Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Donald X.

Filter to certain boards:

Pages: 1 ... 159 160 [161] 162 163 ... 248
4001
I assume that Hero costing 5, while it does have some interactions with cost-caring a la t4b, swindler, etc., is probably more to do with helping you remember the sequence? Or making it look nicer, what have you. We know the cheapest card in the sequence costs 2. I would hazard a guess that the costs of the cards go 2-3-4-5-6.
They do go 2-3-4-5-6, and yes a big part of that is that it helps make it all clear, the 3 goes to the 4.

4002
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 05:53:36 pm »
If you already had 3 copies of the highest treasures available in hand, the Storyteller with +1 sifting also cannot draw more.
And apparently you always do!
No.. but I do sometimes go on to write sentences that explain my point.
In fact I endlessly spend time explaining obvious things to people on the internet. Hey it's part of the job and it's easy.

And I gave you some sentences; they just didn't do much for you. I don't see why additional sentences would be treated differently. At the same time this hypothetical card is too close to a real card for it to be great for me to endlessly analyze it. I don't need to convince you of anything; believe whatever you want about that hypothetical card.

4003
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 05:34:01 pm »
If you already had 3 copies of the highest treasures available in hand, the Storyteller with +1 sifting also cannot draw more.
And apparently you always do!

4004
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 04:37:43 pm »
It is precisely a 1-card sifting difference. Whether this is "trivial" or not is something I'll let you and other people discuss.

It's a plus, and it's a plus that most of the time won't make a difference.

Where do you even get "1 card difference" from?  Whether it's +1 Card or +$1, Storyteller draws you one more card.  The difference is that the earlier +1 Card would let you draw a treasure and feed it to Storyteller whereas the +$1 would not.  Thus, the sifting difference depends on that treasure you may draw and play to Storyteller.  If you draw a Copper, sure, it gives you an extra card.  But if you draw a better treasure, the difference is much bigger.

Edit: Maybe you mean, it's 1 card sifting difference because you potentially play out 1 extra treasure and no more.  I guess you aren't considering the extra draw that comes out of that treasure play?  I suppose you may ignore that for discussion of "sifting", but the extra draw is an important consideration and it makes the +1 card vs. +$1 very, very different.
Changing the +1$ of Storyteller to +1 Card gives you the opportunity to consider that 1 card as part of your hand before resolving the rest of Storyteller, rather than after.  That is effectively a 1-card sift, and all we need to say on the matter as far as describing the immediate functional difference.

Most of the time, you've already got some treasures in your hand and don't need the additional options of that +1 card sift.  So most of the time it doesn't make a difference.

Since most of the time it won't make a difference, I disagree that it is "very, very different."

It would be a small plus, that is all.
Speaking as someone who has played with both cards, I disagree.

4005
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 03:43:10 pm »
I'm curious why it gives +1 action and +$1 instead of just saying +1 action +1 card, as these will amount to the same thing. Is there some interaction here that I'm missing? Overall a really cool card though!
They are not the same at all.
Having +1 Card instead of +$1 would make it *more* powerful, because you could draw your third Treasure to play, if you only had 2 in hand to begin with.
Sure, but it is a 1-card sifting difference. Most of the time +1 card or +1$ amounts to the same effect here.
When N is bigger than 1, N squared is bigger than N. Consider the case where a typical card in your deck is a treasure worth $100.

4006
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 03:29:31 pm »
I hope it's elaborated upon. Intuitively "spend" would have been clearer than "pay" in my mind, but I'm guessing there's a reason it's "pay" we just don't know it yet.
I do not think saying "spend" there would have improved things. There will be a rulebook with a FAQ as always.

4007
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 03:14:41 pm »
I'm curious why it gives +1 action and +$1 instead of just saying +1 action +1 card, as these will amount to the same thing. Is there some interaction here that I'm missing? Overall a really cool card though!
They are not the same at all.

4008
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 03:08:42 pm »
So a question I thought of today is whether paying your (coin symbol thing) includes potions; obviously if it does, that doesn't translate to cards. I am guessing it doesn't, only because that symbol is the same one from Salvager, and Salvager doesn't add potion to my pool if I trash e.g. Possession.
You can obv. play a Potion with Storyteller; [Potion] isn't lost and doesn't get you any cards.

