Dominion Strategy Forum
Dominion => Rules Questions => Topic started by: vishwathg on August 28, 2018, 11:34:01 pm
-
Hey, I found this place again! Anyways:
What exactly are "the trashed cards?" For example, say my opponent's Noble Brigand flips two Estates and I gain a Copper. I use a Watchtower to trash the Copper. Must my opponent gain the Copper? (Probably not, but just making sure.)
-
You gain the cards that were trashed as a result of playing Noble Brigand, not from any other effect.
-
A+ for creativity though.
-
A+ for creativity though.
I don't know if that's quite fair. I think it's reasonable to wonder if any cards trashed during the "window" of Noble Brigand's execution would be gained.
-
A+ for creativity though.
I don't know if that's quite fair. I think it's reasonable to wonder if any cards trashed during the "window" of Noble Brigand's execution would be gained.
Oh I didn't mean it to sound condescending or anything. I just wouldn't have thought about possible Copper junking with Watchtower. It would be kind of neat if it worked that way.
-
A+ for creativity though.
I don't know if that's quite fair. I think it's reasonable to wonder if any cards trashed during the "window" of Noble Brigand's execution would be gained.
Oh I didn't mean it to sound condescending or anything. I just wouldn't have thought about possible Copper junking with Watchtower. It would be kind of neat if it worked that way.
You could also reveal a Beggar, trashing the two Silvers with your Watchtower, then reveal your Diplomat (you still have five cards in hand because they played a Council Room earlier), discarding some Tunnels, trashing the received Golds with Watchtower, and then when the attack rolls around, you reveal a Market Square when your treasure is trashed to get a Gold, then reveal a Trader to get a Silver instead, then reveal your Watchtower to trash it, and then reveal another Market Square to get another Gold, then trash that with your Watchtower, reveal another Market Square, then topdeck that Gold it with your Watchtower.
What happens then?
-
A+ for creativity though.
I don't know if that's quite fair. I think it's reasonable to wonder if any cards trashed during the "window" of Noble Brigand's execution would be gained.
Oh I didn't mean it to sound condescending or anything. I just wouldn't have thought about possible Copper junking with Watchtower. It would be kind of neat if it worked that way.
You could also reveal a Beggar, trashing the two Silvers with your Watchtower, then reveal your Diplomat (you still have five cards in hand because they played a Council Room earlier), discarding some Tunnels, trashing the received Golds with Watchtower, and then when the attack rolls around, you reveal a Market Square when your treasure is trashed to get a Gold, then reveal a Trader to get a Silver instead, then reveal your Watchtower to trash it, and then reveal another Market Square to get another Gold, then trash that with your Watchtower, reveal another Market Square, then topdeck that Gold it with your Watchtower.
What happens then?
Yu-Gi-Oh theme music starts playing in the background as you dramatically point to Bandit Fort and laugh.
-
You could also reveal a Beggar, trashing the two Silvers with your Watchtower, then reveal your Diplomat (you still have five cards in hand because they played a Council Room earlier), discarding some Tunnels, trashing the received Golds with Watchtower, and then when the attack rolls around, you reveal a Market Square when your treasure is trashed to get a Gold, then reveal a Trader to get a Silver instead, then reveal your Watchtower to trash it, and then reveal another Market Square to get another Gold, then trash that with your Watchtower, reveal another Market Square, then topdeck that Gold it with your Watchtower.
What happens then?
What was the middle thing?
-
You could also reveal a Beggar, trashing the two Silvers with your Watchtower, then reveal your Diplomat (you still have five cards in hand because they played a Council Room earlier), discarding some Tunnels, trashing the received Golds with Watchtower, and then when the attack rolls around, you reveal a Market Square when your treasure is trashed to get a Gold, then reveal a Trader to get a Silver instead, then reveal your Watchtower to trash it, and then reveal another Market Square to get another Gold, then trash that with your Watchtower, reveal another Market Square, then topdeck that Gold it with your Watchtower.
What happens then?
What was the middle thing?
?
-
You could also reveal a Beggar, trashing the two Silvers with your Watchtower, then reveal your Diplomat (you still have five cards in hand because they played a Council Room earlier), discarding some Tunnels, trashing the received Golds with Watchtower, and then when the attack rolls around, you reveal a Market Square when your treasure is trashed to get a Gold, then reveal a Trader to get a Silver instead, then reveal your Watchtower to trash it, and then reveal another Market Square to get another Gold, then trash that with your Watchtower, reveal another Market Square, then topdeck that Gold it with your Watchtower.
What happens then?
What was the middle thing?
?
What was the middle thing?