26
Dominion League / Re: Season 18 - Results
« on: December 01, 2016, 06:23:33 pm »
C2 Simon (DK) - diedre91 5-1
Yes.
Might as well report it to the MF forums. I suspect what happened is that MF considers Estates and Inherited Estates to be different cards, with some hacky logic in there to treat them as cards with the same name and such.
Mint works instead of mandrin.
Or gain it with Horn of Plenty.Wow, mind = blown. I didn't realize that Mandarin's effect was on-gain (I thought it was on-buy, guess it was easy to confuse since it used to be impossible to gain it with treasures in play without buying it). I'm still trying to wrap my head around all the things BoM can do. Forget Villa, THAT's a borked card right there.Difficult and usually not useful, but not impossible. Just play Storyteller or Black Market followed by a suitable gainer. But the interaction between Crown and Mandarin is now more interesting as part of that effect.
Ooooh this is super cool. I take it this doesn't affect duration effects from cards played on previous turns, but it would affect anything Princed?
Correct. It affects the first Action card you play in a turn, one way or the other. If you played no cards in your Action phase, it could even affect a Crown played in your Buy phase, come to think of it.
If you started with the Crown in your hand, then it's always better to play it in your action phase. Edge case that.
Of course it can happen if you hit it with Venture.
Ooooh this is super cool. I take it this doesn't affect duration effects from cards played on previous turns, but it would affect anything Princed?
Correct. It affects the first Action card you play in a turn, one way or the other. If you played no cards in your Action phase, it could even affect a Crown played in your Buy phase, come to think of it.
There is one way to prevent Madman from returning to the Madman pile. What is it?
There are two statements on the Wiki for Inheritance, each of which seems to make sense, but they seem to contradict each other. Could you please help me sort this out?QuoteIf you Transmute an Inherited Estate, the Estate is in the trash and, thus, no longer yours when Transmute checks its type; therefore you would only get a Gold (for trashing a Victory card) and not a Duchy (since Estate cannot be an Action card in the trash).I guess if you Transmute an Inherited Estate, then when you check its type it's already back in your hand, so its a Fortress and an Estate, so you would get a Gold and a Duchy.Do you get anything at all? If Transmute is responsible for checking the type of the card after it has been trashed, shouldn't it have lost track of the Estate-Fortress (it's not in the Trash where Transmute is expecting to find it) and hence not be able to trigger any of the "If it is..." options?