I'm including raerae in "claimed redirector". I know she didn't specifically, but I'll eat a hat if that's not the result she "had" on cayvie
so it looks like now raerae knows that she killed Galz!
well, or ari.
well, or me. if i'm lying.
well, or none of this, if she's lying.
well, or something else, if there's more redirection afoot.
This doesn't answer my question...if there's a "tie", which are resolved first? Random, first in first out...what?
They are resolved randomly.
LaLi, how are you and how are things in your part of the world?
for the last couple of weeks I managed to crawl out of depression that was eating me for months and now I am quite resourseful!
Why is everybody saying shraeye's town? He's done a whole lot of not very much.
do you have a scumread on him?
What tale am I weaving? cayvie has made ALL the speculation, I just said she killed Galz. Why is that unbelievable? And we've already talked about how we should stop making claims and giving scum targets so is so crazy that I took that advice? What am I actually being lynched for right now? Can anybody answer that?
It's hard to come up with a role that would allow you to know that with any certyainty given the nature of the game as it has been revealed to us so far. You've refused to claim your role, which would allow us to understand how you are able to know what you claim to know. You left yourself a very specific out for if cayvie flips town (oops, guess the scum redirector targeted her), which is a scummy thing to do when claiming an investigative role.
but i don't think it's scummy from MiX. you're omgusing
so i remember like 3-4 instances of "lynch me but i won't claim" in Mafia games, usually by self-hammering ashersky and in every case he was town. why would scum!rae not claim? I believe her here.
but i also believe cayvie to be town, can't really explain
let's try vote: Joseph for a change
I think scum!raerae doesn't know of a fakeclaim that explains her behavior. That's my read, take it or leave it, I wouldn't give her a chance to discuss with her scummates over night.
Joseph? Eh.
how the hell are you all so sure raerae gets nked if there is like 26 redirectors
who are you asking?
i don't think raerae gets nked because i think she's scum.
but, on the off-chance she's town, i don't think a full-claim makes her any more likely to be nightkilled than her current partial "i'm an investigator but i won't tell you what kind, riddle dee dee" claim.
That sounds correct.
Excellent. In that case, consider me in the “Raerae please claim, you’re gonna get NKed anyways” camp.
Vote: Raerae
It makes negative sense to lunch me if I'm going to be the NK. If I'm the NK then I'm not scum.
Vote: ari
"raerae please claim, if you're town you're gonna get NKed anyways"
Did he really need to say "if you're town" in that sentence? Because it's heavily implied.
That sounds correct.
Excellent. In that case, consider me in the “Raerae please claim, you’re gonna get NKed anyways” camp.
Vote: Raerae
Thank you raerae.
So there's scum in (raerae, cayvie, ari)? Because it seems like it.
Raerae, do you stand by your information being changed if cayvie was redirected?
lol MiX has gotta be like "wtf is going on" right now
If you aren't confused at least once then it's not a good Mafia game, right??
haha. you've played with MiX before, would you mind answering my question about him?
is this game a typical example of MiX's play?
lol MiX has gotta be like "wtf is going on" right now
We all know that Glooble softclaimed to have a night action. It's the first thing he said this game, right?
I guess I'm really trying to ask who you believe and why. I think? We're probably talking past each other again/as always.
I believe everyone. Who do you not believe, other than cayvie?
Answer this please.
cayvie doesn't trust your softclaim. Is that so wrong? Is that so unbelievable? Cayvie isn't jumping into conclusions, she's just going for the first thing that makes sense, and right now there's nothing that points to anything else being more probable than you being scum (or cayvie being scum, but obviously cayvie won't explore that). Why do you assume people will trust your claim, especially the one that absolutely knows that your result has to be wrong in some way or another (from cayvie's perspective)?
You will if we wagon you. This is just bringing a ton of confusion and splitting town, it's much better if you'd simply claim and be done with it. But you won't, because I said you should, and you're too stubborn to listen to anyone but yourself.
This is way too much chaos based on raerae not claiming. You either claim a result, or you say nothing, not this. We're going in circles.
raerae, do you think ari did the NK if cayvie is town?
