Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Eevee

Filter to certain boards:

Pages: 1 ... 535 536 [537] 538 539 ... 594
13401
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia X - The Death of Donald X. Night 1
« on: August 28, 2012, 09:49:26 am »
oh it wasnt l-1, its fine then.

Its fine-ish.  Yes - scum could quick hammer 3-4, but its unlikely.

This assumes both votes on Eevee now are from town.  I don't think we can make that assumption safely.
Quickhammering and completely killing the discussion now would look so ridiculously scummy it's not really a consideration. Just no one do it if you are town, and we are good. Of course I would prefer either of them unvoting seeing how I'm town, but it is what it is. Ashersky, what do you think about the case on me? If I'm not your biggest suspect, who is?

13402
The "aw that sucks!" is not a scum tell, especially on anyone as experienced as robz. Come on now!

13403
The point is you're saying basically: "I was really suspicious...town should have wanted to kill me.  O defended me, theorel accused me therefore: O is town"  Doesn't that seem a little contradictory to you?
The FoS on you was clearly lighter than the town read on O. Some people thought I was suspicious, so for scum O it would have been very easy to just join them and push the wagon to a lynch. It would have been the "normal" thing to do, behavior that doesn't raise questions. Instead he chose to defend me when no one else didn't, I think it's more likely he is town with a good read than scum trying to clear himself through me. Also a thing to note: we all know town O isn't scared of taking a read and sticking with it. I got the impression that's what he did with me. Now, could scum O be devious enough to do it just to get me say this? Maybe, I certainly am gullible enough to do it. But am I the correct target still, am I credible enough? I don't know, but going too far down that road feels like overthinking a simple thing. In the end, O wanted to save my life when he didn't really need to at all, and I'm town. For that, O reads towny to me.

13404
Theorel, I passed the theory question back to yuma because I didn't feel he answered his own question which didn't feel right to me (also knew he was online at the time).

I don't think WIFOM'ing over who expected what to be in the setup is going to be useful, unless you feel you are super good at leveling wars.

I stand by my assessment of O and Galzria. Isn't being wagoned informational like I said? Don't you realize how much info you have on me now, I've stated strong town reads on two players and some scum reads too. Almost any flip is going to implicate me one way or another!

I'm sad and surprised no one else sees the yuma case.

13405
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia X - The Death of Donald X. Night 1
« on: August 28, 2012, 09:02:54 am »
Ok, so looking back perhaps this case doesn't make as much sense as I thought. But my recollection was that Eevee was saying that he thought Robz was probably town, but at the same time including little tidbits telling other people that basically there was no one else we could lynch D1, and that O was really smart and his case was excellent. Not necessarily saying we should lynch him, but just popped into my head, and I thought I should share.
So this is where it all started. In the end, I had a chance to hammer but rather decided to start the wagon on ashersky, which actually got pretty far.

Then, it is suggested O was killed to give the experienced players more power (so they are mafia). What can I say to this? I think O was just killed because no one now has any clue as to why that was, and also he was (at least in my mind, I said it numerous times yesterday) looking very very towny. My strongest town read from yesterday died, I don't know if that implicates me or not.

People who voted for Robz:
Cuzz, Captain_Frisk, Morgrim7, ashersky

People who didn't:
GeoLib, Eevee, Jorbles


I think it's very damn unlike they were both off the wagon (and I'd like to add I think this is always the case). I could see them both being on the wagon very easily, especially newer mafias might get eager and since lynching Robz yesterday was a thing to do, jumping in on the action wasn't really suspicious at all. I still think Morgrim looks towny though. Also got a slight town read on Frisk.
I think the most likely scenario still is that one was off and one was on, but I'm not sure.

You say you have been relying on more active players for information. I know I have answered a lot of questions and generally tried to provide as much info as possible, has any of that been bad this far? Am I being called out for being too helpful and not participating on a townie lynch now?

Jorbles said he'd hammer, so he sort of (would have) participated in a townie lynch too. Ashersky and Cuzz are still scummy for their bandwagoning-behavior I think. GeoLib is very agreeing, pacifistic and nice so it's hard to suspect him, but it's not like he is obvtown at all, could very well just be a cautious mafia.

First vote on me was to raise discussion, 2nd was morgrim being morgrim and joining every possible wagon, no one else has voted. Frisk did talk about "ending the day", implying he thinks we are close to the lynch which is interesting I think (yes he said he doesn't want to do it, but he planted the possibility in our minds now).

If you lynch a townie (like me) and someone dies at night, there'll be two mafias and three townies alive tomorrow. Is the case on me compelling enough to risk that? How many of you think today's lynch target has been found?

If you have any specific questions, fire away! I don't really know how to defend myself.

13406
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia X - The Death of Donald X. Night 1
« on: August 28, 2012, 08:42:14 am »
oh it wasnt l-1, its fine then.

Its fine-ish.  Yes - scum could quick hammer 3-4, but its unlikely.  My feeling is that while I do have pokemon suspicion, its certainly not time to end the day.  Let's talk about our feelings people.

