too many issues with it to make it work though.  Retroactively applying it would have been one concern, but it looks like the designer was aware of that and thatís why itís restricted to full supply piles.  Well not quite because of Port and Rats and victory cards.  Rats would get hilariously awful if you sieged them.  If you want to see if you can place it on a particular pile, youíd have to count how many cards are in it, so thatís annoying.  And then I feel like it just becomes an Embargo more than anythingÖyou have to really want a card to be willing to play it even with the contraband effect.  But I do like that it discourages buying lots of powerful cards, like Cultist.  Either it makes the optimal play to skip Cultist, or else the optimal play requires lots of other cards getting banned, which makes things interesting.  The other issue is you donít want to open with it.  Itís only good once you and/or your opponent have committed to a particular strategy.  But by then, theyíve likely bought at least one copy of the card you want to ban.

Quote
Stronghold
Types: Event
Cost: $12
Set aside an action supply card putting your Province token on it. All copies you own are worth 6 Victory Points. When all copies of that card run out, the game ends at the end of the active players turn.

Clarification: You own the copy of the card you set aside.

Uh...this is insane.  If it were like 1 or 2 VP it would be cool.  But 6 VP is like, you donít care about Provinces any more.  Especially because you can pile out whatever card you put the token on to end the game.  Sorry, this is just way too game-warping, like in a way that makes games a lot less fun I think.  I also think itís not nearly expensive enough.  Youíll still go for it in basically every game.

Quote
Tollhouse
Types: Event
Cost: $1*
+1 Buy
Move your Pass token to Tollhouse.

In games containing Tollhouse, whenever you shuffle your deck: If your Pass token is on Tollhouse, remove it; otherwise, gain a Curse and a Copper and move your Pass token to Tollhouse.


This costs $1 more per empty Supply pile.

Setup: Add an extra Event costing $0 or $1 to the available Event cards.

This is a pretty cool idea.  I donít like the set-up clause because I donít really understand why itís there, and itís already a pretty crowded event; it canít really afford an extra line of text.  I do like that it costs $1 more per empty supply pile, that makes things get increasingly more interesting as the game goes.  My main concern is that players will forget about it when shuffling.

Quote
Decree
Types: Event
Cost: $3
+1 Buy.
Move your Decree token to an Action Supply pile. Directly after resolving a copy of that Action, you may remove your Decree token from its Supply pile and play it again.

This works better than Coronation.  I think it should say ďWhile your Decree token is on an that pileÖĒ because if followed literally as written, the Decree token doesnít actually do anything, and when you remove it, it doesnít unthrone that pile for you.  But of course we all know what it means.  I think it costs too much but itís hard to say.  Itís very roughly on par with giving you a one-shot cantrip version of a card you want.  Maybe thatís reasonable for $3 and no buy.
Logged

trivialknot

  • Witch
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 481
  • Respect: +693
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #28 on: March 30, 2016, 10:14:25 pm »
0

Thoughts on various cards

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.
It seems like you would always buy this on your first turn.  I suppose you could use it later to catch your opponent with a surprise rush?

Quote
Cobbler
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Gain a silver to your hand. Each other player may gain a silver.
This is too good in the rare case when you want a silver flood but your opponents don't, and otherwise useless.  I call that imbalanced.

Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)
I don't know why we want this throne room token to work so badly, it's never going to work in my opinion.

Quote
Disaster
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Once per turn: Trash the top 3 cards of any non-Victory Supply pile.
Flip your Pest token face up (It starts face down).

Pest token: When you would gain a Victory card, gain nothing instead. When you buy a non-Victory Action card, flip this face down
I like the idea of boosting rush strategies by trashing from the supply, and the pest token balances it a bit by making it hard to buy victory cards on the same turn you rush to the end.  But it's kind of complicated for the thing it's trying to do, and uninteresting when there's no rush strategy.  I strongly feel that supply pile trashing is better as an on-gain effect for a kingdom card.

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.
Compare to Trade.  You can pay $4 to island two cards from your hand, but you don't gain the silver.  I guess that's fine.  I might open with two drinking songs though.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Once per turn: Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3
You probably want to buy this almost every turn.  I don't think that makes it exciting, it makes it boring. 

This is crazy with other journey token cards.  For example, with pilgrimage you can pay $5 to instantly gain those copies.

