226
Rules Questions / Re: Herald Overpay while Haggler in play. (possible dominion online bug)
« on: July 03, 2019, 02:17:14 pm »
Yes, I had Changeling and Druid, as you mentioned.
This seems counterintuitive to me: the player can order on-buy triggers however they like, and I would have expected gaining to be just another thing that was triggered by buying. Is there a definitive ruling anywhere?
You buy a card by choosing it from the Supply, and then "gaining" it.
I had wondered about that as well. I noticed that on ShuffleiT there is an option to "do nothing" even if you don't already have the Key and there are Treasures both in the trash and your hand. That seemed to be a minor mistake if each of the options is treated as mandatory once you've chosen it.
I can't read the error message, but if you try to connect with http*s* the errorbehavior seems totally different.
You can't connect to https at all. It doesn't answer on that port.
Of course. It fails to set itself aside, so also fails to return to the supply.I think the answer here is simple... Band of Misfits "play this as if" instructions expects the Band of Misfits to be in play, because that is the normal place that a card is when you are following its on-play instructions. Band of Misfits is not in play, therefore the "play this as if" instruction can't find it to move it.
In which case, should a BOM'd Encampment played from the trash also fail to return itself to the supply (since it similarly expects to find itself in play)?
I actually ran into this on Dominion Online, and the Faitful Hound was set aside, played (I drew 2 cards) and I still got the Hound back next turn. As has been said, only the zone move is prevented by loose track, not other effects.Vassal checks the top of the discard pile. If you reveal Faithful Hound and set it aside, you cannot play it as Vassal lost track.Citation needed. My understanding is that Vassal can play a Faithful Hound that has reacted to being revealed. Lose-track only means it will not be put into play when you play it.