SA sheeps, no explanation.
I gave my reason in a response to silver three posts later, so it's hardly an unexplained vote!
Robz agrees with my post about the disadvantages of lynching teamlyle
I feel like significant parts of Eevee's big post here can be read as buddying Robz!
Then there was this:
We can also probably say that if Robz is scum, J Reggie can't be, because that'd be just suicidal bussing for little reason, right? (J Reggie has just the one Robz vote)
plus
SA asks again if there is anyone on to start a new wagon. Not sure how I feel about this, as I really don't see any reason in silver's posts to change one's mind about him.
[/quote]
So Robz gets a town-vote from you for moving his vote in the run-up to a deadline, but I get suspicion for even talking about moving my own vote?
And no, silver hadn't said anything in the interim, but I'd lapsed a bit behind in my detailed reading of the game, as evidenced by the fact that I didn't find the vote-count mistake till long after it had happened, when I actually got long enough to sit and read through things properly.
I feel from your post that you're kind of skewing your narrative to fit a pre-existing conclusion, which I think deserves some scumpoints.
LaLight's jumping back and forth and making erratic statements about it seemed the most opportunistic to me, and Reggie hammering without giving silver a chance to claim was very anti-town (would he do that as scum?), but this seems like a tough wagon to analyze because so few people were against it, and because Calamitas's setup opinions kind of dominated the discussion, and sort of formed the opposite view to lynching silver. I was hoping I'd find more, but it is what it is.
We may as well credit the people who weren't on the wagon at any significant point, and that was WW and mcmc, plus Calamitas who was just refusing to play with actual reads.
Looking at the eventual wagon, it's kind of interesting that the scum decided to kill an on-wagon person. I mean, for the five still-alive people left, if we were to assume there were two scum on-wagon (which is usually quite a safe assumption), then some of us have a 50-50 chance of picking a scum randomly from the four other still-alive people on that wagon. I'd originally used that to conclude that the scums probably had two people off-wagon and are sitting there laughing at us self-destructing as town, but then I decided it's probably all wifom.
