Dominion Strategy Forum
Miscellaneous => Forum Games => Mafia Game Threads => Topic started by: cayvie on December 18, 2012, 11:32:18 pm
-
Welcome to Mafia XVIII: Major Arcana Mafia II
This is the sequel to Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia (http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=3907.0). The game setup is a heavily modified version of Great Idea Mafia (http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Great_Idea_Mafia), for use with a Tarot deck.
Players Signed Up:
1. Eevee
2. yuma
3. Archetype
4. sparky5856
5. AUTO-ROBZ888
6. Lekkit
7. shraeye
8. Ashersky
9. Grujah
10. Voltgloss
11. Insomniac
12. Cuzz
13. jotheonah
14. jimmmmm
15. Galzria
16. Axxle
-----
Replacements:
-----
Backup Mod (I'm V/LA on weekends): Dsell
Sign-ups and Pre-game:
1. This game wants 16-20 players. As soon as 16 players have signed up, there will be a 24-hour window for others to join. Anyone who signs up after this 24-hour window, or after 20 players have signed up, will be put in the replacement queue.
2. Once the sign-up window has closed, I'll send Role PMs. You should confirm receiving your PM in the game thread.
3. The game will officially start when all but three players have confirmed.
-
Setup Info
So here's how this works. This is a Semi-Open setup.
I've divided my Tarot deck into two piles, the Major and Minor Arcana. As seen below, I've assigned specific, fairly traditional Mafia roles to the Minor Arcana. The Major Arcana, however, have been assigned secret abilities that range from "Oh, that's new and interesting" to "What on Earth was that?" in power and strangeness. As figured out last game, all Major Arcana roles have death triggers, that are secret even to themselves. Some Major Arcana are town-aligned, some are Mafia, some are Werewolf, and some are other.
In order to keep the Major Arcana roles feeling appropriately special, I've separated them from the rest of the deck. For every seven players that join the game, one Major Arcana role is added to the setup. After that is done, I deal enough Tarot cards to give everyone a role. In a game in this size range, there will be exactly two Major Arcana.
Minor tweaking is done afterward to ensure some semblance of balance. It usually comes out pretty balanced, but sometimes there's six werewolves out of 16 players and that's just no good.
-
The Deck
Cups
Ace - Lover
Two - Vanilla Townie
Three - Vanilla Townie
Four - Mason
Five - Vengeful Lover
Six - Vanilla Townie
Seven - Cop
Eight - Roleblocker
Nine - Innocent Child
Ten - Lover
Page - Mafia Goon
Knight - Mafia Goon
Queen - Mafia One-Shot Redirector
King - Mafia Watcher
Pentacles
Ace - Mafia-Immune Serial Killer
Two - Vanilla Townie
Three - Vanilla Townie
Four - Mason
Five - One-Shot Strongman Vigilante
Six - Vanilla Townie
Seven - Cop
Eight - Backup
Nine - Jack of all Trades
Ten - Spy
Page - Mafia Goon
Knight - Mafia Goon
Queen - Mafia Roleblocker
King - Mafia Godfather
Wands
Ace - Werewolf-Immune Serial Killer
Two - Vanilla Townie
Three - Vanilla Townie
Four - Mason
Five - One-Shot Day Vigilante
Six - Vanilla Townie
Seven - Seer
Eight - Ninja Doctor
Nine - Bulletproof Townie
Ten - Doctor
Page - Werewolf
Knight - Werewolf
Queen - Werewolf Rolecop
King - Alpha Werewolf
Swords
Ace - Secret Mason
Two - Vanilla Townie
Three - Vanilla Townie
Four - Mason
Five - Hider
Six - Vanilla Townie
Seven - Seer
Eight - Jailkeeper
Nine - FBI Agent
Ten - Vigilante
Page - Werewolf
Knight - Werewolf
Queen - Ninja Werewolf
King - Werewolf One-Shot Dayvig
Major Arcana
0: The Fool
I: The Magician
II: The High Priestess
III: The Empress
IV: The Emperor
V: The Hierophant
VI: The Lovers
VII: The Chariot
VIII: Strength
IX: The Hermit
X: The Wheel of Fortune
XI: Justice
XII: The Hanged Man
XIII: Death
XIV: Temperance
XV: The Devil
XVI: The Tower
XVII: The Star
XVIII: The Moon
XIX: The Sun
XX: Judgment
XXI: The World
-
I'll follow because the last game was awesome, but I think this game is just too big for me.
