Ok, so looking back perhaps this case doesn't make as much sense as I thought. But my recollection was that Eevee was saying that he thought Robz was probably town, but at the same time including little tidbits telling other people that basically there was no one else we could lynch D1, and that O was really smart and his case was excellent. Not necessarily saying we should lynch him, but just popped into my head, and I thought I should share.
So this is where it all started. In the end, I had a chance to hammer but rather decided to start the wagon on ashersky, which actually got pretty far.
Then, it is suggested O was killed to give the experienced players more power (so they are mafia). What can I say to this? I think O was just killed because no one now has any clue as to why that was, and also he was (at least in my mind, I said it numerous times yesterday) looking very very towny. My strongest town read from yesterday died, I don't know if that implicates me or not.
People who voted for Robz:
Cuzz, Captain_Frisk, Morgrim7, ashersky
People who didn't:
GeoLib, Eevee, Jorbles
I think it's very damn unlike they were both off the wagon (and I'd like to add I think this is always the case). I could see them both being on the wagon very easily, especially newer mafias might get eager and since lynching Robz yesterday was a thing to do, jumping in on the action wasn't really suspicious at all. I still think Morgrim looks towny though. Also got a slight town read on Frisk.
I think the most likely scenario still is that one was off and one was on, but I'm not sure.
You say you have been relying on more active players for information. I know I have answered a lot of questions and generally tried to provide as much info as possible, has any of that been bad this far? Am I being called out for being too helpful and not participating on a townie lynch now?
Jorbles said he'd hammer, so he sort of (would have) participated in a townie lynch too. Ashersky and Cuzz are still scummy for their bandwagoning-behavior I think. GeoLib is very agreeing, pacifistic and nice so it's hard to suspect him, but it's not like he is obvtown at all, could very well just be a cautious mafia.
First vote on me was to raise discussion, 2nd was morgrim being morgrim and joining every possible wagon, no one else has voted. Frisk did talk about "ending the day", implying he thinks we are close to the lynch which is interesting I think (yes he said he doesn't want to do it, but he planted the possibility in our minds now).
If you lynch a townie (like me) and someone dies at night, there'll be two mafias and three townies alive tomorrow. Is the case on me compelling enough to risk that? How many of you think today's lynch target has been found?
If you have any specific questions, fire away! I don't really know how to defend myself.