My PoE list is:
e
Hydrad
Ichi
Silver
Ghacob
Awaclus
Mail-Mi
Secondary (i.e., crossed off but not really a strong read) would be:
Chairs
Ash
Lekkit
Definitely no-kill is:
Hockey
Wither
DeDe
Thoughts on the list:
Silver: I'm inclined to think that the sole defending of Hockey is suspicious a la white knighting. He seemed somewhat genuine, though. Probably towards the bottom of preference.
Ichi: Pretty null here. He goes after DeDe after I cast initial suspicion on DeDe, then goes to Hockey when that picks up some steam, so some suspicion there.
Hydrad: I can't remember any content from him.
e: I don't have a read here. Lower on preference I think.
Ghacob: I'm not sure what to think about him. His treatment of Mail-Mi I thought was a little odd.. he was voting Mail-Mi, Ash pushed hard, and then Ghacob unvoted?
Awaclus: I don't think there's much content there.
Mail-Mi: Jumped on the hockey wagon, but he was right that hockey was scummy. If he was scum looking for a reason, he had a perfectly good townie one. I'm not sure what else he's done except argue against shooting. Being the only person to do so, that's a little bit of town points (logic being scum doesn't like to stand alone---lots of attention).
I guess my preference would be the unknowns first, something like.
Awaclus > Hydrad > Ichi > Ghacob > e > Mail-Mi > Silver
That ordering isn't too precise, though.