Are you claiming something? I honestly can't parse the first sentence.
Yes.
As I'm at L-1 I feel I should say that, as I understand it, we townfolk shouldn't have anything to worry about the mafia preventing a town role from working. Which should make it clear what I am actually saying, and why lynching me is unwise.
I also disagree with everything mcmc is saying. phyphor is the player that I want to lynch the least second to myself
What are the lynch pools looking like?
I am going to continue making scumreads based on how much energy people expend defending themselves vs. scumhunting. Since there are only two scum, self-preservation is significantly more important for scum than town at this point and we should exploit that difference.
I don't think that's a good standard. Generally, people defending themselves is a good thing. We shouldn't discourage that.
vote: poorly written Harry Potter Villain
vote: father-brother-continent
Very slow start here. How about this: everyone vote for someone in their next post
vote: muenstercheese
For the record, my vote was entirely for pressure. Now is the first time that I think I have some kind of read, and it's a town read on WCD. Don't particularly want to explain why.
back to vote: uncle
Partially to save my own back, but also because setting up three of us to share the votes (by switching to Faust) means we are unlikely to lynch on Day 1.
In general we want to lynch every day, but whilst Day 1 is a day with little information which makes it hard to do a good lynching if we don't lynch anyone we run the risk of having the Mafia take out the good townies (be it because they're good at Mafia or have had to role-claim to save their skin).
Question for you, hypercube: How does it make you feel that two of your scumreads, silver and phyphor, are voting for the third, Eddie?
For the record, my vote was entirely for pressure. Now is the first time that I think I have some kind of read, and it's a town read on WCD. Don't particularly want to explain why.
back to vote: uncle
Well, there is a little more to go on by now, I would say. Care to share any reads?
Oh, on that note. May I ask new players to get a signature? Doesn't have to be anything fancy, just something that makes it possible to search especially for your posts when rereading.
"Appearing to be helpful without actually being helpful" (proposed by both Uncle and Simon) seems a useful criteria, and by that one Hypercube is aces. Lots of one-line commentary that revealed little, and jumping on the Uncle wagon, but remarking on the kindness of being amenable but not wanting to but him on L-1, seems an attempt to bolster his town-cred without actually having to do anything. My current most scummy.
Simon seems to be trying to get things going and stirring things up. Other than his squeamishness about me, its been rather erratic, but when he draws down on Hypercube, the response was along the lines well, there hasn't been much to say and I don't want to chatter needlessly. Faust saying that Simon doesn't really count as a newb is interesting, too. Still, it doesn't really feel like he is working with anyone so townish. But I am more on the fence about him than other towns.
alina and Europe voting for faust without a stated reason is somewhat suspicious to me, explanation please?
I mean, I felt I was fairly transparent, about my reasoning, you can disagree with the reasoning as Jester does, but the reasoning still exists. I am prodding a prodded.
The snarky side of myself wants to throw a vote at you now with no explaination given just for fun, but I have just given the explaination (“for fun”) so I guess it’s too late. Bummer.
Apologies for not posting yesterday, although I disagree with Simon's characterization of me as "not playing."
Sorry, was just refering to the prodding-business. Please feel free to make me notice you further.
Actually, a reread of you makes me fairly suspicious of you. Short posts, no strong stances really. I know it's hard to get into a game, but you give off a feeling that you don't really want anything to happen. You criticised me for jokingly trying to incite an omgus- argument and silver for his voting proposal. A stagnate game is good for scum, I think you just might be the scum I assumed would be found among you and muenstercheese.
So.. are you?
The theory of probability says that every time you need to make an opinion about who is a scum, you should pick different person from previous time. So I'll make a try
vote: faust
Very slow start here. How about this: everyone vote for someone in their next postCan you explain how your voting will help us get the game started?
vote: muenstercheese
vote: father-brother-continent
But in the spirit of Lynch All Lurkers
Vote:muenstercheese for being all excited and now suspiciously absent
Vote: alinatolm
Either he is killing a talker, or he is killing someone he thinks is intelligent enough to be a threat, you decide. Ima just vote for the guy to see what happens.
ooooh, Omgus! Fight, Fight, Fight!!
translucent vote: Simon for formenting conflict.
Asch, conflict is good, irregardless if it's fabricated, silly or whatever. What is fishy is to try to dial down a potential subject of conversation. Town wants to have many interactions D1 a so we can go back later days and study them when we have more revealed information.
PPE
So c'mone, be a pro-town player and go hunt down scum!silver, attaboy!
