Dominion Strategy Forum
Dominion => Dominion General Discussion => Topic started by: Beyond Awesome on September 16, 2017, 02:01:04 am
-
Hey guys,
Well, here it is, the first episode of The Outpost. I admit, I'm fairly new to the Podcast thing, so any constructive criticism is welcome. This week Seprix hosted, but we will be interchanging who leads each week. The goal is to also have a special guest each week from the Dominion Community. I am talking with someone right now, but they haven't been locked in yet. It's a matter of everyone's schedules meshing together. Anyway, without further ado, here is the Podcast. https://dominionstrategy.com/2017/09/16/the-outpost-a-dominion-podcast-the-beginning/ (https://dominionstrategy.com/2017/09/16/the-outpost-a-dominion-podcast-the-beginning/)
-
hey guys!
Listened to it, it's very cool, hope to be your guest one day ;)
Improvement-wise, I think that it would be much better if some quiet wordless music would play in the background, Seprix has this stuff, I know :)
-
It's a good start and I look forward to more. My main suggestion would be to give the full details of a card before discussing it. I listen to several X-Wing miniatures podcasts, and this is something almost everyone forgets to do. The podcasters and many of their listeners will know what everything does, yes, but those who don't are completely in the dark and the podcast fails to shed light for much of its audience (and worse, they don't back for more).
-
Is this available via standard podcast apps?
-
hey guys!
Listened to it, it's very cool, hope to be your guest one day ;)
Improvement-wise, I think that it would be much better if some quiet wordless music would play in the background, Seprix has this stuff, I know :)
I object. I've never listened to a podcast with background music and I don't intend to start.
I already commented at length on Discord. summary: I like it, keep it up and make small improvements.
-
I think the podcast would have more audience if it were shorter, I'am a bit discouraged by this 50min lenght (however, I'm not the main audience since I do not understand english very well, especially listening)
-
I think the podcast would have more audience if it were shorter, I'am a bit discouraged by this 50min lenght (however, I'm not the main audience since I do not understand english very well, especially listening)
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
-
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
I agree, but then I think YouTube is a bad delivery service. Not everyone has mobile data or has WiFi on their commutes, so I think it's important that it's easy to be able to download the podcast and listen to it offline
-
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
I agree, but then I think YouTube is a bad delivery service. Not everyone has mobile data or has WiFi on their commutes, so I think it's important that it's easy to be able to download the podcast and listen to it offline
I think podcasts are meant to be lengthy and fill the role of detailed in-depth discussion that some people seek but have trouble finding due to lack of people willing to supply it. 50 minutes for a podcast actually seems like it's on the short side.
The long length of a podcast is probably not ideal for a large chunk of the playerbase. I think I've seen podcasts be accompanied by an abridged version of it or even a completely separate summary video or else a shorter video inspired by the discussion of the podcast.
-
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
I agree, but then I think YouTube is a bad delivery service. Not everyone has mobile data or has WiFi on their commutes, so I think it's important that it's easy to be able to download the podcast and listen to it offline
It is easy to be able to download YouTube videos (or just the audio if you want that).
-
This looks really cool!
-
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
I agree, but then I think YouTube is a bad delivery service. Not everyone has mobile data or has WiFi on their commutes, so I think it's important that it's easy to be able to download the podcast and listen to it offline
It is easy to be able to download YouTube videos (or just the audio if you want that).
I did download the podcast to listen to it, but I shouldn't have to go to another site or use other software to make a podcast listenable for me. Also, if it's so easy, then my suggestion to make the podcast also available in a downloadable audio format should be easy for BA or Seprix to implement, too. And this isn't even considering the extra level of convenience that would come with integration into iTunes, Google Play, or other similar services. That might be a bit more difficult, though; I don't know.
I may have been too harsh on YouTube podcasts in my original comment, but I think it's a reasonable suggestion that they should consider multiple formats.
-
I shouldn't have to go to another site or use other software to make a podcast listenable for me.
Regardless of where they upload it, you will have to go to that site (i.e. another site) to download it.
-
Just remember who you're talking to tripwire, and remember it's not worth it.
-
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
I agree, but then I think YouTube is a bad delivery service. Not everyone has mobile data or has WiFi on their commutes, so I think it's important that it's easy to be able to download the podcast and listen to it offline
It is easy to be able to download YouTube videos (or just the audio if you want that).
I did download the podcast to listen to it, but I shouldn't have to go to another site or use other software to make a podcast listenable for me. Also, if it's so easy, then my suggestion to make the podcast also available in a downloadable audio format should be easy for BA or Seprix to implement, too. And this isn't even considering the extra level of convenience that would come with integration into iTunes, Google Play, or other similar services. That might be a bit more difficult, though; I don't know.
