Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

I'm not sure I've ever seen Hydrad so not present. 

[Hydrad]

I'm not sure I've ever seen Hydrad so not present.

On lunch now for a bit so I'll try to catch up and post thoughts right away

[jotheonah]

or, we could do Hydrad first. That's probably even better. but one of those two.

I think IG is a better choice. He's a much more informational lynch, more interactions to analyze. Plus, he's likely a VT if he's not scum (since he's been at L1 multiple times and never claimed). And if my theory is right he's a roleblocker, so so much the better to get rid of him.

[Eevee]

Post count, because I have no clue. Rereading Hydrad after this.

WW: 152
silverspawn: 113
Eevee: 108
IG: 80
joth: 71
faust: 59
Hydrad: 55
ashersky: 39
jimmm: 11

Well, my first impression is that both Jimmm and ashersky have been getting remarkably little scrutiny for their underposting. Jimmm is often a low poster, but not to this extent, and I don't think I've ever seen ash be such a non-factor halfway through day 2. Of Jimm's 10 posts after the game started, 5 were about Robz's avatar change and his only post today reads "And we are back."

[Witherweaver]

I have too many town reads this game... I tried figuring out who I wanted lynched if not WW (I'm less sure about him now, it's still decent, but maybe there are other options). And really all people who are active seem townie. There may be scum in Hydrad/Jimmmmm/ashersky, who are all very much absent, but there's not really a case for them. I could do Hydrad I guess.

By the way, this was the same thinking that led me to vote for Jimmmm, and then Hydrad, earlier.

[Witherweaver]

Why is it you think Ichi is town?

I don't think his reaction to silverspawn's claim was something scum would do.

This didn't stop you from voting for him a couple times yesterday, though.

[Eevee]

Reread Hydrad.

I don't think he's scummy. Generally I see him considering all the angles and making a ton of sense all the way. Sure, he hasn't posted a lot but enough to touch on almost all the topics people are discussing, and probing others with questions constantly. I don't know, I don't get a scum vibe, I think he's played fine.

I do agree it would make sense for scum to be in the low posters given how the more active people don't appear scummy. I do have a bad feeling about WW I can't quite explain.

[Eevee]

It's hard to say anything about Jimmm since the only information we have is that he voted for SS for his VT claim and found IG scummy early (and we don't know IG's alignment), and that he hasn't been posting much at all.

I guess I could go reread ash to see what he has been thinking since I have no idea.

[Eevee]

Ash was more active day 1, although a lot of it was setup pondering. Biggest things I found were that he didn't suspect IG, suspected me for being hedgy, I don't think I ever got a response when I asked him to elaborate why he thought it was scummy, and the whole thing was quickly forgotten. Mentioned suspicion on ss and town reads on joth and WW.

Ash, where is your head at now?

[Hydrad]

Ok so here are my reads right now.

I'm going to do a scale of 1 - 10. where 10 is most likely scum and 1 is towny. 5 is null

WW: Still like fausts case on WW and is one of my higher scum reads. 8
silverspawn: Don't think scum would pull that VT move. seems towny but if there is a SK I think hes it. still think hes more town then SK though. 3
Eevee: Can't read this game that well. weird that he pushed xp and no one cares that much about it. 5
IG: Still feels really towny to me. 2
joth: I still think joth is scummy. I'm not sure how everyone seems to have such a town read on him. 7 for me.
faust: Only played with in dice mafia. I feel like his playstyle is different so this ones a bit more of a gut read. 7
Hydrad: -1 so towny i'm off the scale
ashersky: very little info but don't think town or scum asher would lurk for much reason. slight town read I guess but very little info to go off of 4.9
jimmm: for lurking and POE he is one of my higher lynch wants now. This is probably one of my more willing lynches as letting someone lurk till the end makes it almost impossible to read them to see if they are town or scum. I feel like this is what kinda happened in zelda mafia where I just couldn't build a case on him and he ended up winning there. 8

With this in mind I actually want to go for Vote: Jimmm Now.

PPE:3

[Witherweaver]

Vote: Hydrad

[Hydrad]

Vote: Hydrad

Do i get a reason?

[Witherweaver]

Vote: Hydrad

Do i get a reason?

Would one convince you to vote for yourself?

[silverspawn]

1 - 10 scales are stupid. either make it 1 - 9 or 0 - 10. five isn't even in the middle of 1-10

[silverspawn]

plus i never understood why people make 1 the lowest score. one is, like, one. one point. something. you give him a point. why give the worst thing a point?

it should start with zero.

[Hydrad]

1 - 10 scales are stupid. either make it 1 - 9 or 0 - 10. five isn't even in the middle of 1-10

hmm thats true. ok lets say thats 0-10 now. the numbers would be almost the same and now 5 is in the middle.

[silverspawn]

I don't have many actual things to say about your reads. the fact that you make long posts makes me think you're scum. this list could easily be done by scum!hydrad.

[Hydrad]

Vote: Hydrad

Do i get a reason?

Would one convince you to vote for yourself?

nope. but I guess it might help others vote for me if you reason is good enough. and I'm kinda curious.

[Witherweaver]

Why not make the scale from -95 to 105?

[Eevee]

I agree with most of Hydrad's reads (I think faust is towny is the biggest difference). Town read strengthens (<-- one of the hardest words to spell or what?).

[Hydrad]

Why not make the scale from -95 to 105?

i feel like I don't want to use a scale anymore... I thought it was a good idea.

[Eevee]

Silver, the argument that Hydrad is more polished than usual did enter my mind, but ultimately, at least for today, I want to give the guy who thinks similarly to me the benefit of the doubt.

[Jimmmmm]

Sorry guys, letting another one slip. I'll catch up today, I promise.

[faust]

Post count, because I have no clue. Rereading Hydrad after this.

WW: 152
silverspawn: 113
Eevee: 108
IG: 80
joth: 71
faust: 59
Hydrad: 55
ashersky: 39
jimmm: 11

Well, my first impression is that both Jimmm and ashersky have been getting remarkably little scrutiny for their underposting. Jimmm is often a low poster, but not to this extent, and I don't think I've ever seen ash be such a non-factor halfway through day 2. Of Jimm's 10 posts after the game started, 5 were about Robz's avatar change and his only post today reads "And we are back."

Ash is still VLA, I think.

[faust]

Why is it you think Ichi is town?

I don't think his reaction to silverspawn's claim was something scum would do.

This didn't stop you from voting for him a couple times yesterday, though.

Well, I changed my mind. I hear you know something about that, right?