-
gosh-diddly yes.
-
dibs on the stronger major arcana.
-
I'll follow because the last game was awesome, but I think this game is just too big for me.
want to back-up mod?
-
I'll follow because the last game was awesome, but I think this game is just too big for me.
want to back-up mod?
Yes!
-
I'll follow because the last game was awesome, but I think this game is just too big for me.
Ditto, but more because I don't have time to obsessively read over lots of old posts. Not that it stops most players. ;)
-
/in!
-
Can I get a better role than Vengeful Lover?
-
inininin
Love the setup!
-
Can I get a better role than Vengeful Lover?
does such a thing exist??
-
Holy crap, /in
-
Can I get a better role than Vengeful Lover?
Vengeful Lightning Rod.
I thought about making PGO Lightning Rod once. Everyone targets you. You kill everyone. :)
-
I'll follow because the last game was awesome, but I think this game is just too big for me.
Ditto, but more because I don't have time to obsessively read over lots of old posts. Not that it stops most players. ;)
zing. i'm okay at calling scum teams early though.
-
AUTO-IN PLEASE.
-
Can I get a better role than Vengeful Lover?
is this an /in?
hey, want a true story from last game?
last time around, you were complaining mildly about always getting vanilla or worse roles. so when i was picking roles, i came to you, and drew VT. i felt a little bad, so i decided to give you another chance, and gave that role to the next player on the list (i think it was shraeye). then i drew again for you, and got lover--and you wound up being the only lover in the game. it was hilarious.
-
I've no time for this!
I've no time for anything!
Bah!
In.
-
Can I get a better role than Vengeful Lover?
is this an /in?
hey, want a true story from last game?
last time around, you were complaining mildly about always getting vanilla or worse roles. so when i was picking roles, i came to you, and drew VT. i felt a little bad, so i decided to give you another chance, and gave that role to the next player on the list (i think it was shraeye). then i drew again for you, and got lover--and you wound up being the only lover in the game. it was hilarious.
Making the most of a one-sided lover WAS a real challenge. It's hard knowing someone is so good inside, but that feeling isn't reciprocated. Still...
Bah!
-
Even if I feel very busy, I must play. Arcana I was my intro-game here and I loved it. Sign me up for round 2.
-
I was just going to tag to follow.
But, werewolves. /in
-
I was freaking awesome last time (my own assessment), even though I've actually replaced in... /in.
-
Also, claiming Hierophant now.
-
/out. too big for me.
-
(http://i.qkme.me/3s97w6.jpg)
/in
-
In if there is room and volt doesn't draw sk :p
-
I call for a suitclaim!
-
Hey I heard the first version of this was fun.
/in
-
Would suck to get a VT in this set up! haha
-
Would suck to get a VT in this set up! haha
is that an /in?
-
Would suck to get a VT in this set up! haha
is that an /in?
Ozle likes to pretend that he actually has a life. At least we don't fool ourselves. But he "claims" to be too busy to play with us.
Besides, he's got Treasure to find!
-
Would suck to get a VT in this set up! haha
is that an /in?
Nope sorry, would not have the required time
-
PM me when the 24 hour signup window opens. I want to get in this but depends on start time.
-
I'm going to /out.
We'll see when it's closer to launching.
-
I'm going to /out.
We'll see when it's closer to launching.
sad face :( , followed by a slightly optimistic and hopeful face....there just isn't a good emoticon for slightly optimistic and hopeful
-
I'm going to /out.
We'll see when it's closer to launching.
sad face :( , followed by a slightly optimistic and hopeful face....there just isn't a good emoticon for slightly optimistic and hopeful
Is there a good actual expression for that?
-
hopeful?
-
hopeful?
/in?
-
I'm going to /out.
We'll see when it's closer to launching.
sad face :( , followed by a slightly optimistic and hopeful face....there just isn't a good emoticon for slightly optimistic and hopeful
(http://www.emofaces.com/en/emoticons/f/fingers-crossed-emoticon.gif)
-
/in for now at least. :)
-
I'm going to /out.
We'll see when it's closer to launching.
sad face :( , followed by a slightly optimistic and hopeful face....there just isn't a good emoticon for slightly optimistic and hopeful
(http://www.emofaces.com/en/emoticons/f/fingers-crossed-emoticon.gif)
exactly, Galz that emoticon is directed to you... you can even make it your avatar if you want...
but seriously, no pressure to play, but I really do like playing mafia games with you.
