okay let's do this then
Somehow that amounts to a decent day 1 scumread?
yes, the points that are not null together amount to a decent scum read. I will show you - here is my quote with all parts erased that I said I considered null
first ash has these two posts
which are def both super scummy, as I've gone over already
then he pushes RR, which is bad. not that bad though. RR is my strongest townread, but I could see town!ash doing it.
also, not a single post of him gives me town vibes.
This leaves 3 points left. #1 are your first 2 posts, #2 is you pushing PR (which is 'bad but not that bad' meaning it gives mild scum points), and #3 is that nothing you did gives me any town feelings. They are enough for a decent day 1 scum read, meaning they amount to a read that has about about average confidence among my set of previous day 1 reads. this average confidence is of course not very high, because mafia is hard and it's day 1.
This is what I meant with the post, it is what I said in my post, and it is what I now reiterated to make it abundantly clear.
You continue to let your personal feelings for how I "wrecked" your fanfiction game by using a plan you thought was "bad" to win the game in a way you didn't like mess with your game.
No... I don't do that at all. First of all,
I don't have negative personal feelings towards you.I keep little files for all persons in my life in my head. Whenever they do something, that adds to their file and my interpretation of this. I do this because I am obsessed with character interpretation. And believe it or not, your file has changed very marginally due to what happened in fanfiction mafia. It basically only confirmed what I thought previously and added some minor touches.
Second of all, there is no evidence for me letting any personal feelings come in the way. Actually, I deliberately avoided confronting you in any way at all to make the chance for this argument happening as small as possible, because I suspected that you would snap as soon as I push your case in any way, no matter how careful I am - because that fits in line with how I interpret your personality - and so I tried not to do that. Until I have to, like I did twice this day; once early on after you made your posts that gave me the initial scum read, and another time now, because I think you might be the best lynch for today. Further dodging you in order to avoid confrontation would be anti town.
At this point, I'm disgusted with it and am pretty much at the point where I feel like we should just avoid playing forum games together. Which is sad, but it's what happened with Eevee, and I guess can happen again.
You can do that, but I think you're a fascinating person and won't try to avoid playing with you.