4009
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 03:01:58 pm »
This card looks like it might be the output of a chain of design ideas that began with the version of Jester that allows you to swap the vanilla bonuses another card gives you—it's an implementation of "swap +$ for +Cards".
No, it goes back to trying "pay $ to draw cards" in Prosperity.

4010
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 01:29:15 pm »
Eh, probably will be answered in "Secret Histories", but why is it limited to 3 Treasures?
Power level.

I are need more explain :(
That's already more strategy advice than I like to give.

4011
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 01:15:31 pm »
Eh, probably will be answered in "Secret Histories", but why is it limited to 3 Treasures?
Power level.

4012
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Preview: Storyteller
« on: March 30, 2015, 12:53:14 pm »
When you Pay, are the cards technically still in play? So coppers played and paid to the Storyteller will still hinder buying a Grand Market later in your turn?
Yes, those Coppers are still in play.

4013
Would exchanging rule out scheme shenanigans like with hermit?
Exchanging requires actually having both the card leaving and the card coming in. If I resolve Scheme first and put Hero on top, I can't get a Champion with it that turn. If I exchange Hero for Champion first, the Champion is in my discard pile and the Hero is gone, Scheme does nothing.

4014
The "upgrade chain" (Traveller type) cards changed a whole lot from the Chicago meetup, wow.

No kiddin', dang.  I think I personally liked the old version better but that's entirely because I like overly complicated things.

I hope this will all be revealed in the Secret History.
Yes, all will be revealed. The original version was way too slow, and also having the cards all be vanilla wasn't great. The new version is fast and the cards are way more interesting. Anyway, there is a secret history, that is where the secret history will be told.

4015
Query: is exchanging considered gaining?
Exchanging is not gaining.

4016
Does that mean that if you are playing a game with Pages, there are 10 pages, and 4 additional piles of 5 cards each? So in a really complicated game you could end up with at least 11 non-supply piles (Spoils, Madmen, Mercenaries, 6 Travelers, Champions, Teachers)?
Yes. You may wish to not play with all of those cards at once, or to specifically do so. Since they're non-supply, if table space is an issue, you could just have them in one big pile and paw through it as needed.

4017
Good thing Donald specified what genders the artists should draw, otherwise we might have gotten some intersting life-stories including sex change.
Each set of 5 was done by one artist, so that it would clearly be the same character.

Edit: Like LF said.

4018
I wonder how many travellers there will be in each pile. With 30 kingdom cards, 20 events and 2 12 card-piles, there's not enough room for 10 of each.

Also I wonder how exactly "exchanging" works. Does that mean the Hero goes to the Champion pile?
There are 5 cards in each pile you upgrade into (the top two aren't Travellers, since they don't upgrade). They return to the piles, so that tends to be enough. Sometimes it isn't in multiplayer if everyone wants multiples right away.

You exchange by putting Hero back in the Hero pile, and taking a Champion. You can't exchange if the pile you're upgrading into is empty.

4019
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Previews #1 - Lost City, Magpie, Hero
« on: March 30, 2015, 10:05:19 am »
It's a new Dominion expansion! Some of you knew it was inevitable; some of you hoped it would happen; some of you were glad it wasn't going to. It's happening though, I am so sure of it that I am previewing cards from it.

Adventures has a ton of cards, so I am previewing three a day. Each day but today the cards will fit a theme, showing off a different functional aspect of the set - Reserve, Duration, Events, tokens. That leaves today to show off some cards that don't fit those themes.



I like to lead with a simple card, to prove that the set has some. Lost City is a vanilla card on top, that makes the other players draw a card when you get one. You really don't want them to have that good turn, but then you may really want some Lost Cities.

Recent studies show that magpies do not especially collect shiny objects. These are folklore magpies though, which still do. Magpie might find you a treasure, or perhaps just reveal another Magpie. Over time a single Magpie can turn into a whole flock of them. There are just ten Magpies in the pile; they're not Rats with wings.

