Elyv beats ScottPilgrim92 4-2 in the Witch Division. We played with identical starting hands, no veto mode, and no point counter.
Game 1 (Elyv 47-33 ScottPilgrim92): Both of us open Silver/Nomad Camp with the intention of getting hoards and going green. The main difference is that ScottPilgrim bought an early expand while I didn't buy any, and he felt like that was why I won.
Game 2 (Elyv 31 - 21 ScottPilgrim92): I open potion/warehouse, visions of king's courted alchemists dancing through my head, but Scott goes for Jack BM. When he sees me grab the potion, he buys an early embargo and blocks the alchemists, so I decide that I have to transition into Jack BM as well. It was a pretty close game, but I realize that I still haven't been able to trash one of my starting estates, so I'm able to grab the second-to-last province without fear, and then am lucky enough to get the next one on the following turn as well.
Game 3 (Elyv 46 - 35 ScottPilgrim92): Another BMish game, with the difference that he opens with horse traders and I open silver/silver, intending to get a vault later. His deck ends up doing better for the majority of the game, with the result that when the duchies run out with 2 provinces left, he has a slight lead on points. Luckily, I'm able to snag the last two provinces to take the game.
Game 4 (Elyv 35 - 39 Scottpilgrim92): At the beginning of this game, I say something to the effect of "finally an interesting board", which was really kind of a silly thing to say since I'd somehow missed that the kingdom had no card draw, leading to both of us going remake BM. Scottpilgrim grabbed a second remake, and that may have been the difference, as he ends up with a pretty significant lead once the duchies run out. I felt like I had no real chance to win the game at that point, so I bought the province for the loss.
Game 5 (Elyv 26 - 27 ScottPilgrim92): Probably the closest game of the series. I open masq/silver since I hate opening with tournament, especially when paired with terminal card draw, but Scott doesn't seem to mind. I end up getting the first couple of golds, so he gets a couple of Noble brigands, which hurt me a lot more than I was expecting. Regardless, I was still able to make my one tournament collide with my one province before he was able to, putting me in a good position. On my last turn, I stupidly use tournament to grab a diadem instead of a princess, forgetting about the $1 that the tournament provides. As a result, scott is able to pass me his one curse with masquerade and buy the province to squeak out the win. If I had grabbed princess, I would've been able to buy an estate as well, and the game would've been a draw.
Game 6 (Elyv 34 - 20 ScottPilgrim92): Probably the most interesting game of the series. Both of us go for a fishing village/steward deck, mixing in jesters and forges later. Again going into the endgame, I'm up a point from a random estate that I hadn't had a chance to trash, so I'm able to buy the penultimate province and then the last one a turn later to take the game.
It was a fun match, especially since I was able to chat with ScottPilgrim after every game, and it felt like every game was very close.