Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - WestCoastDidds

Filter to certain boards:

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 211
1
That was fun! Thank you Swowl and Scola for making it happen.

2
Shraeye was so super anti-EFHW that it was strange.

Gkrieg, you have been awesome! And mid-move. Seriously impressive!

Vote: EFHW

3
Why wouldn't the SK just kill gkrieg though? Do they think they need the extra kills from the vig missing to win at this point?

I think so. If gkrieg comes back dead today, and math has cleared someone else, then the other PR claims, wed have 3 or 4 confirmed town and it would be tough to wiggle. But with math dead, we get no more info from him and now its just an argument about if gkrieg is lying or not. Or if the fear was that math checked her, a guilty result would been game over. Better odds there than the POE on the other scenario, right? And she wouldnt have known shed have been gkriegs target when she decided.

That all works, right? (I havent had coffee yet!)

I feel so understood!

:)

4
Such a globetrotter Didds! Do you think the stars will ever align that we'll meet in person?

For sure! Just gimme time it helps that you live in a delicious city.

5
Why wouldn't the SK just kill gkrieg though? Do they think they need the extra kills from the vig missing to win at this point?

I think so. If gkrieg comes back dead today, and math has cleared someone else, then the other PR claims, wed have 3 or 4 confirmed town and it would be tough to wiggle. But with math dead, we get no more info from him and now its just an argument about if gkrieg is lying or not. Or if the fear was that math checked her, a guilty result would been game over. Better odds there than the POE on the other scenario, right? And she wouldnt have known shed have been gkriegs target when she decided.

That all works, right? (I havent had coffee yet!)

6
Good morning! Ill wait to vote until everyone is around since it would be E-1.

Im going to Chile tomorrow. Anyone know anything awesome to do in Santiago??

7
Mafia Game Threads / Re: f.ds Mafia Hub
« on: August 01, 2022, 06:13:52 pm »
someone please grab the pulp fiction kit and jab FDS in the heart and lfg?
I am good to open another game after this one, but I would like to play one as well :)

❤️

8
It's the lack of interest at deadlines due to us not playing for a while, the plurality exile, the weekend deadline, or something else?

My guess is plurality is the problem

9
Sorry about that, although it doesnt look like I missed anything. I thought the airplane would have WiFi, but alas, no.

10
We have 2ish hours

11
This is unfortunate.

Well be able to kill scum tomorrow, though.

Right?

Probably?

Anyway. Im going to sleep. Might not wake up until after deadline.

Best of luck, folks.

This is the second time Eddie said this and he didn't answer my question about the first time. Then goes to sleep without changing his vote despite implying strongly that he thinks Jack is town. What's the message here?

Eddie, this is left over from Day 1. Can you respond?

Science.

Is that really the end of this conversation...?

I kinda want uncle to be SK so I can OMGUS without negative consequences, but I'm not seeing anything out of the ordinary. I mean, other than the quoted post. But when your meta is not explaining your reads...

Now I would reread joth, but I'm out of time. I might be here during deadline, or not.

Any conclusions?

12
Unvote

13
MIX, Shraeye, and EFHW

Okay, so if Gkrieg, Math, and WCD are all off the table (assuming were believing gkrieg and math, obvi)

Among whos left, whose the SK?

14
Granted, Shraeye is the guy that seems to bamboozle me more than most on here, but Id be shocked if hes bad.

I dunno.

Id vote for EFHW leagues before shraeye, but shraeye doesnt want me to.

Im following gkrieg, and no one at all seems interested in EFHW. Im not sure why gkrieg prefers Shraeye over MiX. Mathdude has cleared me, so we need to POE this thing out.

15

Vote: Shraeye

16
We are now less than 24 hours to deadline.


17
MiX, are you voting for math because you think hes the SK or self-Pres?

Both, but he did say something that makes me reconsider. I kinda hate going back to shraeye because I think I'm only scumreading him for being shraeye. So...I don't know.

Thanks for the unvote joth.

Why the reconsider?

The PR claim, basically.

Got it. Shraye then? Or am I still on your list?

18
MiX, are you voting for math because you think hes the SK or self-Pres?

Both, but he did say something that makes me reconsider. I kinda hate going back to shraeye because I think I'm only scumreading him for being shraeye. So...I don't know.

Thanks for the unvote joth.

Why the reconsider?

19
Im included to sheep gkrieg, but Im going to think about mathdude some more today before I do that since no one seems interested in EFHW.

20
MiX, are you voting for math because you think hes the SK or self-Pres?

21
Who uses "when" for a counterfactual they know for a fact will never happen?

Didds, you're a linguist/comms professor, back me up here.

But English isnt his first language. Im not sure we can read deep into specific word meaning, in this case.

22
Hey yall- Im with friends and not at all caught up.

Were choosing between MiX and math? Really?

I love the threat that MiX will only speak Portuguese. Thats hilarious because his English is a bajillion times better than any of my other languages.


23
Irkedness is a great word!

24
D1 his comments were snide and about my stunning lack of ability to build a case on someone despite me finding scum.
Today he is taking me to task for things that others think or have responded to.
He seems convinced that I am a baddie in a stubborn sort of way, so it all seems rather pointless.
Let's go line-by-line:
Disagree on tone, content, and relevance of consequence.
Disagree on magnitude and cause.
Disagree on my mindset and the futility of words.

Off your number one: this is snide. It may not be relevant to you, but it is to me and I get to determine my own consequences.

I think Didds level of heing and hawing has been much higher, also has been put on display on a awkward way....feels performative.

And if Didds is borrowing the metric of scumShraeye is shraeye-lite, it really feels like this is didds-lite.  I was thinking about that before Didds came in with her analysis on her wagon.
Hmmm....  I was looking at the people voting for me...
And wow. The amount of effort/substance staggered me.


#2: magnitude and cause- your cause is unknown to me. Magnitude is that I have you been your sole focus since mid-way through D1, and all of today.

#3: mindset and futility of words. I think Joth summarized well. We disagree on what an SK would think. I have no experience being an SK so I am just guessing. You decide the way that I think about is wrong and therefore scummy, so it really doesn't matter what I say.  I will agree that I don't know your mindset, but but can be surmised based on these posts.


This really doesn't compute. If Eddie/Joth are the folks most instrumental in exiling Jack, you can be HAPPY with their actions (I am) but in terms of whether their actions make them GoodPeople...their actions really just means "They are very much not Jack's partner."  Which means they are either SK or Town, each having equal incentive/happiness at exiling a Goon on Day1.

The only world where Jack's partner is somehow still alive is when it is gkreig going crrrrazy with a gambit.  So, you're saying "I am sure Eddie/joth are on my team because they are not Jack's partner....really doesn't compute with the statements you made here"

shraeye do you suspect Didds of being the SK, or are you just telling her she's wrong?



25
That's my list, too, mathdude.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 211

Page created in 0.1 seconds with 19 queries.