Quote
Reconstruction
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
You lose your remaining actions (actions, not action cards).
Discard a card from your hand with a cost higher than $0. If you do, turn your Journey token up (it starts face up). If it's face up: +1 Action.
Return to your action phase.
As I mentioned with the last event competition, I designed an event that gives you a new action phase, but it was cheaper and simpler than this.  I think this event is overrating the value of having an extra action on demand.  Although, I suppose you could just discard estates?

Like invent, this has the problem that it doesn't interact well with other journey token cards.

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.
Alms is pretty crazy because you can gain a $4 whenever.  This strikes me as crazier than alms.  Basically, all $5 cards are discounted except for possibly the key card.  But you can still pick up the key $5 pretty easily because it no longer competes with the other $5s.

Quote
Sabotage
Types: Event
Cost: $0
Pay the cost of an action card in the supply to place it under the Sabotage event. When any player plays a card from this card's supply pile they discard a card.
I don't like a card that so easily shuts down engines.

Quote
Siege
Types: Event
Cost: $5
Once per game: Put your Contraband token to an Action Supply pile which contains ten cards. When another plays a card from that pile, the player to its left names a card which can not be bought this turn.
Why does this only affect opponents?  What if I buy siege on a card, then buy a copy of the card, preventing my opponent from doing the same to me?

Quote
Decree
Types: Event
Cost: $3
+1 Buy.
Move your Decree token to an Action Supply pile. Directly after resolving a copy of that Action, you may remove your Decree token from its Supply pile and play it again.
Sounds good, actually.
Logged

mustang255

  • Steward
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 28
  • Shuffle iT Username: Mustang255
  • Respect: +26
    • View Profile
    • Souva Games
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #29 on: March 30, 2016, 11:38:40 pm »
0

Overall: why does almost every single event card here have +buy and extra tokens? Is that just what people want out of events?
Logged

scott_pilgrim

  • Jester
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 978
  • Respect: +1924
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #30 on: March 31, 2016, 12:02:42 am »
+2

Overall: why does almost every single event card here have +buy and extra tokens? Is that just what people want out of events?

+buy is because a lot of events don't make sense without it.  On a lot of boards, you have no +buy, which means if your event also has no +buy, it has to be worth spending your entire turn on.  A lot of the cheaper events have effects that are inherently weaker than even the cheapest cards' effects (because they're one-shot), so they can't be worth spending your whole turn for, so they need +buy to make them worthwhile more often.

Tokens, I'm not so sure about.  I guess it's just a lot easier to come up with new ideas that make use of tokens, since they give you a lot of extra space to track things you couldn't otherwise and do new things with old cards.  New tokens are an automatic minus for me though, but not a huge one.
Logged

ConMan

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1226
  • Respect: +1417
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #31 on: March 31, 2016, 12:45:00 am »
+3

Overall: why does almost every single event card here have +buy and extra tokens? Is that just what people want out of events?

+buy is because a lot of events don't make sense without it.  On a lot of boards, you have no +buy, which means if your event also has no +buy, it has to be worth spending your entire turn on.  A lot of the cheaper events have effects that are inherently weaker than even the cheapest cards' effects (because they're one-shot), so they can't be worth spending your whole turn for, so they need +buy to make them worthwhile more often.

Tokens, I'm not so sure about.  I guess it's just a lot easier to come up with new ideas that make use of tokens, since they give you a lot of extra space to track things you couldn't otherwise and do new things with old cards.  New tokens are an automatic minus for me though, but not a huge one.
I think it's two things. One the one hand, it's the fact that Adventures already has such a plethora of tokens that you put on supply piles or other things and do stuff with. And on the other hand, it's what you say, that tokens let you keep track of stuff. So if you want a card that fits into Adventures and does X, the easy choice is to introduce a token that does X and make your Event put the token somewhere. I don't like it, mainly because I think there are still interesting things to do with the tokens already in Adventures, and with the concept of Events in general, but also because it seems a little like a cop-out to just add another token.

As for having +Buy, if you have an Event that does something "neat", but not super-powerful, then on a board where players only have one Buy per turn they will probably skip your Event in favour of buying a card that actually helps their deck. So by adding the +Buy, you're essentially just giving them something to spend that little bit of excess money on in addition to getting a useful card. Taking an example like Campaign (just because it's near the top of the list), if it didn't have the +Buy then you would almost exclusively use it on turns where you didn't get enough money to buy a card you wanted, whereas I feel like the person who wrote it instead wanted it to be like a mini-Tactician thing, letting the player give themselves a tiny boost at just the right point in the game.
Logged

Mr Anderson

  • Conspirator
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 233
  • Respect: +188
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #32 on: March 31, 2016, 04:50:22 am »
0

Thoughts on various cards

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.
It seems like you would always buy this on your first turn.  I suppose you could use it later to catch your opponent with a surprise rush?

