@Axxle, killing all three seems like a terrible way to handle this.
While I agree with this, that's only the worst-case scenario. I think it's fairly safe to say that at least one of {Insom, Galz, Robz, Eevee} is scum. I also think it's reasonable to say that the most likely Town of these is Insom. If we believe Galz (not saying I do, still unsure what to make of Galz' game so far, but Galz seems the easiest to verify) then that leaves us with Robz and Eevee. If we hit scum, that's great, mission successful. If not, then Galz can take care of the other and we're 1-1 which seems like a good return. If it turns out Galz is (the?) scum, then he's/his team's going to NK anyway so there's not much we can do about that, and we can lynch Galz and be 1-1 from Town kills. Worst case, they're all Town and Insom is scum, in which case it might be worth it to find him out rather than wrongly trust him for the rest of the game.
So at this stage, Axxle's plan seems plausible. Would like to hear from Robz and Eevee. And Galz. And Insom. And everyone else.
PPE: Wow okay, some stuff has happened. New plan? Maybe we do an unofficial vote and if we get to "L" then Robz can dayvig?