-
was very fun to follow the last one as co-mod. i do believe I'll play this time.
-
Well I've gone from being in 3 games to 0 in about 2 days, so I guess I can /in.
-
With theory or Galz this is full, I think. Yay!
-
Oh goodness. I've way too much going on. I'm honestly confusing games at this point, and forgetting others are going on until I see the "new post" tag.
But what the hell.
In.
I didn't expect a full, 12 player game with 4 scum, to end before N3.
-
I said "hopeful" as a suggestion to Axxle, not as an intent to play.
-
/in
-
okay!
wow, that filled up.
24-hour window starts now.
i'll send out pms december 26, i think--don't want to start on christmas eve or christmas.
-
okay!
wow, that filled up.
24-hour window starts now.
i'll send out pms december 26, i think--don't want to start on christmas eve or christmas.
You could send them out on Christmas, like individually wrapped little presents!
..... You know, if you like, don't have a life and want to be on the forums on the 25th.
-
ha, no life
no, i'll be working on christmas
-
Oh goodness. I've way too much going on. I'm honestly confusing games at this point, and forgetting others are going on until I see the "new post" tag.
But what the hell.
In.
I didn't expect a full, 12 player game with 4 scum, to end before N3.
Which game was that?
-
ash's Buffy game (Tabula Rasa).
-
ash's Buffy game (Tabula Rasa).
Someone should start writing game summaries for past games. I don't really want to read through the whole thread, and even skimming the end game stuff doesn't really help much. I note that the title says the town won flawlessly. How's that?
-
ash's Buffy game (Tabula Rasa).
Someone should start writing game summaries for past games. I don't really want to read through the whole thread, and even skimming the end game stuff doesn't really help much. I note that the title says the town won flawlessly. How's that?
We won in the fewest possible number of days (although one death too many):
D1: Lynch Mafia
N1: Mafia kill Doctored, SK kill hits town
D2: SK lynch
N2: Mafia kill hits, Vig kills Mafia.
D3 Lynch Mafia
3 Mafia, 1 SK, 2 Town dead.
---
To do it in fewer:
D1: Lynch Mafia
N1: Doctor Mafia Kill, SK hits Mafia
D2: Lynch SK
N2: Vig Kills Mafia, Mafia kill hits
---
Without the SK hitting Mafia:
D1: Lynch SK
N1: Doctor Mafia Kill
D2: Lynch Mafia
N2: Vig Mafia, Mafia NK
D3: Lynch Mafia
---
So we never mislynched, and won in the fewest number of days assuming the SK doesn't hit scum. We could've technically gotten 1 fewer town deaths. But it's flawless because we never missed a lynch, and had the fewest nights possible.
Note: Both Vig and Doc were 1-shot.
-
More info: how was such accuracy achieved? Did scum make serious slips?
-
More info: how was such accuracy achieved? Did scum make serious slips?
eHal, I think it was quite comparable to the first few days of XI, which you were a part of. The mafia weren't necessarily slipping, they were just being kind of scummy, voting/defending in a scummy way, and not posting enough. It just snowballed out of control for scum.
I was the Doctor, and I successfully WIFOMed the mafia on their night kill ;D
-
It was closer than it appears though. We were REALLY close to lynching a townie day 1 and day 1mafia lynches are super bad for them. Town got really lucky with the sk hitting mafia. Cuzz flipping SK still feels like a lucky break to me, we hunted him down ny looking for mafia-y interactions.
-
FYI I'll be VLA until around the end of the 26th forum time, I believe, maybe even until some time on the 27th. I shouldn't miss the start by too much if at all, and I don't think I'll be the only one busy during this time.
-
It was closer than it appears though. We were REALLY close to lynching a townie day 1 and day 1mafia lynches are super bad for them. Town got really lucky with the sk hitting mafia. Cuzz flipping SK still feels like a lucky break to me, we hunted him down ny looking for mafia-y interactions.
Galz says SK hit town?
Anyway, thanks for the summary. Probably should stop polluting this game thread. :)
-
You should /in!
-
yeah you should, PMs going out tonight, thread opening tomorrow probz?
-
Yay!
-
ok signups actually closed now. drawing cards.
-
I should probably say this:
Thread Locked
-
http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=6168.msg163612#msg163612 will be the game thread for this game when it is open.
i guess this thread can be unlocked.