I mean wtf, the case against me is flimsy at best, and the day has gone on for like two days, no it is not time to end the day yet. I'll reread everything and answer the best I can, although I have a feeling the case is so feeling-based and subjective it's going to be hard.

13407
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia X - The Death of Donald X. Night 1
« on: August 28, 2012, 08:24:05 am »
oh it wasnt l-1, its fine then.

13408
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia X - The Death of Donald X. Night 1
« on: August 28, 2012, 08:20:17 am »
on phone cant post but if someone hammers, lynch him tomorrow no matter what.

13409
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia X - The Death of Donald X. Night 1
« on: August 28, 2012, 08:19:16 am »
Someone unvote quick. I havent even defended myself wtf!!

13410
Btw, one thing I did well in this game was not getting lynched. Townies wanted me dead almost every day, but in the end we always lynched scum instead so hurray! I mean I should play less scummy and not be on the top of our freaking cop's lynch list even after he investigated me, but other than that..

13411
What you actually did was lynch someone you suspected of being mafia and not the guy who was obviously lying. There was no proof I was mafia, there was however proof that jo was lying badly. And in an anti-town way. Not really sure why you lynched me instead of him.
Lynch mafia not scum
Lynch lekkit not joth.

13412
Lynching the mafia instead of the serial killer was indeed so stupid of us, no wonder town lost!

 :)

13413
And to be honest, I don't get why I was lynched. There was an exposed liar, seriously, where would the IW have gone if I didn't have it? I wouldn't be able to do all the craziness that jo was able to do with the trash pile, and I guess I would've been lynched the day after that. But I was actually telling the truth the whole day when it came to jo. It's a pity you couldn't see that.
We DID see that!! Too bad Jot was unlynchable so it didn't help us.

13414
Was I supposed to realize this? It's not like I want to be the guy who always screws over his own team THIS majorly.

Oh well, in before people start pre-emptively lynching me in day 1 to avoid having me alive later.

13415
I'd say the game--which really was a lot of fun, especially last few days--had to have been unbalanced in favor of scum. We were a scum-lynching factory here at the end, and we still lost! And we had the right person to kill for like 9 straight days!

The scum felt it was very much against them, actually!  I think it was fairly well balanced but super, super swingy.
Well curses might have had it rough, but what about that joth dude?

13416
I'd say the game--which really was a lot of fun, especially last few days--had to have been unbalanced in favor of scum. We were a scum-lynching factory here at the end, and we still lost! And we had the right person to kill for like 9 straight days!
We even had the unnightkillable Eevee alive until the end, which was utterly useless ofc.

13417
eh.

so, eevee can't redirect jo's night kill back at him?

Robz didn't full claim his powers.  He also had a double vote.  Eevee was guaranteed lynch.

I was keeping that a secret in case I needed to override everybody still in the game, or to beat Jo in a head-to-head.

Also, I was supposed to get 5 VP if I saved the guy I gave 2 VP to from being killed. So Eevee, if you directed it all to me, you ruined everything.
I did (the night you died), but what was I supposed to do?

Doesn't matter actually. There's nothing we can do when the last scum is unkillable for two straight days, and then gets my double vote.
I mean yeah, here I was thinking I for once did not fuq up the end game for my faction completely. Oh well.

13418
eh.

so, eevee can't redirect jo's night kill back at him?

Robz didn't full claim his powers.  He also had a double vote.  Eevee was guaranteed lynch.

I was keeping that a secret in case I needed to override everybody still in the game, or to beat Jo in a head-to-head.

Also, I was supposed to get 5 VP if I saved the guy I gave 2 VP to from being killed. So Eevee, if you directed it all to me, you ruined everything.
I did (the night you died), but what was I supposed to do?

13419
Can you link me to  the first post in the curse QT? Somehow it doesnt have the "all" button and clicking "next 25" 50 times on a slow internet when half the time the number turns into a skype phone number and my computer tries to call, it doesnt sound fun.

And uh what an anti-climax for a fun game, damnit. :( I thought we had jot!

13420
I dont understand! Maybe the QT will shed some light on what just happened.

13421
I had a feeling my universe would appear scummy.

13422
I'm from the Wizard of Oz. And before anyone asks, no I'm not the gal on isotropics witch avatar.

Are you a Wheeler?
Nope, but man that was weird.

13423
I'm glad for the extended twilight, because without it I would have gotten like 0 posts in today because someone decided to quickhammer. Yeah. >________>

Are you Cayvie's scumbuddy?
I'm quite certain I'm not. Like really sure!

timchen sure?
Oh please. I'm even more certain than timchen thought he was!

13424
Oh and if I get to graverob a person (what a weird thing to say), who shall I revive? Most likely I'll just get nothing again, but I'm a dreamer and won't give up on the hope of getting something useful one of these days.

13425
I'm glad for the extended twilight, because without it I would have gotten like 0 posts in today because someone decided to quickhammer. Yeah. >________>

Are you Cayvie's scumbuddy?
I'm quite certain I'm not. Like really sure!

Pages: 1 ... 535 536 [537] 538 539 ... 594

Page created in 0.181 seconds with 18 queries.