So, silver.
Early on, he was all about iguana, got bogged down in a scumslip discussion. IIRC he never really dropped his suspicion of igua, we'll see how that plays out.
I like that much more!
but I'm not so sure about igu being scum anymore after his most recent posts. His 'I went wrong as town last game, I'm not gonna do that mistake again' read genuine to me.
is your vote serious?
Or not.
Votes for Ampharos, WW, then back to Ampharos, whom he pushes a lot. He then grows unsure about Ampharos.
Declares RR obv!town, votes Awaclus, then Haddock, then Hydrad for posting only fluff.
Calls a Hydrad/yuma/iguana team. Those are never very serious, but it does mean he still suspected iguana.
Well, he votesiguana again after his reads list, so there's that too.
see, this is one of the reasons why you are scummy, although not the most important one.
You think reads lists are towny. So you make a reads list, and now you expect to be towny because of it.
It does not work that way. towniness is not some progressive point gathering, it's a judgement of your alignment. Every scum can sit down and write a reads list. It depends on the content.
That's bad for you both because you have being towny in the forefront of your mind, and because you gave Amph unjustified town points.
Increasingly clashes with yuma over many things, mostly silver's case on iguana (he makes a case on him based on iguana's reads list somewhere in there). Things get out of hand.
Then votes Ampharos because his iguana vote is not doing anything.
After being absent for a while, comes back and asks if there's support for a Haddock or WW lynch. Still wants to lynch iguana.
Votes yuma for being inconsistent about the use of his power.
There are lots of towny people this game, not so many scummy people.
let's see
Witherweaver
yuma
silverspawn
Teproc
iguanaiguana
Hydrad
Roadrunner7671
2.7...
faust
Ampharos
EgorK
Awaclus
Haddock
At some point in here he sheeps me on e.
vote: YPG
vote: Awaclus
vote: e
we should lynch one of those guys. too much stalling is going on right now.
So... silver was moving his vote around a lot. By the end of day 1, he was clearly saying he was pretty unsure of his reads. Pretty much the only consisten thing is his scum read on igua (and his town on read on RR). He also suspected Ampharos a lot,and yuma to a certain extent. ENded up reversing on WW/Haddock, didn't look like a very strong read either way.
Didn't see any hintof PR, which, you know, he wasn't one so that makes sense.
Briefly looking at reads list towards the end of the day, it's not like he was a consensus town read either. But I guess no one really is in this game.
So... the obvious explanation here is "silverspawn is active, not the most likely to be lynched, generally pro-town, let's kill him". But why him more than other players who fit that description (there are a few) ? As scum, I kill people I think are going to suspect me in the future, preferably if they're not suspecting me now. I don't think iguana would have been that worried about silver : he continually failed to get support there, and killing him only serves to bring his case in the light again. I think his kill makes me suspect his null reads the most, from the above reads post. So that's {Teproc, Hydrad, 2.7, faust, Egork}.
There's also yuma, though I still think he's town. Annoying, but town. And there's Ampharos, whom I specifically reread during the night and concluded he was town. His reads are constantly moving in a way that feels ery organic, I think most of the suspicion he got was a playstyle thing, he's very self-aware, like silver actually when he started playing here.
Author
Topic: M72: Marvel Heroes Mafia (Town Wins!) (Read 324700 times)