Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10
 1 
 on: Today at 05:21:08 am 
Started by Donald X. - Last post by ossiangrr
Sculptor->Ducat could be pretty good.

 2 
 on: Today at 05:20:17 am 
Started by Donald X. - Last post by Minotaur
I feel like this Seer has overseen a lot of Experiments.

 3 
 on: Today at 05:16:10 am 
Started by LaLight - Last post by SpaceAnemone
Galz and gkrieg seem entrenched in their silver case.

I've left my "test vote" on Galz because I think he's being lazy about giving a good justification. Gkrieg is trying harder, at least, but I still don't think it's enough to go on.

I'm not saying I think silver is conf!town, but I'm saying I'm not interested in the cases on him today.

yes I know, I wasn't trying to dissolve your previous comments. I was just reading through from start to finish and posting all of it as I went.

Yeah, but it's nicer for other people if you flag your intentions up-front. To me it totally looked like you were ignoring stuff I'd said ~90 posts ago, filling the thread with a load of stuff that's purely mechanical and offers no insight or conversation to the other people in the thread, and boils down to one little post where you say "hey, here are three points where things don't make sense".

One little post saying "I found these three voting mismatches, and I wonder why Space missed the Hydrad one? Maybe they're scum together!" would have been a much better way of getting some engagement going. Flooding the thread with stuff that the conversational people aren't interested in re-reading, verifying or engaging with, in a game that's already stalling pretty badly, doesn't actually seem all that pro-town.

 4 
 on: Today at 05:11:18 am 
Started by LaLight - Last post by DatSwan
Also galz you have admitted that I feel DIFFERENT from the past game where I was scum. The natural conclusion to draw from that is that I'm town, not scum. Yet somehow you just say "well but obvious reasons now you're scum". This is incredibly annoying. I hope I am not this annoying when I'm tunneling someone.

Seems like you already grasp what LCD means....
But what's it an abbreviation for?

Also... you could be "SK, not skum"

 5 
 on: Today at 05:06:53 am 
Started by LaLight - Last post by DatSwan
Also galz you have admitted that I feel DIFFERENT from the past game where I was scum. The natural conclusion to draw from that is that I'm town, not scum. Yet somehow you just say "well but obvious reasons now you're scum". This is incredibly annoying. I hope I am not this annoying when I'm tunneling someone.

Seems like you already grasp what LCD means....
But what's it an abbreviation for?

Lowest Common Denominator

 6 
 on: Today at 05:05:44 am 
Started by Donald X. - Last post by Minotaur
Ducat is S-tier "easier to play in real life".
Note that ShuffleIT now allows you to undo the "play all treasures" button without it asking your opponent for permission. A change specifically made with Ducat in mind.

My mistake is that I tend to start buying before I play my tokens.  A few more games and I'd probably be better.

EDIT:  Oh right, because you might forget to withhold a Copper or two.  Yeah, I screwed that up as well.  Good move, ShuffleIT

 7 
 on: Today at 05:05:30 am 
Started by LaLight - Last post by silverspawn
Also galz you have admitted that I feel DIFFERENT from the past game where I was scum. The natural conclusion to draw from that is that I'm town, not scum. Yet somehow you just say "well but obvious reasons now you're scum". This is incredibly annoying. I hope I am not this annoying when I'm tunneling someone.

Seems like you already grasp what LCD means....
But what's it an abbreviation for?

 8 
 on: Today at 05:04:41 am 
Started by LaLight - Last post by DatSwan
Galz and gkrieg seem entrenched in their silver case.

I've left my "test vote" on Galz because I think he's being lazy about giving a good justification. Gkrieg is trying harder, at least, but I still don't think it's enough to go on.

I'm not saying I think silver is conf!town, but I'm saying I'm not interested in the cases on him today.

yes I know, I wasn't trying to dissolve your previous comments. I was just reading through from start to finish and posting all of it as I went.

Obviously, I meant to quote your previous post - sorry.

 9 
 on: Today at 05:03:37 am 
Started by LaLight - Last post by DatSwan
Galz and gkrieg seem entrenched in their silver case.

I've left my "test vote" on Galz because I think he's being lazy about giving a good justification. Gkrieg is trying harder, at least, but I still don't think it's enough to go on.

I'm not saying I think silver is conf!town, but I'm saying I'm not interested in the cases on him today.

yes I know, I wasn't trying to dissolve your previous comments. I was just reading through from start to finish and posting all of it as I went.

 10 
 on: Today at 05:02:56 am 
Started by Asper - Last post by Asper
Shrine is sound but doesn't excite me. After the first shuffle it is "trash 2 cards, buy a $2 if there is a decent one". In the endgame you can discard green for Coins. The key problem IMO is that discarding for benefit and trashing are to some degree substitutes.

And if there are no decent 2$s? Will you really spend several turns in a row doing nothing? What if you have this and a (terminal) Silver in hand? Are you really going to discard it, only to trash two cards and get to 2$ instead of getting to 5$ (perhaps getting to 5$ AND trashing one card)? Another example, how do you feel about Alt VP boards? Or draw-to-X engines?

Personally I believe the fact they are substitutes makes this card more interesting, not less.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10

Page created in 0.093 seconds with 16 queries.