1
Mafia Game Threads / Re: M113: sufjan stevens (day 2)
« on: February 21, 2018, 01:31:21 pm »Sorry been super busy.
Same. WIll try to get to this tonight.
Sorry been super busy.
I was town to the people who know I don't do that kind of thing as scum. Which is like everyone but you and Cuzz.
You're asking entirely the wrong questions, anyhow.
No, you just enjoy being cryptic. I am taking this as a claim of "investigative PR with town result on Space", and will assume you're scum if you try to walk it back later on.
The question should have read, "why did you target space"? Instead, it's the usual kill the obvious good guy for using his role to help town identify the other good guys that always happens for inscrutable reasons especially since it is always town that leads the crusade.
You're asking entirely the wrong questions, anyhow.
WHy is Space a known townie ?Because I said so.
Will do some more in depth analysis later this morning. Interesting scum killed the other major wagon for us and galz was on wagon and lurking. Honestly strange kill.
Scum always comments on the strangeness of the kill.
Is the above good enough for you? I am time limited this game, that's why I am not fully fleshing out all my thoughts and supporting everything I say with quotes and stuff.
I could vote Space but what if they are town? I'd be bummed.
what does ATE mean?
Pretty meh on the clement votes. Classic "he is scummy for not saying anything" followed by "he said something, it is scummy!"
Unfortunately I see town doing that far too often out of over reading perceived scum traits.
[reads list]Aka "I want to be able to jump on all the popular wagons"
Vote: SirClemens
[reads list]Aka "I want to be able to jump on all the popular wagons"
Vote: SirClemens
The wagons are probably popular for a reason.
Teproc has a 100% scum read record on me in every game we've played together, and a 0% accuracy rate on my being scum. He has no clue what he's looking for, and his case here is more of the same from him.
Huh. Is that true? It might be true.
I mean, I'll give you that my memory isn't always the greatest - but I cannot recall a game with Teproc where he hasn't scum read me for the majority of the game, and I've been town each time.
Mind you, that argument is irrelevant as a defense of my alignment here as past alignments have no bearings on current ones - it's more a note on Teproc's inability to read me.
Would you expect those in that game to remember? I feel like I was an observer, but don't remember much at all.QuotePlayer list:
1. LaLight
2. Galzria
3. gkrieg
4. 2.71828.....
5. Archetype
6. Teproc
7. Witherweaver
8. IDontPlayThisGame
9. Datswan
10. Eevee
11. Qvist
12. RoadRunner
13. faust
14. SpaceAnemone
15. Iguanaiguana
16. Jimmmmm
17. O
Run by: Robz, mcmc
The three people that took him at face value and assigned town points were all involved in the previous game.
Cool, iguana is confirmed town, and Teproc.
Vote: PPS
Catching up.Context? Bonus points if you are willing to point out where in the game in occurred.I believe that if I describe the thoughts that occured to me when I saw my role PM, it would help prove to you all that I am town. However, doing so would involve claiming.
Should I claim? Discuss.
Hm. Usually I'd give townpoints for this, but iguana has done this as scum in Lost so meh.
I believe that if I describe the thoughts that occured to me when I saw my role PM, it would help prove to you all that I am town. However, doing so would involve claiming.
Should I claim? Discuss.
I believe that if I describe the thoughts that occured to me when I saw my role PM, it would help prove to you all that I am town. However, doing so would involve claiming.
Should I claim? Discuss.
vote: iguana for even bringing up claiming immediately i'm so sick of insta claims and mass claims.
Actually vote: cuzzVote: mcmc
I accept iguana as town, and don't think he should claim more.
I don't accept this argument. The iguana is town part, at least. And think he should claim if he thinks he should (looks like he isn't going to, which is fine), but find those giving town credit without actually hearing what he has to say/claim mildly to moderately suspicious.I accept iguana as town, and don't think he should claim more.
you would
Yes
Good. Now that we've gotten that out of the way, which of these seems most likely:
Scum {any of us} supports Town Iguana
Scum {any of us} supports Scum Iguana
Town {any of us} supports Town Iguana
Town {any of us} supports Scum Iguana
Personally, in a void, I think option 2 is least likely in any given game. That means even if you value the others all equally, Iguana is more likely than not town.
Not to mention, you know, this isn't scum iguana.
Vote:Galz
also just remembered how much i despise this part of the game
unvote
not voting (5): Robz888, SirClemens, Teproc, Galzria, iguanaiguananot voting (5): Robz888, SirClemens, Teproc, Galzria, iguanaiguananot voting (5): Robz888, SirClemens, Teproc, Galzria, iguanaiguana
Woah.
I think Cuzz' reaction on ii claim was a little off. What does meta say about this?
anyone claiming ii is town should be looked at as skummy. the only people that could possibly make that assumption at this point int he game are themselves and skum.
I essentially agree with Galzria.
I'm close enough to IC now that I'm gunna lurk and silently judge yall for a while.
I am confused by the amount of people posting at 4am. Also I have come around to agree that iguana's statement is slightly more likely to be made by town and that cuzz's reaction has been the scummiest.
Lalight want to elaborate on your robz read I didn't get weird vibes from him at all.
Also datswan is town, I think he unnecessarily attacks galz and gets miffed more often as town.
Your 4am is my 13.00
I don’t know, he just said couple of general statements and this is all.
I know you and faust live on the other side but I was suprised by the datswan and galz/cuzz activity.
Also doesn't robz just always do that now. He's literally said "Iguana is town and shouldn't claim" and "I agree with galz". What do you expect town!robz to have done/said?
Interesting white-knighting here
well, I would expect not the bare words and statements, but at least a back up of why he agrees with Galz, why he thinks that ii is town, anything else, even RVS!
Are you really saying "I would expect robz to post thought out and backed-up ideas early day 1" because I just can't remember the last time he did that as either alignment.
I'm close enough to IC now that I'm gunna lurk and silently judge yall for a while.
Wanna actually be IC use your town cred to engage people and create even more discussions while accruing reads based on said discussions then if we get into a lul in game state you can slam some of those reads on us with a vote/case. you know pro-town things not just pro-iguana things.
mcmc is being super aggressive
Had a crazy day at work and just got to a spot where I could catch up. Quite a lot of intense discussion for a D1.
Have no idea what to make of it. I certainly don’t care for the iguana division method. I took it as perfectly null and pretty much any response to it as null. Getting all invested in null is pretty useless to me.
Galzria left himself off his reads list so Vote: Galzria
I am willing to sheep this. vote: DatSwan
As a wise man once said:I think the answer is just sheep Faust.
Vote: DatSwan
On the other hand, this series of posts has been scummier than what DatSwan did.
Vote: Cuzz
On the other hand, this series of posts has been scummier than what DatSwan did.
Vote: Cuzz
Cool! Care to show your work for the rest of the class?
Sure. We have a post discussing the scumminess of DatSwan without a vote, immediately followed by a post about how people voting for DatSwan are scummy sheepers. There you gave the reason why you didn't vote for DatSwan! Amazing stuff.
And then comes a pointless reads list that only restates the stuff you just said. But hey you look active at least!