I am not sure whether you want your extra turn that early. You get one turn ahead if you do and your opponent does not, plus you cycle faster. However, if you buy it when your engine is up and running, the turn will be much better, you might get ahead two or three "first shuffle turns".

Quote
Coronation
Types: Event
Cost: $8
Once per game: Move your Crown token to an action supply pile costing up to $4. (When you play a card from that pile from your hand, after you resolve it, play it again.)

Clarification: When you play it again, it's already in play, so the event's effect doesn't happen again. For the same reason, you only get one extra play if you use Throne Room, King's Court, Procession or Disciple to play the card; and none if you use Golem, Herald or Prince. (Procession and Disciple say to "Play an Action card from your hand twice", but for the purposes of this card that's "Play [an Action card from your hand] twice", not "[Play an Action card from your hand] twice", as the card does not return to your hand.)

I agree this card is super strong and can't be correctly priced as is, but I still like the concept.
Maybe you could weaken the card by moving the token to a cheaper action card or removing it after you played the action due to Coronation.
« Last Edit: March 31, 2016, 04:51:54 am by Mr Anderson »
Logged

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event
« Reply #33 on: March 31, 2016, 12:32:44 pm »
+2

Thoughts on various cards

Quote
Campaign
Types: Event
Cost: $0
+1 Buy

Once per game, if you did not buy any victory cards this turn, take another turn after this one. You may not buy any victory cards for the rest of this turn.

Clarification: You may not buy any victory cards the turn you buy this event but any cards during the additional turn.
It seems like you would always buy this on your first turn.  I suppose you could use it later to catch your opponent with a surprise rush?

I am not sure whether you want your extra turn that early. You get one turn ahead if you do and your opponent does not, plus you cycle faster. However, if you buy it when your engine is up and running, the turn will be much better, you might get ahead two or three "first shuffle turns".

But the thing is, it's the same either way.  Suppose you are going for that engine.  Let's say it takes 10 turns to really get running, at which point you can draw your deck.

Scenario A: you take your double turn early.  Engine is full speed on turn 9 and you draw your deck.  You draw your deck on turn 10 as well.

Scenario B: you wait on that double turn.  Engine is full speed on turn 10.  You take your double turn now, drawing your deck each time.

From turns 2-9, scenario is simply ahead of scenario B by one turn.  B catches up on turn 10.  From turn 11, they are identical.

So I think you pretty much always want the extra turn immediately, in case that one turn is the difference.  The only reason to save it would be the surprise factor to suddenly end the game with two turns of buying power, but that depends on the opponent tracking the game state well enough to make judgements on it yet failing to account for your double turn.

What the event needs is something that makes it more powerful if you save it for later.  Making it cost $2 might be enough, since that amount hurts more of you use it early.  Or maybe it could give you 7 cards for your bonus turn, which is valuable in different ways at different points in the game.
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #34 on: April 02, 2016, 11:45:35 am »
0

Results:

Border Crossing - 12
Recruit - 11
Decree - 9
Invent - 9
Drinking Song - 8

Crop Rotation - 7
Epic - 5
Salvage Yard - 5
Coronation - 4
Disaster - 4
Tollhouse - 4
Campaign - 2
Sabotage - 2
Cobbler - 1
Reconstruction - 1
Reserves - 1
Siege - 1
Stronghold - 1
Bonanza - 0
Lodger - 0
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Voting!)
« Reply #35 on: April 02, 2016, 11:47:55 am »
0

Quote
Border Crossing
Types: Event
Cost: $4
Move your Gaining token to an Action Supply pile (when you buy a card from that pile, you may gain a cheaper card.)

Quote
Decree
Types: Event
Cost: $3
+1 Buy.
Move your Decree token to an Action Supply pile. Directly after resolving a copy of that Action, you may remove your Decree token from its Supply pile and play it again.

Quote
Drinking Song
Types: Event
Cost: $2
+1 Buy
Choose one: Put a card from your hand onto your Tavern mat; or put any number of cards from your Tavern mat on top of your deck.

