901
Let's Discuss ... / Re: let's discuss guilds cards: doctor
« on: January 12, 2017, 12:13:48 pm »
Good counter to Sea Hag.
I get a newborn donkey during harvest as well.Newborn foal added.
Strategist
Type: Action
Cost: $5 ?
Play any number of Action cards from your hand in any order, then put your hand on top of your deck in any order.
All the $4 splitters should be roughly at the same rank, really.Now this is something about $4 Villages I do agree with Awaclus on. The special abilities for $4 Villages tend to be:
man, you really want to give a tl;drtl;dr added.
J
starts with 7 Coppers
and 3 Estates
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 4 Coppers
and an Estate
.
c
starts with 7 Coppers
and 3 Estates
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 3 Coppers
and 2 Estates
.
Turn 1 - Jack Rudd
J
plays 4 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Smithy
.
J
draws 3 Coppers
and 2 Estates
.
Turn 1 - counterspell4u
c
plays 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Merchant
.
c
draws 4 Coppers
and an Estate
.
Turn 2 - Jack Rudd
J
plays 3 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Silver
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, a Silver
, an Estate
and a Smithy
.
Turn 2 - counterspell4u
c
plays 4 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Smithy
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 4 Coppers
and an Estate
.
Turn 3 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws a Copper
and 2 Estates
.
J
plays a Silver
and 3 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Market
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 4 Coppers
and a Silver
.
Turn 3 - counterspell4u
c
plays 4 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Throne Room
.
c
draws 2 Coppers
, an Estate
, a Merchant
and a Smithy
.
Turn 4 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Silver
and 4 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Goons
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
and 3 Estates
.
Turn 4 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Merchant
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 2 Coppers
and an Estate
.
c
plays 4 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Silver
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, an Estate
and a Throne Room
.
Turn 5 - Jack Rudd
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, an Estate
, a Market
and a Smithy
.
Turn 5 - counterspell4u
c
plays 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Silver
.
c
draws 4 Coppers
and an Estate
.
Turn 6 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Silver
and a Goons
.
J
plays a Silver
and 4 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Merchant
and a Village
.
J
draws 3 Coppers
and 2 Estates
.
Turn 6 - counterspell4u
c
plays 4 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Smithy
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws a Silver
, 2 Estates
, a Merchant
and a Smithy
.
Turn 7 - Jack Rudd
J
plays 3 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Village
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 4 Coppers
and a Village
.
Turn 7 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Merchant
.
c
draws a Smithy
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws 3 Coppers
.
c
plays a Silver
and 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Goons
.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, a Silver
and a Throne Room
.
Turn 8 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays 4 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Smithy
.
J
draws 3 Coppers
, a Smithy
and a Goons
.
Turn 8 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Silver
and 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Market
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws a Copper
, a Silver
, an Estate
, a Market
and a Merchant
.
Turn 9 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards a Copper
and an Estate
.
J
plays 3 Coppers
.
J
buys a Market
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Market
.
J
draws a Silver
, 2 Estates
, a Market
and a Merchant
.
Turn 9 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Merchant
.
c
draws a Smithy
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws 2 Coppers
and a Goons
.
c
plays a Silver
and 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains 2 Villages
.
c
draws 2 Coppers
, 2 Estates
and a Smithy
.
Turn 10 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Market
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Silver
and a Copper
.
J
buys and gains a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Market
, 2 Smithies
and a Goons
.
Turn 10 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws a Copper
, a Silver
and a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Silver
and 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Market
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws a Copper
, 2 Smithies
and 2 Villages
.
Turn 11 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards a Copper
and a Smithy
.
J
plays 2 Coppers
.
J
buys a Village
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Village
.
J
draws 4 Coppers
and a Village
.
Turn 11 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Market
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws 2 Coppers
and a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays a Market
again.
c
draws a Silver
.
c
plays a Silver
and 2 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Goons
.
c
draws a Copper
, a Silver
, a Market
, a Merchant
and a Goons
.
Turn 12 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws a Smithy
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Market
and a Smithy
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
and a Silver
.
