I think it's possible for scum to say that. It's certainly not very good, though. But imagine this: You know Hydrad is lying. You know he'll get lynched after a counterclaim that you know will end up happening. You try to get town points from trying to make the PR stay hidden.
PPE: Yeah...
No, I mean would we rather counterclaim or lynch Hydrad without a counterclaim?Or do we not want to counterclaim, as that gives scum more info?
Unvote
We absolutely want the counterclaim if there is one. No PR is as good as catching scum.
This is highly suspicious.
It is certainly weird, and I would think it suspicious had Hydrad flipped town. But as it is, I don't see why scum posts that.
Come to think of it, Joseph jumping on e on the back of the `massclaim incident' (as it shall henceforth be known) is not terrible, but it looks really bad that he then swings round on me as soon as e says anything at all about it.
vote: Joseph
and I will make that a real vote as soon as I check that I'm not hammering or anything. Small games are WEIRD!
No, I mean would we rather counterclaim or lynch Hydrad without a counterclaim?Or do we not want to counterclaim, as that gives scum more info?
Unvote
We absolutely want the counterclaim if there is one. No PR is as good as catching scum.
I started playing Town of Salem.
People don't lynch there. It's awful.
e, you explained the Haddock vote, but what makes Joseph scummy?
\in ...teresting
What do you think about scum using this to safely fake claim something without ever having to prove it?
I think I planned for that. And I think you blew that possibility out of the water. And I think DAMA.
What do you think about scum using this to safely fake claim something without ever having to prove it?
I think that's not very likely to have occurred, because I'm not scum.
My plan has been fruitful. That's good.
Don't like the VT claim.
Don't like WW trying to turn it into a mass claim.
I have no experience with such things, so I wouldn't get too excited. Has "ooh, and that's a bad miss" been done already?
What I think of whenever I see Shanty Town:
Shantier Town Action
+2 Cards
Reveal your hand. If you have no Action cards in hand, +2 Actions.
Well I certainly prefer starting with 7 Coppers in the deck to starting with 7 Ruined Markets.
Vote: Awaclus
WW is Joseph's partner.
We're Masons.
this isn't a series claim, is it?
Vote: Awaclus
WW is Joseph's partner.
Vote: Awaclus
I'm not so sure. I faked ignorance about a claiming plan in my first scum game and claimed earlier than I needed to.