Quote
Invent
Types: Event
Cost: $1
+1 Buy
Once per turn: Flip your Journey Token over. If it's face up, +$3

Quote
Recruit
Types: Event
Cost: $4
The player to your left names two cards. Gain a card costing up to $6 that he did not name.

Submit your votes to me via this forum's messaging system. To vote, give each card a score from 0 to 10. (It is recommended, but not required, that you give at least one card a 0 and at least one card a 10, to maximize your voting input.) The winner will be the card with the highest sum. Feel free to discuss the cards (but not your scores) in this thread.
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #36 on: April 02, 2016, 01:04:44 pm »
0

So I'm underwhelmed by Decree, Recruit and Drinking Somg.

Decree is a one shot Throne Room for $3. It seems pretty weak. Why not just buy a $3 action and play it multiple times?

Drinking Song, in my opinion, is more comparable to Island than Save. The difference? It's cheaper and infinite, so you always build a deck that doesn't slow down when you green. Isn't finding ways to get past green cards one of the major parts of Dominion?

And Recruit seems like Feast+. There's always Gold, and there are usually a few juicy non-terminal Actions that are a great putchase for $4. Recruit just seems underwhelming; I'm okay with having Contraband's ability unique.
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #37 on: April 02, 2016, 02:10:36 pm »
0

Drinking Song, in my opinion, is more comparable to Island than Save. The difference? It's cheaper and infinite, so you always build a deck that doesn't slow down when you green. Isn't finding ways to get past green cards one of the major parts of Dominion?

My favourites are Drinking Song and Invent.  For me, Dominion is interesting because the different cards (and events!) introduce new things that make each game a different experience, so the possibility you describe is a feature, not a bug.  It still costs coins for every use so if you want to use the event as an Island, you need to do it with $2 less each turn you buy it.  That's not trivial!  I'm more interested in how it compares to Native Village.

The only finalist I really don't like is Decree.  I don't think it's worth the extra token to have something that's basically a worse Royal Carriage in the same set as Royal Carriage.

I have concerns about Recruit slowing down the game for either no effect or a huge effect depending on the board, but I do like the Contraband effect and would love this if it works out.

Invent is just really nice and simple.

I don't mind Border Crossing but I've cooled on it;  I am swayed by the recent comments regarding adding new tokens.
Logged

ConMan

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1226
  • Respect: +1417
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #38 on: April 03, 2016, 06:55:00 pm »
0

Aww, missed it by that much. (My card was Crop Rotation.)

I will think carefully about the finalists, and try to judge them absent my hang-up about having new tokens. That said, several of the finalists need to be adjusted either for balance or to more closely match what I assume is the intention of their creator.
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #39 on: April 03, 2016, 07:05:43 pm »
0

Mith, when are the finalist votes due?
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #40 on: April 05, 2016, 04:19:28 pm »
0

Monday-ish. Though I'll probably be a day or two behind on updating, so...
Logged

faust

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1779
  • Shuffle iT Username: faust
  • Respect: +2396
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #41 on: April 07, 2016, 08:02:55 am »
+1

Is there something I'm not getting about Invent? It seems bad. To me there are two cases:

A) There are other Journey token card on the board.
In this case, it's just ridiculously powerful, yes? Like game-breakingly so. For example, it turns Giant into +$4 plus the attack, which is crazy. Or Pilgrimage into $5, gain 3 different cards you have in play. Also crazy. This does not seem like a thing you want to do.

Then, there is

B) No other Journey token cards.
In this case.. it simply turns the Journey token into a glorified coin token? Like it would not be that different if it simply gained a coin token once per turn. Which is... okay-ish, but not all that interesting?

So either the author was going for A, which I think is really bad, or for B, in which case I think this should be solved via coin tokens rather than using the Journey token to avoid A.
Logged
Since the number of points is within a constant factor of the number of city quarters, in the long run we can get (4 - ε) ↑↑ n points in n turns for any ε > 0.

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #42 on: April 07, 2016, 01:43:25 pm »
0

Is there something I'm not getting about Invent? It seems bad. To me there are two cases:

A) There are other Journey token card on the board.
In this case, it's just ridiculously powerful, yes? Like game-breakingly so. For example, it turns Giant into +$4 plus the attack, which is crazy. Or Pilgrimage into $5, gain 3 different cards you have in play. Also crazy. This does not seem like a thing you want to do.