I may have been too harsh on YouTube podcasts in my original comment, but I think it's a reasonable suggestion that they should consider multiple formats.
Yeah I think it's fine to have it primarily in video format, but if I can't get the audio via Overcast or whatever it's probably a no go for me. Otherwise I'm not really sure it's a podcast, which is fine, but then just call it a youtube channel.
-
Yeah I think it's fine to have it primarily in video format, but if I can't get the audio via Overcast or whatever it's probably a no go for me. Otherwise I'm not really sure it's a podcast, which is fine, but then just call it a youtube channel.
I agree with this. There are several podcasts I listen to that are just the audio of a video show. While my preference is for podcasts that are designed to be audio-only, these audio-from-video versions are usually pretty good.
But yeah, if it's not somewhere my podcatcher will see it (in this case, the iOS Podcasts app and iTunes), there's less than a 1% chance I'll ever listen to it.
-
I liked it, and I'm really excited to listen to each new one. Good work!
-
Re: the recent episode with Dan Brooks.
Funkdoc coined the name "WeedGoku69" in describing his opponents. Seprix is innocent!
hello, kind of a long story here but i thought this was interesting and worth discussing...
so sometimes i can't find anybody within 1000 rating points of me, and i just set matchmaking to play anyone. a lot of these people will gain you like 5 points if you win and cost you like 80 if you lose, and dominion is a swingy enough game that your MF rating will drop like a rock if you play enough of these folks.
however, even on my worst losing streaks to these players, my iso rating wouldn't drop much at all! i'd always remain quite a bit higher than i was at my lowest points when i was just playing evenly-matched opponents. i suspect this is because i was still winning a much higher % of games overall, and perhaps you could argue that's a better way of doing it. it just doesn't feel right to me that if i cared about nothing but iso, i should dodge Titandrake and spend all night playing against WeedGoku69. i'm curious if others have noticed this and if i'm alone in feeling this way...
-
Newest episode is up.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JK40yqGZ2ws
-
It's a good start and I look forward to more. My main suggestion would be to give the full details of a card before discussing it. I listen to several X-Wing miniatures podcasts, and this is something almost everyone forgets to do. The podcasters and many of their listeners will know what everything does, yes, but those who don't are completely in the dark and the podcast fails to shed light for much of its audience (and worse, they don't back for more).
I'm listening to a Sliders podcast, and it IS nice how they briefly do a recap of the episode they're going to talk about, eventually covering more details as it goes underway.
Before I memorized most of the cards, I would use Jack Of All Dominion (for Android) as a card reference guide so I'd know what folks were talking about.
I think the podcast would have more audience if it were shorter, I'am a bit discouraged by this 50min lenght (however, I'm not the main audience since I do not understand english very well, especially listening)
Curious... what would be your ideal length?
For me, 20 to 75 minutes usually does it for me. Shorter is nicer in being able to finish it more easily, although I do just whip out my PDA and "set a bookmark" there if I need to resume from the same episode/track. Too short, and it's too much downloading.
-
Have you guys made any more moves towards getting the podcast up on the iTunes store (where basically all podcast apps can get it from?) I love podcasts to listen to on commutes and in the lab off of my phone but I'm never going to sit in front of a computer and listen to an hour+ podcast on youtube.
-
Have you guys made any more moves towards getting the podcast up on the iTunes store (where basically all podcast apps can get it from?) I love podcasts to listen to on commutes and in the lab off of my phone but I'm never going to sit in front of a computer and listen to an hour+ podcast on youtube.
This. As an avid podcast listener and sometimes Dominion player, I'm very much in the market for this, but not if I have to go on Youtube for it.
-
Another thing that some longer shows do which is sometimes nice is to give a brief rundown of topics discussed with the corresponding time stamps in the episode notes. That way you know where to skip to if you want to hear just one particular portion of the episode.
-
Another thing that some longer shows do which is sometimes nice is to give a brief rundown of topics discussed with the corresponding time stamps in the episode notes. That way you know where to skip to if you want to hear just one particular portion of the episode.
I like this. I for one enjoy how long they are, and I'd still listen even if it was a 2 hour podcast. With this idea, it can be good for everyone, whether they want it long or short.
-
I just watched the 4th episode and I think while you mentioned the artist's website, it's not linked aynwhere.
I think you should include such a link in the description.
-
It's linked on the blog.
