51
Mafia Game Threads / Re: M114: Wheel of Time II - Day 2
« on: March 21, 2018, 08:45:01 am »
Okay, I think I need a reads list to keep track of everybody...
Robz: absent much of day 1. Comes back in support of the mcmc-lynch with I feel like good reasoning, but of course we now know that was a bad lynch. After a fresh read, often town can come in with a new direction, scum would probably feel good about pushing the leading wagon. Still, his arguments and reactions sound townier. I'm going to lean town here, if that's right, it's unfortunate that he didn't come in with a new direction yesterday, but it is what it is.
Joseph: early mass-claim push, and then he kind of just laid low until later in the day where he kind of avoided talking about mcmc. Says he's going to re-read "especially mcmc", but ends up voting schadd without explicit reasoning. Which, while I don't know that it's particularly scummy, it doesn't help get anyone off of mcmc either. This could easily be scum trying to avoid a known bad-lynch, while trying not to derail it. I'm leaning a little scummy here.
schadd: He has that argument with ww, which now known-town mcmc thought included scum. After TWM notes that only mcmc has gotten above 2 votes, and pushes him for inactivity...he makes a comment about galz, and joins mcmc? (@schadd: what did you mean by "i wanted to see if/how galz would leave ww"?) Also he joins mcmc after TWM points out that it's scummy that he stayed off. Highest scum-read so far.
SpaceAnemone: joins the mcmc wagon early and sticks there. She does try to prod people to give more info, offers reads, and generally seems to do pro-town work. I'm reading town here.
TWM: was on mcmc before it was cool. Then had an argument with galz. Then switched back to mcmc, until he unvoted later to try to make other things happen (like schadd). He reads town to me for how this went down, even though it's something scum might like to do to distance themselves from a bad lynch. I guess I might be influenced by my scum-read of schadd, but I'm strongly reading him as town.
Theorel: I'm town, wee
Galzria: He agrees with mcmc, then agrees with schadd, then fights with TWM, over asking mcmc to provide examples, then agrees with robz, twice. He seems to be drawing his opinions from other players rather than providing his own...might be a higher scum-read than schadd.
Witherweaver: Argument with schadd, where he doesn't vote him. Ends up on mcmc, and sticks there while trying to pull arguments out of others. Pulled a good bit of heat over the day, but it never went anywhere...still, I'm going to tentatively lean town here.
pps: he voted for me early with no reason, and just stuck to it. When providing an argument, it was "it's all really based on his initial posts", which doesn't really explain what he found scummy...then he defends it being forced because it's day1. And then he hammered. While the hammer is apparently NAI for pps, the rest reads scummy to me. A lot like Joseph, he looked like he was trying to go somewhere other than pps, but didn't really push to make it happen.
I'm going to go ahead with vote: Galzria, though I could be persuaded to help with schadd.
Robz: absent much of day 1. Comes back in support of the mcmc-lynch with I feel like good reasoning, but of course we now know that was a bad lynch. After a fresh read, often town can come in with a new direction, scum would probably feel good about pushing the leading wagon. Still, his arguments and reactions sound townier. I'm going to lean town here, if that's right, it's unfortunate that he didn't come in with a new direction yesterday, but it is what it is.
Joseph: early mass-claim push, and then he kind of just laid low until later in the day where he kind of avoided talking about mcmc. Says he's going to re-read "especially mcmc", but ends up voting schadd without explicit reasoning. Which, while I don't know that it's particularly scummy, it doesn't help get anyone off of mcmc either. This could easily be scum trying to avoid a known bad-lynch, while trying not to derail it. I'm leaning a little scummy here.
schadd: He has that argument with ww, which now known-town mcmc thought included scum. After TWM notes that only mcmc has gotten above 2 votes, and pushes him for inactivity...he makes a comment about galz, and joins mcmc? (@schadd: what did you mean by "i wanted to see if/how galz would leave ww"?) Also he joins mcmc after TWM points out that it's scummy that he stayed off. Highest scum-read so far.
SpaceAnemone: joins the mcmc wagon early and sticks there. She does try to prod people to give more info, offers reads, and generally seems to do pro-town work. I'm reading town here.
TWM: was on mcmc before it was cool. Then had an argument with galz. Then switched back to mcmc, until he unvoted later to try to make other things happen (like schadd). He reads town to me for how this went down, even though it's something scum might like to do to distance themselves from a bad lynch. I guess I might be influenced by my scum-read of schadd, but I'm strongly reading him as town.
Theorel: I'm town, wee
Galzria: He agrees with mcmc, then agrees with schadd, then fights with TWM, over asking mcmc to provide examples, then agrees with robz, twice. He seems to be drawing his opinions from other players rather than providing his own...might be a higher scum-read than schadd.
Witherweaver: Argument with schadd, where he doesn't vote him. Ends up on mcmc, and sticks there while trying to pull arguments out of others. Pulled a good bit of heat over the day, but it never went anywhere...still, I'm going to tentatively lean town here.
pps: he voted for me early with no reason, and just stuck to it. When providing an argument, it was "it's all really based on his initial posts", which doesn't really explain what he found scummy...then he defends it being forced because it's day1. And then he hammered. While the hammer is apparently NAI for pps, the rest reads scummy to me. A lot like Joseph, he looked like he was trying to go somewhere other than pps, but didn't really push to make it happen.
I'm going to go ahead with vote: Galzria, though I could be persuaded to help with schadd.