Then, there is

B) No other Journey token cards.
In this case.. it simply turns the Journey token into a glorified coin token? Like it would not be that different if it simply gained a coin token once per turn. Which is... okay-ish, but not all that interesting?

So either the author was going for A, which I think is really bad, or for B, in which case I think this should be solved via coin tokens rather than using the Journey token to avoid A.

On B:

The trick with this card is that it'll be a net positive even if you buy it every turn, but sometimes it'll be better for you not to give up the $1 when you could buy something better, and sometimes it'll be better to wait on getting the net +$2 until you really need it.  Deciding when to wait is an interesting decision that will come up multiple times in a game.  I highly approve.

The tempo is very different than it would be with coin tokens because you can't continue stockpiling them.

On A, I guess it needs testing but I think having that craziness once in a while would be fun.  I mean,  there are some other wild combos around.  MS-Hermit, CH-Travelling Fair, Proc-Fortress... I like that combos like this exist, as long as they aren't in every game.  It would be different if the combo made the game miserable, like a super easy pin, but I think the journey token ones would be OK.
Logged

mith

  • Board Moderator
  • *
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 742
  • Shuffle iT Username: mith
  • Respect: +716
    • View Profile
    • MafiaScum.net
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #43 on: April 14, 2016, 06:11:39 pm »
+1

Results:

Recruit (scott_pilgrim) - 79
Invent (Roadrunner7671) - 69
Border Crossing (spiralstaircase) - 51
Decree (Fragasnap) - 41
Drinking Song (eHalcyon) - 28

Congrats, scott_pilgrim! (2 for 2 with "player to your left" $4 Events!) Sorry for the delay in updating, but there wasn't as much urgency since we're on a break... We'll be back sometime in May!
« Last Edit: April 14, 2016, 06:13:26 pm by mith »
Logged

eHalcyon

  • Adventurer
  • ******
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 8689
  • Respect: +9126
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Results!)
« Reply #44 on: April 14, 2016, 07:49:22 pm »
+3

I tried, Roadrunner!  I gave you a 10.
Logged

XerxesPraelor

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1066
  • Respect: +359
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Results!)
« Reply #45 on: April 14, 2016, 11:20:53 pm »
0

The result is probably the order I would have ranked them in.
Logged

Roadrunner7671

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1844
  • Shuffle iT Username: Roadrunner7672
  • Forum Mafia Record: 17-32-2
  • Respect: +1317
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Results!)
« Reply #46 on: April 14, 2016, 11:22:32 pm »
0

I tried, Roadrunner!  I gave you a 10.
Thanks man.

So congratulations to Scott! I like my Event, but I'm not sure if it's a good fit for Adventures. Regardless, it's still nice that people liked it!
Logged
Oh God someone delete this before Roadrunner sees it.

tristan

  • Saboteur
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1138
  • Respect: +192
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #47 on: April 15, 2016, 01:52:28 am »
0

Then, there is

B) No other Journey token cards.
In this case.. it simply turns the Journey token into a glorified coin token? Like it would not be that different if it simply gained a coin token once per turn. Which is... okay-ish, but not all that interesting?

So either the author was going for A, which I think is really bad, or for B, in which case I think this should be solved via coin tokens rather than using the Journey token to avoid A.
Perfect analysis. I'd like to add the obvious, that a "non-terminal" Coin token gaining event for 1$ is extremely overpowered. You can always transfer one unused Coin without any cost!
Asper once had such an Event that cost 2$ and it was too strong (albeit without the once per turn restriction, I think that once per turn such an Event is fine).
Logged

drsteelhammer

  • Torturer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1516
  • Shuffle iT Username: drsteelhammer
  • Respect: +1428
    • View Profile
Re: 2016 Treasure Chest Design Contest - Part 6: Event (Finalists!)
« Reply #48 on: June 09, 2016, 07:19:36 am »
0

Results:

Recruit (scott_pilgrim) - 79
Invent (Roadrunner7671) - 69
Border Crossing (spiralstaircase) - 51
Decree (Fragasnap) - 41
Drinking Song (eHalcyon) - 28

Congrats, scott_pilgrim! (2 for 2 with "player to your left" $4 Events!) Sorry for the delay in updating, but there wasn't as much urgency since we're on a break... We'll be back sometime in May!

Is that next May?
Logged
Join the Dominion League!

There is no bad shuffle that can not be surmounted by scorn.
Pages: 1 2 [All]
 

Page created in 0.221 seconds with 20 queries.