Dominion Strategy Forum

Dominion => Game Reports => Topic started by: guided on September 16, 2011, 07:10:59 pm

Title: Great Moments in Contraband
Post by: guided on September 16, 2011, 07:10:59 pm
This isn't super flashy, but this game (http://dominion.isotropic.org/gamelog/201109/16/game-20110916-155730-c4d1b50f.html) features some of my all-time favorite Contraband prohibitions.

We were both buying Contraband because it was the only $5 card on the board and we wanted to Remake them into Golds and Nobles. At first, sure, it's pretty mundane: I made sure he couldn't get his first Gold off a Contraband buy. Which isn't completely the end of the world for him, since he can buy Nobles instead.

Then the endgame rolled around, and he was behind, so he had to rely on Contraband for cash and buys attempting to catch up. Again, at first, it's mundane: It's greening time, so I prohibit Provinces, and he buys lesser VP cards instead:

   — Leonard's turn 14 —
   Leonard plays a Contraband.
   ... led prohibits Leonard from buying Provinces.
   Leonard plays 4 Coppers and 2 Silvers.
   Leonard buys a Duchy.
   Leonard buys a Duchy.

   — Leonard's turn 15 —
   Leonard plays a Contraband.
   ... led prohibits Leonard from buying Provinces.
   Leonard plays 3 Silvers.
   Leonard buys a Duchy.
   Leonard buys an Estate.
   Leonard buys an Estate.


But then we get down to 1 Province left in the pile, and I realize hey! If he buys it I've got enough VPs to hold him off. The only way I can lose is if he gets too many Duchies first and then buys it. So here's where I make a really fun play I've never gotten to try before:

   — Leonard's turn 16 —
   Leonard plays a Contraband.
   ... led prohibits Leonard from buying Duchies.
   Leonard plays 2 Coppers.
   Leonard buys an Estate.
   Leonard buys an Estate.
   Leonard buys an Estate.
   Leonard buys an Estate.

   — Leonard's turn 17 —
   Leonard plays a Contraband.
   ... led prohibits Leonard from buying Duchies.
   Leonard plays a Copper and a Silver.
   Leonard buys an Estate.
   Leonard buys an Estate.
Title: Re: Great Moments in Contraband
Post by: WanderingWinder on September 16, 2011, 07:24:43 pm
This is not uncommon at all (and part of why contraband is generally terrible in 2p).
I think my favourite prohibition was either on curses, when that would have three-piled to end the game with me losing. Unsurprisingly, I think I lost anyway.

Edit: I should note that I mean to say it's not uncommon for an opponent who's bought contraband, which is of course pretty rare itself.