J
plays a Silver
and 7 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Council Room
and a Village
.
J
draws an Estate
, a Market
, a Merchant
and 2 Villages
.
Turn 12 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Merchant
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards an Estate
and a Merchant
.
c
plays a Silver
and 2 Coppers
.
c
buys a Village
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Village
.
c
buys a Bandit
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Bandit
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 2 Coppers
, 2 Estates
and a Village
.
Turn 13 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Goons
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards 2 Estates
.
J
plays a Copper
.
J
buys a Council Room
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Council Room
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, a Silver
, a Council Room
and a Market
.
Turn 13 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays 3 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Village
.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, a Silver
and a Market
.
Turn 14 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, a Smithy
and a Village
.
c
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Silver
and 5 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains 2 Villages
.
J
draws a Copper
, an Estate
, a Merchant
, a Smithy
and a Village
.
Turn 14 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Market
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws a Smithy
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws a Silver
, a Village
and a Goons
.
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards a Copper
and an Estate
.
c
plays 2 Silvers
and 4 Coppers
.
c
buys a Throne Room
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Throne Room
.
c
buys a Province
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Province
.
c
draws a Copper
, a Bandit
, a Merchant
, a Throne Room
and a Goons
.
Turn 15 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws a Copper
, a Silver
and an Estate
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Silver
and 2 Coppers
.
J
buys and gains a Throne Room
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, an Estate
, a Village
and a Goons
.
Turn 15 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Merchant
.
c
draws a Smithy
.
c
plays a Merchant
again.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws 2 Coppers
and a Smithy
.
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards a Copper
and an Estate
.
c
plays 4 Coppers
.
c
buys a Goons
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Goons
.
c
draws 4 Coppers
and a Village
.
Turn 16 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards 2 Coppers
.
J
plays 2 Coppers
.
J
buys a Throne Room
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Throne Room
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Smithy
and 3 Villages
.
Turn 16 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays 2 Coppers
.
c
draws an Estate
, a Market
, 2 Villages
and a Goons
.
Turn 17 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Council Room
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Council Room
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 2 Estates
, a Smithy
and a Goons
.
c
draws a Province
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, a Silver
and a Village
.
c
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Merchant
and a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
and a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
plays a Merchant
again.
J
plays a Throne Room
again.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards an Estate
, a Province
, a Market
and a Village
.
J
plays a Goons
again.
J
plays a Silver
and 7 Coppers
.
J
buys a Goons
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Goons
.
J
buys a Throne Room
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Throne Room
.
J
buys a Throne Room
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Throne Room
.
J
buys a Throne Room
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Throne Room
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws a Market
, a Merchant
, a Throne Room
, a Village
and a Goons
.
Turn 17 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards a Market
and a Merchant
.
c
plays a Goons
again.
c
buys a Gardens
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Gardens
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 2 Silvers
, an Estate
, a Market
and a Village
.
Turn 18 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards an Estate
and a Market
.
J
plays a Goons
again.
J
plays a Copper
.
J
buys a Council Room
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Council Room
.
J
draws 2 Coppers
, a Market
, a Throne Room
and a Village
.
Turn 18 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws an Estate
.
c
plays 2 Silvers
.
c
buys and gains a Gardens
.
c
draws 2 Coppers
, a Bandit
and 2 Villages
.
Turn 19 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Council Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Smithy
, a Throne Room
and a Village
.
c
draws a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Council Room
again.
J
draws a Copper
, an Estate
, a Throne Room
and a Village
.
c
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
draws a Copper
, an Estate
and a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Smithy
again.
J
draws an Estate
, a Council Room
and a Smithy
.
J
plays a Throne Room
again.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Silver
, a Market
and a Goons
.
c
draws a Goons
.
J
plays a Council Room
again.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws a Copper
, a Throne Room
and 2 Villages
.
c
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Throne Room
again.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Market
again.
J
draws a Merchant
.
J
plays a Throne Room
again.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Goons
.
J
plays a Market
again.
