OK. So. Rereading:
Roadrunner.
Weird - kinda goes without saying.
Almost never explains his votes, which is frustrating but then he hasn't been horribly off-target so whatever.
Seems to think that everything he says should be accepted as perfect truth by everybody.
D1: Is completely ignorant of how mafia works. Pushes faust early for no reason. Claims VT, super weird. Ends up on the right place (ie. early on the ash wagon), which given how quickly that developed is definitely a not-mafia-tell.
D2: Is completely ignorant of how mafia works. First to vote for yuma. Superinconsistent in his discussions of gkrieg, finds him scummy then doesn't then does etc. (possible town tell?) Then randomly jumps off the wagon just as yuma gets hyperscummy. Realistically this must surely be TOO obvious a play for RR to ever be mafia.
D3: Is completely ignorant of how mafia works. Not much to say about D3.
D4: Is completely ignorant of how mafia works. Is also totally panicking.
In sum: No way is RR ever mafia. It's just not possible. The interactions with ash and yuma just make it so unlikely. So he might be SK, but on rereading I don't find him as scummy as I thought. His biggest towntell is that he doesn't really seem to pay very close attention to the game. But he still might be SK. One thing is how quickly he matched up NKd players with players who found me scummy. I think that might be a mild SKtell, I can maybe see an SK killing people who've been vocal about a particular player, to try to push suspicion onto them.
Awa:
I'm not gonna split him day by day, he hasn't had as much to say as RR. One thing: he's been terrifyingly right all game. Like all of the people he's properly pushed to lynch have been scum, and vice versa. So either he's town/SK and epically on point, or he's been playing the boldest mafia line I can imagine. I don't think the second is likely. Says he's definitely going to vote RR then doesn't do so, which inconsistency might be a town tell? Suddenly massively vocal today, which is weird for him. But I dunno. MAYBE he's the SK, but as much as anyone can read Awa I read him as town.
Ichi:
Aw man this is sad. I had something of a town read on him, just from gut, but I'm having to change my mind slightly now. I could see him as the mafia partner, probably not the SK.
His biggest real towntell is inconsistency re. a few people, me being one. But he's been very wrong with all of the things. Not on the ash wagon (which doesn't mean much in fairness, that was so so quick). Not on the yuma wagon, which reads scummy to me, and pushed for Hydrad's lynch fairly hard.
I still don't read Ichi as superscummy, but where previously I couldn't have seen him as mafia, now I could.
Chairs:
Lurky as hell. 28 posts total. Of those, 3 are an unexplained vote and nothing else, 3 are an unexplained vote couched in some small discussion of stuff not related to the vote, and 1 is him going v/la. So yeah, that's a quarter of his posts done. Has said absolutely nothing today! Yeah chairs is scummy, sorry. He could be either, but I think SK is slightly more likely.
Author
Topic: M70: Switch Mafia 2 (Game Over!) (Read 137439 times)