Hmm.. I don't think PPS is a strong D1 vote, because he is actually quite likely to make scumslips if he lives long enough. And I think I may still even be voting for him :-/
Catching up on more recent posts tells me I need to re-read Galz, but in the meantime I'll go with vote: robz, which is more gut than usual for me.
Scumslips are barely a thing anyway and this is a seriously weak one at that.
I've already admitted it was weak. It's no weaker than iguana math and I'm not ripping into anyone over that.
I am, however, entirely the wrong person to try to tell scumslips barely exist seeing as most glaring examples are my own.
Galzria left himself off his reads list so Vote: Galzria
Why would anybody include themself on their own reads list? Barring edge cases they would just put themself under town, whether they are town or scum.
Of course, you put yourself as town. But not including yourself is psychologically indicative of deflecting attention from yourself. It's the lowest grade scumslip there is.
Oh wait you were serious about this? The idea that leaving yourself off a read list is indicative of a scum alignment is a pretty extraordinary claim and I will need some extraordinary evidence to believe it.
It's every bit as good as the iguana long division method for finding scum D1. As I recall everyone ever has put themselves on the list. To not do so is a willful act but not necessarily a conscious one. I'm placing my bets on this being a scumslip.
I certainly don’t care for the iguana division method.
I know all of these words individually but I have no idea what this means on the whole
Iguana did the early cryptic BS thingy and everyone decided to let that be a basis for picking sides on the "issue" and then trying to base reads of how people responded to it. Yes, I know that is how mafia works but I felt like this particular thingy was not worthwhile of doing the mafia thing around yet it has basically molded the D1 mindset and I'll have no part of it, except, you know, the part I'm having of it right now where I just call it null and void.
Galzria left himself off his reads list so Vote: Galzria
Why would anybody include themself on their own reads list? Barring edge cases they would just put themself under town, whether they are town or scum.
Of course, you put yourself as town. But not including yourself is psychologically indicative of deflecting attention from yourself. It's the lowest grade scumslip there is.
Dryuary - is that like a thing where you convince yourself that you're not an alcoholic so that you can go back to poisoning yourself for the rest of the year without feeling guilty?
People are strange.
On the other hand, this series of posts has been scummier than what DatSwan did.
Vote: Cuzz
Not feeling DatSwan
That is, if you find us scummy for reading iguanas post as townie, fine. But unless you're suggesting that it's scum pushing a town narrative on a scum partner after his opening D1 post, then to find us scummy should mean that Iguana gets moved more into the town column.
Ok, but I think you can find 2 people scummy while also thinking it is unlikely that they are scum partners.
And I typically do a DAMA at some point in the game but had taken January off for Dryuary. So haven't done one. Meta joke.
Teproc posting 0 times is not alignment telling at all. Stuff happens, he should be prodded but no one here can reasonably say he is lurking - As he just doesn’t do that.
I hate the ii discussion because as we go to night 1 all it means is that he will be targeted if he is Town and not if he is skum. Suppose that speaks against potential SK.
Galz mis reading me is skummy based on every game we have ever played together.
It’s February and still no dams posts from TWM so probz skum there.
Oh and i think cuz could be skum
vote: cuzz
I certainly don’t care for the iguana division method.
Galzria left himself off his reads list so Vote: Galzria
I can't imagine that Teproc not posting yet is actually alignment indicative of him.
Which I suppose your latest vote illustrates.I asked a question which Cuzz answered and now everyone is clear on where he stands on the matter.
Yes, just in case there is any ambiguity, I disliked iguana's post but I also dislike having no posts at all.
Do you think Teproc is scummy for not posting or is it more of a prodding kind of vote?
I asked a question which Cuzz answered and now everyone is clear on where he stands on the matter.
That is, if you find us scummy for reading iguanas post as townie, fine. But unless you're suggesting that it's scum pushing a town narrative on a scum partner after his opening D1 post, then to find us scummy should mean that Iguana gets moved more into the town column.
No read:
Everybody else (Space, Teproc, PPS)
Disagree completely. You're looking at it in a vacuum based purely on numbers. I'm looking at it through the lens of a social construct. Players have alignments, and players have actions/reactions. Those actions/reactions are influenced by their alignments, and absolutely tip the scales beyond a purely mathematical outcome.
Good. Now that we've gotten that out of the way, which of these seems most likely:
Scum {any of us} supports Town Iguana
Scum {any of us} supports Scum Iguana
Town {any of us} supports Town Iguana
Town {any of us} supports Scum Iguana
Personally, in a void, I think option 2 is least likely in any given game. That means even if you value the others all equally, Iguana is more likely than not town.
Good. Now that we've gotten that out of the way, which of these seems most likely:
Scum {any of us} supports Town Iguana
Scum {any of us} supports Scum Iguana
Town {any of us} supports Town Iguana
Town {any of us} supports Scum Iguana
Personally, in a void, I think option 2 is least likely in any given game. That means even if you value the others all equally, Iguana is more likely than not town.
Not to mention, you know, this isn't scum iguana.
I mean do you want me to give you thought out and backed-up ideas early D1? I create interactions!