J
draws a Council Room
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
plays a Smithy
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
c
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards 4 Coppers
, a Bandit
, a Market
and a Village
.
J
plays a Goons
.
J
plays a Silver
and 7 Coppers
.
J
buys a Market
.
J
gets 2 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Market
.
J
buys a Market
.
J
gets 2 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Market
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 2 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 2 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 2 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws 2 Merchants
, a Smithy
, a Village
and a Goons
.
Turn 19 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards 2 Merchants
.
c
plays a Goons
again.
c
buys a Gardens
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Gardens
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, a Smithy
and a Throne Room
.
Turn 20 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Council Room
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
draws a Silver
, an Estate
, a Council Room
and a Merchant
.
c
draws a Merchant
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards 3 Coppers
.
J
plays a Silver
and a Copper
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Council Room
, a Smithy
, a Throne Room
and a Goons
.
Turn 20 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Throne Room
.
c
plays a Merchant
.
c
draws a Province
.
c
plays a Merchant
again.
c
draws a Goons
.
c
plays a Smithy
.
c
draws an Estate
, a Gardens
and a Village
.
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards a Council Room
and a Smithy
.
c
plays a Copper
.
c
buys a Merchant
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Merchant
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
shuffles their deck.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, a Smithy
and a Goons
.
Turn 21 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards a Copper
and a Smithy
.
J
plays a Goons
again.
J
plays a Copper
.
J
buys a Market
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Market
.
J
draws an Estate
, a Market
and 3 Villages
.
Turn 21 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Goons
.
J
discards an Estate
and a Market
.
c
plays 2 Coppers
.
c
buys a Gardens
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Gardens
.
c
buys a Copper
.
c
gets 1 VP from Goons.
c
gains a Copper
.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, a Market
and a Village
.
Turn 22 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
again.
J
draws a Copper
, 3 Markets
and a Throne Room
.
Turn 22 - counterspell4u
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Bandit
.
c
plays a Market
.
c
draws a Village
.
c
plays a Village
.
c
draws a Copper
.
c
plays a Bandit
.
c
gains a Gold
.
J
reveals a Copper
and an Estate
.
J
discards a Copper
and an Estate
.
c
plays 4 Coppers
.
c
buys and gains a Copper
and a Gardens
.
c
draws 3 Coppers
, an Estate
and a Village
.
Turn 23 - Jack Rudd
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Market
again.
J
draws a Merchant
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Copper
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
draws a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
shuffles their deck.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Market
again.
J
draws a Village
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Council Room
.
J
plays a Council Room
.
J
draws a Copper
, a Merchant
and 2 Villages
.
c
draws a Merchant
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Village
.
J
draws a Merchant
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
draws a Market
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Market
.
J
draws a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Market
again.
J
draws a Goons
.
J
plays a Throne Room
.
J
plays a Merchant
.
J
draws a Silver
.
J
plays a Merchant
again.
J
draws an Estate
.
J
plays a Goons
.
c
discards 2 Coppers
and an Estate
.
J
plays a Silver
and 4 Coppers
.
J
buys a Gardens
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Gardens
.
J
buys a Gardens
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Gardens
.
J
buys a Gardens
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Gardens
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
buys a Merchant
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Merchant
.
J
buys a Copper
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Copper
.
J
buys a Copper
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Copper
.
J
buys a Copper
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Copper
.
J
buys a Copper
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Copper
.
J
buys a Copper
.
J
gets 1 VP from Goons.
J
gains a Copper
.
J
draws 2 Markets
, 2 Merchants
and a Goons
.
As many of your comboes include cards played after Artificer, I would think that Villages are something to list as a combo card.Particularly Border Village and University, for Artificer-gaining reasons.
It might. If I were you, I'd test it out in Goons games to see how it plays there.Probably not a good card; if it's worth buying, everyone will buy it en masse and the Province pile will empty quickly as people play cantrips. (See innumerable discussions about why Rebuild is annoying; same dynamic.)
You're probably right that putting a cantrip on it is a bad idea. Would the 2nd half of the card be interesting enough though?