-
Newest episode is up. This week, we interviewed DougZ. https://dominionstrategy.com/2017/10/22/the-outpost-episode-5-dougz-and-the-holy-relic-of-isotropic/ (https://dominionstrategy.com/2017/10/22/the-outpost-episode-5-dougz-and-the-holy-relic-of-isotropic/)
-
Newest episode is up, discussing the Nocturne Preview cards. https://dominionstrategy.com/2017/11/03/the-outpost-a-dominion-podcast-nocturne-previews/ (https://dominionstrategy.com/2017/11/03/the-outpost-a-dominion-podcast-nocturne-previews/)
-
How come I cannot find it on iTunes or Overcast yet? I really want to listen to it!
-
This won't be a part of my life until i can play it in my car without using a web browser on my phone. Has such a moment occured? I'll install the nichest of apps.
-
This won't be a part of my life until i can play it in my car without using a web browser on my phone. Has such a moment occured? I'll install the nichest of apps.
You can use a youtube-to-mp3 site to get mp3's of the podcasts, and put those on your phone.
-
This won't be a part of my life until i can play it in my car without using a web browser on my phone. Has such a moment occured? I'll install the nichest of apps.
You can use a youtube-to-mp3 site to get mp3's of the podcasts, and put those on your phone.
This is 300% too much work; most people don’t even regularly sync their phones with their computers anymore.
That said, if you have YouTube Red, you can at least play the podcast in the background. It won’t save your place like podcasting apps, but it is barely tolerable.
I agree this needs to be a real podcast and on real podcast providers soon, there just needs to be a place to host mp3s and an RSS feed.
-
Haven't started listening yet, but I will soon, so I hope there are more episodes to come!
Why haven't I already been listening, and what is changing that? My answer to the first part is the same as many others'....
Is this available via standard podcast apps?
While normal videos should certainly aim to be short, the audience for podcasts typically wants something lengthy, as they listen to them during long commutes or work.
I agree, but then I think YouTube is a bad delivery service. Not everyone has mobile data or has WiFi on their commutes, so I think it's important that it's easy to be able to download the podcast and listen to it offline
It is easy to be able to download YouTube videos (or just the audio if you want that).
I did download the podcast to listen to it, but I shouldn't have to go to another site or use other software to make a podcast listenable for me. Also, if it's so easy, then my suggestion to make the podcast also available in a downloadable audio format should be easy for BA or Seprix to implement, too. And this isn't even considering the extra level of convenience that would come with integration into iTunes, Google Play, or other similar services. That might be a bit more difficult, though; I don't know.
I may have been too harsh on YouTube podcasts in my original comment, but I think it's a reasonable suggestion that they should consider multiple formats.
Yeah I think it's fine to have it primarily in video format, but if I can't get the audio via Overcast or whatever it's probably a no go for me. Otherwise I'm not really sure it's a podcast, which is fine, but then just call it a youtube channel.
I agree with this. There are several podcasts I listen to that are just the audio of a video show. While my preference is for podcasts that are designed to be audio-only, these audio-from-video versions are usually pretty good.
But yeah, if it's not somewhere my podcatcher will see it (in this case, the iOS Podcasts app and iTunes), there's less than a 1% chance I'll ever listen to it.
Have you guys made any more moves towards getting the podcast up on the iTunes store (where basically all podcast apps can get it from?) I love podcasts to listen to on commutes and in the lab off of my phone but I'm never going to sit in front of a computer and listen to an hour+ podcast on youtube.
This. As an avid podcast listener and sometimes Dominion player, I'm very much in the market for this, but not if I have to go on Youtube for it.
How come I cannot find it on iTunes or Overcast yet? I really want to listen to it!
This won't be a part of my life until i can play it in my car without using a web browser on my phone. Has such a moment occured? I'll install the nichest of apps.
I agree this needs to be a real podcast and on real podcast providers soon, there just needs to be a place to host mp3s and an RSS feed.
Today I had a great idea for a website I could build: you could enter a YouTube channel URL, and then the site would convert the channel feed into a podcast feed. Now, many of my ideas only go as far as a half-baked bit of code on my computer that takes hours to get up and running when I return to develop it further after the initial burst and I've forgotten how any of it works, and most of the rest of my ideas are things that actually already exist. Fortunately for all of us, this was the latter.
I found podsync.net, and got a URL for the podcast that I was able to load into the Apple Podcasts app with the "Add a Podcast by URL..." feature, so hopefully this works with Overcast and other podcast apps too.
https://podsync.net/k7oYrtcSS
The feed at this URL does consist of full videos--so mobile users may still want to take care to not use cellular data when downloading episodes via the podsync link--but playing only the audio with the screen off works just fine on my iPhone.
-
From both camps...
If your answer is to "just download it", then a suggestion may be in order. Some of them do NOT let you download clips more than 10 to 20 minutes due to copyright reasons.
If you'd like for the podcast to host its own files, then a suggestion on some sites and tools may be in order as well. YouTube may not be convenient for us to download, but they do make it easier for those that want to upload content.