Oh, yeah, this compares a little too well to Pawn. Pawn is kinda on the weak side so it wasn't too hard of a mistake to make. I mean, it's not -strictly better- than Pawn because you can't play +1 Action +1$, but using Pawn as a guideline it does seem a tad strong.
I want it to be cheap because I want it to be easy to use +buy to pick up more of them, so I'd rather not raise it to 3$. Maybe if I axe the latter two options? I wanted to have some options you'd almost never pick at the end, for fun, but I didn't want them to make the card too strong to be 2$.
So maybe like:
Fiddler
2$ Action
Choose one: +2 Cards, +1 Buy; +1 Card, +1 Action; gain a card costing up to 2$; put a card from your hand on top of your deck.