1
Forum Games / Re: Mafia Championship Season 11 Invite
« on: April 22, 2024, 07:51:03 am »
I have signed up for it. Wish me luck!
What are your preferences regarding semi-blitz/full-blitz/long?
Analyse | Deter | All-round | Protect | Track | 6lock |
Town Odd Night Tracker Town Even Night Vanilla Cop Town 2-shot Doctor 9x Vanilla Town Mafia 2-shot Watcher Mafia Roleblocker Mafia Goon | Town Jack of All Trades Town 2-shot Roleblocker Town Odd Night Doctor 9x Vanilla Town Mafia Roleblocker Mafia Jack of All Trades Mafia Goon | Town Jack of All Trades Town Even Night Vanilla Cop 10x Vanilla Town Mafia Jack of All Trades 2x Mafia Goon | Town Odd Night Doctor Town Even Night Jailkeeper 10x Vanilla Town Mafia 1-shot Jailkeeper 2x Mafia Goon | Town Odd Night Tracker Town 2-shot Doctor 10x Vanilla Town Mafia 1-shot Tracker 2x Mafia Goon | Town 2-shot Roleblocker Town Even Night Jailkeeper 10x Vanilla Town Mafia 1-shot Roleblocker 2x Mafia Goon |
This was the last time scola gets to use the "I'm always awkward Day 1" excuse!
What I do do as scum is pushing cases on townies only exactly the right amount to avoid them actually getting exiled, which lets me continue tunneling the same people the next day, which I haven't done here — I was indeed an instrumental part of both town exiles and I'm pretty sure both of them were popular enough to have supporters off-wagon.
I still don't have a good read on anyone this game. Those who seem the most scummy to me are ones I almost always find scummy, often just based on their posting style. But since it looks like there's no chance of me surviving, I might as well offer what final thoughts I have, to see if they may be of any help tomorrow to try and find at least 1 scum this game.
Right now, I feel like scum is one of MiX and Awaclus, then one of gk and joth. I don't have anything concrete to back up this guess... it's just a gut feel.
Scum-to-chum list:
Awaclus
MiX
joth
gk
scola
WCD
I really don't think there's anything the last two have done that is overly townie. They just haven't done as much that I see as scummy.
MiX, why Scola over Math? I’m ready to vote for Math, but I want to make sure I’m not missing anything.
Because I think they're both scum. Honestly it doesn't matter for me, I just think that if scola flips scum then mathdude's more likely to be scum than the other way around, so voting scola first technically helps flip both.
How realistic do you think it is we'll exile someone other than math tomorrow if scola flips town?
MiX, why Scola over Math? I’m ready to vote for Math, but I want to make sure I’m not missing anything.
How about we stop thinking about how Swowl never makes everything clear and start thinking in the correct world...
Mathdude. A readlist? Please? Anything.
As I said, it makes more sense to wait until closer to the deadline. Can you give me an argument otherwise?Theory is cool how about you make a scum to chum list so we can look at it after we exile you.
My list alone will probably be pretty useless. I admit I have very weak reads this game. On top of that, I know I will have a slightly biased scum-read towards those who target me the most (I always do).
I assume it would be better to do this closer to the deadline, rather than this early in the day. Let's let gk and joth actually contribute to this day - otherwise their places in the list will be quite meaningless (if they were even put in the list). But if I am up for exile, I trust someone would post an intent-to-hammer, and give time for me to post such a list, rather than a quick-hammer (which would be very scummy).
Did you read that and ignore it? Do you just post without reading responses directly to your posts/requests?
Well, we'll have to agree to disagree.
No we don't, I'm objectively correct and you're objectively wrong. If scum can't correctly estimate how the info will make others act in the future, there is no reason to expect our estimation to be correct either, since we're making it with less info than scum is making theirs with.
I haven't had time for a reread and may not.
Town is small enough now that a towncore approach appeals.
Right now I'm strongly townreading MiX and Didds. Awaclus too, though I'm a bit more wary there. That leaves scum somewhere in scola, gkrieg, or mathdude. I definitely get the sense that gkrieg and mathdude are both people who've had multiple wagons on them that didn't stick, which normally would be scummy, but given the nature of this game it may not be (since there was effectively 1 scum the first couple days).
I think it's a little odd that the day opening post didn't actual identify the night's victim. Can we get confirmation that LaLight was killed by scum rather than modkilled?
So you think scum no-killed? Why would they do that?
The LaLight kill (if indeed it is such) sort of points to scum being one person who's had a lot of suspicion on them and one who's had very little.
Because if scum is like gkrieg-math, why not kill MiX or Didds or Awa, who all seem to be kind of aligned in that direction? But if the scum is, say, Awaclus-gkreig, then better to keep the strong town allies in play.
But even if Awaclus is scum, which I seem to be talking myself around to, I still would rather get the partner today, on the basis that it seems easier to get the consensus, especially because I 100% believe Awaclus will bus without a second thought.
Does scum!Awaclus vote his partner right out of the gate in a game where his partner only needs 4 votes to be exiled? Feels a bit too gutsy.