1
Mafia Game Threads / Re: M139 - Godfather Mafia - 3 spots left!!
« on: November 13, 2022, 05:51:06 pm »
Hey
Still suspicious. Probably more so.If it helps, I’m a good guy.
Oh, thanks. That helps so much! [/sarcasm]
I can't speak for others, but I know it doesn't give me any reassurance. You are one of my possible targets tonight... I'm still debating between you and a couple others. It's a combination of wanting to maximize the chance of finding non-town, between picking the most scummy and trying to not double up on what other PRs might pick... while also not coordinating targets in thread, so the SK can't plan around it.
vote: ShraeyeHuh, I was just about to say Mix is good.
I’m included to sheep gkrieg, but I’m going to think about mathdude some more today before I do that since no one seems interested in EFHW.Agree, not interested in EFHW
To what degree?My read on mathdude is just that he has been significantly under the radar for his usual style D1. Like no one butted heads with him at all, even faust.
I can do you one better: Jimmmmm was kinda against the idea that math was town. So. Yeah.
No distractions are pointless; everything is now.As a math dude, you should know thatIt was more a comment about grammar than logic. The claim could have been "I have a gut feel" or "I think he's most likely" - an opinion or a read. But he went all MiX-style, saying a definitive statement that I'm most likely, as if there were actual logic behind it.
Conclusion is wrong =/=> logic is flawed
Anyway, this has been a pointless distraction of a conversation. Let's move on.
Vote: mathdude I’m feeling he’s the most likely SK.
Most likely based on what flawed logic?
I don’t have cases either, shraeye.I never said that no cases was the SK-way. The issue came up D1, where Didds made a post that seemed wagon-analysis-ish but had much less content than, forexample, joth's similar post.
Am I the SK?
The fact that we exiled a scum does not override your lack of cases.D1 his comments were snide and about my stunning lack of ability to build a case on someone despite me finding scum.Let's go line-by-line:
Today he is taking me to task for things that others think or have responded to.
He seems convinced that I am a baddie in a stubborn sort of way, so it all seems rather pointless.
Disagree on tone, content, and relevance of consequence.
Disagree on magnitude and cause.
Disagree on my mindset and the futility of words.
Off your number one: this is snide. It may not be relevant to you, but it is to me and I get to determine my own consequences.
That wasn't what I was waiting for. See joth/shraeye/Didds comboSo, what are your thoughts on gkrieg's claim?I’m firmly on team Eddie/Joth now!
Why is Eddie/Joth a team? What made you want to join it?
These are the folks instrumental in exiling Jack. They are my town team. Either of them not joining the wagon would have made traction on exiling scum way harder.
I believe him. Or at least I think it’s in our best interest to proceed as if what he is saying is true. If it’s not, we find out soon enough.
Shraeye, here's the answer you wanted. Yesterday.
What now?
D1 his comments were snide and about my stunning lack of ability to build a case on someone despite me finding scum.Let's go line-by-line:
Today he is taking me to task for things that others think or have responded to.
He seems convinced that I am a baddie in a stubborn sort of way, so it all seems rather pointless.
shraeye do you suspect Didds of being the SK, or are you just telling her she's wrong?Was waiting for Didds to respond...apparently she doesn't care to.