26
Dominion General Discussion / Re: Not playing Smithy in fear of drawing dead actions?
« on: April 12, 2013, 02:05:39 pm »No. Basically all dominion advice does depend on the Kingdom.
Edge case:
"On a Witch board, if you open 5/2, is it better to open Witch/Nothing, or Curse/Curse?"
That question does not depend on the Kingdom.
Of course it does. You said, 'On a Witch board'. That's a specific kind of kingdom on which your question depends.
Actual question that doesn't depends on the kingdom:
When I use my Copper to buy a card, do I have to return it to the supply/bank like in other games (Monopoly, Settlers, Power Grid...)?
Yup, I'd agree, that one doesn't.
Now, I'd hate to make this a silly semantics argument, but ftl was talking about advice, not basic how-to-play questions. I've tried, but I've not yet come up with a question that asks for an opinion on the best play that doesn't depend on the kingdom.
My first try was, would you rather have gold or silver? Seemed obvious, then I remembered Feodum. There are cards that refer to, by name, Estate, Duchy, Province, Copper, Silver, and Gold, so the value of each of these varies with the kingdom.