Finally we have Hero. This one is somewhat enigmatic. The top is straightforward, you get +$2 and gain a Treasure, any Treasure in the game. Usually Gold but you never know, could be Platinum or something more exotic. And then when you discard it from play, you can exchange it for a Champion. And wait, this isn't in the Supply. How do you get one? Well I'll tell you. You just need to discard a Warrior from play; then you can exchange the Warrior for a Hero. Warrior isn't in the Supply either though - you get one by exchanging a Treasure Hunter for it. I suppose it's obvious that you get a Treasure Hunter by exchanging a Page for it. But that's it, that's all the turtles there are; you buy a Page, and it turns into a Treasure Hunter, then a Warrior, then a Hero, then a Champion. Page costs $2, so the actual cost of Hero is, $2, plus playing those other cards once each. I somehow fit two of these cycles into Adventures - there's also a Peasant who becomes a Soldier, but then a Fugitive, but then a Disciple, and finally a Teacher. It's two little life stories, played out in cards that gradually get better for you. What exactly the other cards do will remain a mystery until the set is out; there is just too much to preview.

But wait, there's more! dominionstrategy.com [wait that's here] is also going to have a preview each day this week - single card previews, a different previewer each time. The set has 58 uh things; even at 4 a day, it will be below average for what % of it was previewed. No doubt these other previews will be crossposted here, just as these are crossposted there. I am mentioning them here anyway.

4020
Puzzles and Challenges / Re: Endless Dominion Picture Trivia
« on: March 29, 2015, 08:10:03 pm »
Sing a song of sixpence, a pocketful of rye,
four in twenty blackbirds baked in a pie,

There is in fact a distinctive Dominion card name in that nursery rhyme.

4021
Puzzles and Challenges / Re: Endless Dominion Picture Trivia
« on: March 29, 2015, 03:45:41 pm »
So, is it true that #2 isn't Baker? I figured #8 was King Masterpiece, but that only turns up images of Transformers for whatever reason...

Also, guess what i had google search for when i stumbled over this:


Deeplin King?

Nope.

It's: King Sage. The game is King's Age.
You are seeing an image from a game, but we are seeing "No Deeplinking please!"

4022
Dominion Articles / Re: Why Engine?
« on: March 28, 2015, 06:05:19 pm »
It's a bit funny when, say, Stef posts that he agrees with someone and gets more respect for it than the original post.

That shouldn't be surprising. When you experience some symptoms, read stuff on Wikipedia, make some vague conjecture about your condition and then visit your doctor who confirms it, your doctor's statement is far more valuable to you than the wikipedia article and your own guesswork.

Similarly, when Unknown Player X says something and Unknown Player Y argues the opposite, the entire argument would be pretty meaningless to a mediocre player who's unable to judge who's correct. Now, if Stef chimes in saying "I agree with every word of Player X, very well expressed!", that statement would be tremendously valuable.

The value isn't in the words themselves but in them being a destillation of high-level experience.
I agree. Well put!

4023
"A sifter is a card that draws and discards, in either order, or reveals/looks at cards from your deck with the option of discarding them, so as to cycle through your deck to get to more desirable cards."

http://wiki.dominionstrategy.com/index.php/Sifter

Hamlet and Plaza sift.  True, NV doesn't technically sift in this manner, but it's got a sift-y vibe to it.
This is just you quoting yourself, right?

4024
Dominion General Discussion / Re: Interview with Donald X.
« on: March 28, 2015, 10:02:37 am »
At what time will you post previews each day?
I assume you'll post them here and on BGG, where will you post first?
I'll post them when I get up, which will probably get slightly later as the week progresses. No earlier than 7 AM Pacific time.

I'll post them on BGG first. The image may not show up instantly over here.

4025
Dominion: Adventures Previews / Re: Teasers!
« on: March 27, 2015, 06:17:32 pm »
Also, the third day of previews will be April Fool's Day...
Those previews won't be a trick or joke. That is just the full week leading up to the original posted release date.

Pages: 1 ... 159 160 [161] 162 163 ... 248

Page created in 0.112 seconds with 19 queries.